Who's for President 2025? Any takers?

Can't the president refuse to sign any legislation which he/she thinks is contrary to the constitution?
The bill would be referred back to the Dail for changes
The President can call a Council of State to get advice on constitutionality
Legislation can be referred to the Supreme Court

So, some power ...

Anyone remember this....

"The President's "sin" was to refer the Government's tough new anti-terrorist emergency powers legislation to the Supreme Court to test its constitutionality."
 
A bunch of councils are deciding today whether to nominate a candidate. Kerry have nominated Gareth Sheridan.
The support of four councils is needed to get on the ballot.

Laois, Westmeath and Kildare are among the local authorities hearing from candidates this afternoon, with city councils in Galway, Cork and Dublin convening later. Nine councils are mulling their position on whether to back any candidate for the Áras today on what has been dubbed ‘Super Monday’.

 
Can't the president refuse to sign any legislation which he/she thinks is contrary to the constitution?
The bill would be referred back to the Dail for changes
The President can call a Council of State to get advice on constitutionality
Legislation can be referred to the Supreme Court

The President must call a Council of State meeting before referring the legislation to the SC, and any such referral (which is exclusively the President's decision) must occur within 7 days of him/her getting the legislation to sign. (Article 26.)

Addendum: I wasn't familiar with Article 27 which (in summary) states that:

A majority of the members of Seanad Éireann and not less than one-third of the members of Dáil Éireann may by a joint petition addressed to the President by them request the President to decline to sign and promulgate as a law any Bill to which this Article applies on the ground that the Bill contains a proposal of such national importance that the will of the people thereon ought to be ascertained.

If the President (after consulting with the Council of State) agrees with the petition then he/she can write back to the Taoiseach and formally refuse to sign the bill - in this case a referendum should take place.

Rather difficult to imagine that ever happening , but who can say what the future may bring.
 
The President must call a Council of State meeting before referring the legislation to the SC, and any such referral (which is exclusively the President's decision) must occur within 7 days of him/her getting the legislation to sign. (Article 26.)

Addendum: I wasn't familiar with Article 27 which (in summary) states that:

A majority of the members of Seanad Éireann and not less than one-third of the members of Dáil Éireann may by a joint petition addressed to the President by them request the President to decline to sign and promulgate as a law any Bill to which this Article applies on the ground that the Bill contains a proposal of such national importance that the will of the people thereon ought to be ascertained.

If the President (after consulting with the Council of State) agrees with the petition then he/she can write back to the Taoiseach and formally refuse to sign the bill - in this case a referendum should take place.

Rather difficult to imagine that ever happening , but who can say what the future may bring.
In this country the People, through their Parliament, are sovereign. It is therefore appropriate that all real political power resides in that Parliament. The President,or the Seanad, should now easily or freely be able to check that power.
 
Gavin answering too many "political" questions already. Would be better off saying he is going to de-politicise the role and just be a president to represent the country as was intended. further and further every day
going back at this stage is as difficult as continuing forward, Jim admires Michael D work, I can think of one Dublin Vote he will not be getting,;)
 
Last edited:
From The Journal:

Laois, Roscommon, Galway City, Longford, Cork City and Dublin City Council all voted in favour of motions not to back any Áras hopefuls...

Dublin City Council: After hearing from the candidates this evening, 50 councillors voted in favour of not backing any of them. Nine councillors voted to nominate a candidate.
 
Hardly equivalent.
I'd agree - the 10-15 would have been selected form a large pile of cv's and thus would have had several attributes that would have made them possible candidates for the position.

Whereas the motley crew that presented to the councils....
 
Whereas the motley crew that presented to the councils....
Why do you label Maria Steen a motley crew ? Her ideas may not fit yours but entitled to have her voice heard without derogatory comments like that. Are people afraid of the level of support she may get from the public ?
 
Why do you label Maria Steen a motley crew ?
I don't think she can play or sing so she shouldn't be counted with that band.
I'd like to see her run. I wouldn't like to see her win but there's far worse out there and a conservative voice as a balance against the liberal establishment (which I largely agree with) would be a good thing.
 
Why do you label Maria Steen a motley crew ?
In relation to being President of Ireland, I simply don't see her suitability.

If she wanted to run as a political candidate in a general election and represent a certain view. That's no issue.
 
Back
Top