Moneymakeover What to do ... A Fortunate Problem.

Agricola

New Member
Messages
7
Personal details

Your age: 55
Your spouse's age: 60
Number and age of children: 3 - all in their late 20s, all working


Income and expenditure
Annual gross income from employment or profession: €120K
Annual gross income of spouse/partner: c. €23K (Public Sector Pension)

Monthly take-home pay: €6K between my salary and wife's pension -

I save €500 into a Zurich Savings Plan each month, pay Revenue €650 per month to ensure I don't have to pay a lump sum for tax liabilities and to cover property tax, put another €1300 into savings and spend approx €1200 per month on shopping/utilites/health insurance etc.

Type of employment - Employed
Employer type: Public servant

I save more than I spend


Summary of Assets and Liabilities
Family home value: €400K
Mortgage on family home: None
I have another property, value about €400K, not let-out just sitting there in case one of my adult children would like to buy it/move into it etc. and I'm happy with that as I bought it for €100k less than that

Cash: Approximately €610K in various deposit accounts. I know this makes no sense from an investment/inflation point of view, though I do try to move the money between various banks so as to get the highest interest rate available.

I have €160k in a Zurich Special Savings Plus Matrix Plan

I have €72K in an AVC to use so as to max out my final lump sum amount, but I stopped making AVC contributions years ago

My wife has an ARF with Zurich of approximately €20K

Defined Contribution pension fund: I can retire in a couple of years and will get a pension of approximately €50K per year, as I am a public servant, and I will get a lump sum of approximately €170K

Company shares : I bought €3.5 k of shares in Bank of Ireland and €3.5 in another company in 2007 - I never sold any. BofI are worthless now, but when I last looked at my holding in this other company, the shares are now worth c. €23K. I really didn't/don't know, or at least know very little, about shares and investments so this was a warning to me - hence my cautious approach thereafter!

I also do part-time work outside of my main employment which generates c. €12K annually before tax etc. As a Sole Trader for this employment I usually pay c. €7k pa in liabilites to Revenue for income earned from this work and interest earned abroad on money on deposit.

We have no loans/debts.

Other savings and investments:
I have €28K in Prize Bonds - waiting to win the top prize which I don't think will actually happen!

Other information which might be relevant

I also do part-time work outside of my main employment which generates c. €12K annually before tax etc. As a Sole Trader for this employment I usually pay c. €7k pa in liabilites to Revenue for income earned from this work and interest earned abroad on money on deposit.

What specific question do you have or what issues are of concern to you?
I have two key questions please.

1) Ihave an opportunity to buy a property near me for €270k from a sibling who wishes to sell it. The sibling lives abroad, has had the property for 20 years, used it as a holiday home, but now no longer wants it. The property is vacant. I am toying with the idea of buying this as it would probably be worth more (not a huge amount, c.€20K) on the open market but the sibling doesn't want the hassle of dealing with estate agents, clearing out the house etc. If I was to buy it, I think I would want to rent it out in order to make a return on the investment, but I read so much about how difficult about it is to be a landlord (as in everything seems to favour the tenant) that I'm a bit wary of being caught in a nightmare scenario, but then again I hear of tenants who are good and keep the property and pay the rent on time, etc. so I guess it's a lottery. I am also open to leave it sit there for a year and see what might happen re house prices, if legislation changes so as not to drive so many landlords out of the rental market, might dispose of it to one of my children etc.

2) What do I do with my cash (irrespective of whether or not I buy the house in 1 above)? I know enough to know that I probably need to diversify and have a portfolio but for someone like me, who doesn't really like risk what might be the best options? Or who best would advise (thanks in advance to those here who will do so). I would love to invest in some ethical funds that might help those who are less well off, but don't know if they exist. Would it be a feasible idea to loan the money to my childen in lieu of a mortage (one already has a mortage) so as to help them become a bit more financially independent? I don't belive in handouts for them and that they need to learn to manage their money and be responsible for it.

Finally, I know that the best thing is to spend the money, but both my wife and I have a relatively simple lifestyle - we do go away on holidays etc. but we thankfully have more than we need, which is a very fortunate position to be in.
 
You have €800K in property, €610K in cash, a good income and generous pension cover. Buying yet another property would be madness in my opinion. You would be better off selling the property that's lying idle and a drain on your finances once maintenance and other fixed costs (e.g. vacant home tax = 7 times the LPT, insurance, utilities etc.) are accounted for. And then invest a good chunk of the resulting c. €1M of cash into a diversified basket of shares.
Your pensions are basically guaranteed annuities that give you a lot of flexibility and ability to ride out any volatility that arises with any equity investments. You might also want to consider using the small gift exemption to make tax efficient gifts to your children (and spouses and grandchildren if applicable).

Minor issue, how is your net household income only €6K p.m. when, by my rough calculations, it should be more like €8K?

BTW if your sibling sells the property to you at a discount to the fair market value then there could be tax implications for either or both of you.

What is your actual annual household expenditure these days?
 
Last edited:
You should divert your Zurich €500 per month (or more if you can afford it) into an AVC PRSA. You will get 40% tax relief on these AVCs. When you retire you can set up an ARF and you have scope to drawdown income from this at 20% tax when you cease public sector employment.

Are you pre 95 public sector?

If you are, ARF drawdowns after your cease public sector employment can gain you Reckonable class S Prsi contributions and allow you to qualify for a portion of the COAP.

Read these threads.

 
Last edited:
Some official rules that bear on your questions (no view here on which funds to pick):

Lump sum: Revenue's page on retirement lump sums says the tax-free amount is a lifetime €200,000 from all sources, with €200,001 to €500,000 taxed at 20%. A €170,000 lump sum is inside that, but the limit counts all lump sums together, so if the €72,000 AVC is used to top up the lump sum, the combined total is what is tested.

Helping the children: the small gift exemption is €3,000 a year from each person to each person, and those gifts don't count towards the lifetime thresholds. You and your wife giving each of three children €3,000 each comes to €18,000 a year tax-free.

Lending instead: Revenue treats an interest-free loan as a gift each year equal to the deposit interest the money could earn, less any interest paid. Its examples use 2%, so a €150,000 interest-free loan from one parent is a deemed gift of €3,000 a year, which uses up that parent's small gift exemption for that child. Revenue also has separate filing rules for family loans.

Shares: selling the holding now worth about €23,000, bought for €3,500, gives a gain of €19,500. After the €1,270 annual exemption, CGT at 31% (disposals from 7 October 2026) is about €5,651. A loss realised on the Bank of Ireland shares in the same year would come off the gain first.
 
I have another property, value about €400K, not let-out just sitting there in case one of my adult children would like to buy it/move into it etc. and I'm happy with that as I bought it for €100k less than that

1) Ihave an opportunity to buy a property near me for €270k from a sibling who wishes to sell it. .... I am also open to leave it sit there for a year and see what might happen re house prices,

It does not matter if you paid €300k or €500k for the first house (apart from some small CGT implications). It is worth €400k today and what is the best use for it?

If your children have not expressed any interest in it, then you should sell it or rent it out. It seems wrong to leave a house empty with the crisis we are in at the moment. I know that the crisis is not of your making and has been made worse by anti-landlord policy, but it still seems wrong.

If you children might want it at some stage in the future, then keep it, but rent it out.

Yes, you could run into problems with the tenant. But it's not a lottery. You can take steps to reduce the risk. You also can't be generous and must charge the absolute maximum rent. And if things go wrong, you are not depending on it. You can afford a tenant who pays no rent or which takes you a year to leave.

So hold onto the property and rent it out.
 
If your children are unlikely to want the second property , don't buy it. The potential profit of €20k will disappear in transaction costs.

It is better to keep the cash in a liquid investment so that when one of your children sees a house which they actually want, you can help them to buy it. If all your money is tied up in empty property, you won't be able to help them.

And maybe that is a question you should ask. Rather than buy a property because it's near you, how about investing in a property that your kids might actually want to live in? Are they living with you at present. If you are in a rural location, and the three of them are working in the city and renting, maybe buy a property in the city and rent it to them?
 
Whatever about the other decisions is the house you are thinking of buying vacant 2 yrs? If so you could apply for the grant to do it up and then rent it out.
 
Unless one of your children will need the second property in the near future, I would sell it. You have seen all the threads here on the risks of being a landlord. Old timers are getting out. It really isn't something for first timer with no experience. A mistake picking a tenant can result in no rent for years while you grind through the long, stressful and expensive RTB process. And that's before the political risks such as a rent freeze or another eviction ban.

The tenant will have a 6 year tenancy. In theory if a child needs it in the meantime, you can get it back. But again as discussed on other threads, that is just in theory. If the tenant overholds, there is little you can do but take them to the RTB and hope for the best.

Same goes for the second property. As another poster pointed out, the €20k discount will rapidly disappear in fees, costs, repairs and improvements. In any event, do you really want to double your hassle and risks. You're now renting out two properties.
 
Thanks to all for your replies on a Sunday afternoon. Your committment to advise is to be applauded!!

Minor issue, how is your net household income only €6K p.m. when, by my rough calculations, it should be more like €8K?
Yes, we get about €6k per month but mayber where I skewed the figures it that my wife currently gets a pension of about €13k this year, I belive and hope as a PRSI Class A worker she will get a supplementary pension which will bring her up to about €23K


What is your actual annual household expenditure these days?
We save about €1800 per month, pay Revenue about €650 so that's about €2500 out of the €6k gone, spend about €1200 - €1500 on shopping and utilities and so that leaves about €2k to sit in the current account to pay for one off things like holidays, once off items, going out etc.
You should divert your Zurich €500 per month (or more if you can afford it) into an AVC PRSA. You will get 40% tax relief on these AVCs. When you retire you can set up an ARF and you have scope to drawdown income from this at 20% tax when you cease public sector employment.

Are you pre 95 public sector?

No, I first started working after April 1995 so I'm Class A and my wife is the same as she was orignally D, but then A. The advice I got from the pensions person we dealt with was that we had enough in AVCs as I can only get €200k max in a lump sum anyway and the rest will be in an ARF.
Helping the children: the small gift exemption is €3,000 a year from each person to each person, and those gifts don't count towards the lifetime thresholds. You and your wife giving each of three children €3,000 each comes to €18,000 a year tax-free.
That's a good way to give them some money so I'm going to start doing that, as it is now they could do with it. Thanks.
If your children have not expressed any interest in it, then you should sell it or rent it out. It seems wrong to leave a house empty with the crisis we are in at the moment. I know that the crisis is not of your making and has been made worse by anti-landlord policy, but it still seems wrong.
I agree with you Brendan. One of my children is likely to move in there soon (I figure this would be a possiblilty) and I still have adult children living with me who can't afford to move out, or see it as being pointless to pay rent to stay in a room in another house rather than in the room and the house they've grown up in.
Yes, you could run into problems with the tenant. But it's not a lottery. You can take steps to reduce the risk. You also can't be generous and must charge the absolute maximum rent. And if things go wrong, you are not depending on it. You can afford a tenant who pays no rent or which takes you a year to leave.

So hold onto the property and rent it out.
One might move into this second property and I think your advice re it not being a lottery is helpful and you make the valid point that I don't need it to actually make a yield, though of course I would prefer it did and then maybe in 20 years I, if I'm still alive, and my children would have an asset.
Whatever about the other decisions is the house you are thinking of buying vacant 2 yrs? If so you could apply for the grant to do it up and then rent it out.
No, it has been used as a holiday home.
ame goes for the second property. As another poster pointed out, the €20k discount will rapidly disappear in fees, costs, repairs and improvements. In any event, do you really want to double your hassle and risks. You're now renting out two properties.
Well I think one of my children will move into the second property I have now, but I suppose this is the crux of the matter. I'm kind of torn between your advice and what Brendan said in terms of getting the right tenant. The house is turnkey, but there will still be transaction costs etc and at my age and stage I don't want hassle.
Shares: selling the holding now worth about €23,000, bought for €3,500, gives a gain of €19,500. After the €1,270 annual exemption, CGT at 31% (disposals from 7 October 2026) is about €5,651. A loss realised on the Bank of Ireland shares in the same year would come off the gain first.
I might dispose of €1270 per year so.
And then invest a good chunk of the resulting c. €1M of cash into a diversified basket of shares.
I will look further on the forum here at this basket of shares to put some of my cash into as I know having it in even the most high yielding short-term and instant accessible deposit accounts means it is still losing money over time.

Again, thank you to all of you who have responded, it has certainly given me food for thought.
 
I would love to invest in some ethical funds that might help those who are less well off,
I have another property, value about €400K, not let-out just sitting there
I am also open to leave it sit there for a year and see what might happen re house prices
You want to be ethical but you also want to have two vacant properties for nothing other than price speculation...tad but hypocritical.

Either become a landlord and buy the second property or sell the vacant property and don't buy the available property.

Would it be a feasible idea to loan the money to my childen in lieu of a mortage (one already has a mortage) so as to help them become a bit more financially independent?
I find your logic hard to follow, if anything this would make them more financially dependent on you than ever in their entire lifetime.

Any mortgage that they take out should still follow the Central Banks lending rules so it should be based on their income and ability to pay. So you are not actually offering them much other than another alternative to a bank.

For example, if one of the kids has a joint income of €150k, they could borrow €600k from a bank. If you facilitate this, then you won't have enough for the next child. You would be far better off giving them a gift, e.g. €50k, that let's them buy a better home or reduce the amount they need to borrow. They are now off the books, you've done your job.

Buying a house for them or giving them a mortgage they can't afford is not helping them in the long term
 
The house is turnkey, but there will still be transaction costs etc and at my age and stage I don't want hassle.
The house is turnkey now. It will require work between each rental. Over 12 years renting, 5 tenancies. Only once did the place not require any work in between rentals. Perfect tenants stayed 18 months.
 
The house is turnkey now. It will require work between each rental. Over 12 years renting, 5 tenancies. Only once did the place not require any work in between rentals. Perfect tenants stayed 18 months.
Exactly and every new tenant is a risk. You'll have met them for 15 minutes and they'll be on their best behaviour but you won't know what they are really like until they move in at which point it may well be too late. I once spoke to a very convincing landlady referee who I later found out was the tenant's auntie!

Will you be able to cope with a situation where the tenant isn't paying the rent, is damaging the property and is engaging in anti-social behaviour. You'll be trying to evict the tenant via the Rogue Tenants Board while the neighbours are in the RTB as well chasing you for compensation for not doing enough. Obviously that is the nightmare scenario but it does happen, even the most experienced landlord can get caught and wander into a mine field.
 
If your children are unlikely to want the second property , don't buy it.
You need mean the potential third property?
They already have two and are considering buying a third.
That would be a crazy/very risky concentration of their net worth in Irish residential property.
Even having the second property lying idle is a very questionable use of resources in my opinion.
 
You want to be ethical but you also want to have two vacant properties for nothing other than price speculation...tad but hypocritical.
I can understand your saying this, but the second property was my original family home and the context in which I bought it was partly why I did so. I really don't want to be a speculator and up until I bought the family home, I always only had one home, when during the height of the boom, people I knew were borrowing and buying to make a killing, but I never wanted that as it was enough to run one house.

I do see your point about loaning money and it could be messy - I suppose I was just trying to figure out if there was a more economical way of them to get onto the property market, as they won't have a joint income of €150k, but as you say it might be better to gift them money each year.

Thanks.
The house is turnkey now. It will require work between each rental. Over 12 years renting, 5 tenancies. Only once did the place not require any work in between rentals. Perfect tenants stayed 18 months.
Good point. Thanks for that.
 
I have another property, value about €400K, not let-out just sitting there
You would be better off selling the property that's lying idle and a drain on your finances once maintenance and other fixed costs (e.g. vacant home tax = 7 times the LPT, insurance, utilities etc.) are accounted for.
Have you clarified if you're liable for the Vacant Homes Tax or just LPT on this property?
 
One more point on the second house, since you say one of your children may move in there.
If a child lives in a property you own rent-free (or below market rent), Revenue treats that free use as a gift to them. Revenue's page on free use of property says the gift each year is the market rent less any rent actually paid, taken on 31 December (or the day before the use ends if they move out).
The small gift exemption can be claimed against it, but it is the same €3,000 a year from each of you to that child, not an extra one. So if you also give that child €3,000 in cash each year, the rent-free use would count towards their lifetime Group A threshold instead. There's nothing to pay unless that threshold is passed, but it's worth keeping a note of the yearly rental value, and it might change how you split the cash gifts between the three.
 
You need mean the potential third property?
They already have two and are considering buying a third.
That would be a crazy/very risky concentration of their net worth in Irish residential property.
Even having the second property lying idle is a very questionable use of resources in my opinion.
Yes, I can see that and after the input from here today I'm questioning my exposure, so thanks.
Have you clarified if you're liable for the Vacant Homes Tax or just LPT on this property?

Yes, it is lived in for 30 or more days a year by a relation who is not a relation as per the Revenue rules so I just pay LPT on this.
 
I'm usually very much pro property as an investment.
But given that you had a second house but didn't rent it out, I'd be saying don't buy.
And sell the second house while you're at it.

Then put the entire savings 1m?
Into ETFs using some low cost app
Revolut, degiro, etrade
Remember to get tax advice.
Employ an accountant.
 
Whether or not you hold on to your existing property is up to yourself. You are under no obligation to rent it out when the government have made the PRS so risky and unattractive.

I definitely wouldn't be embroiling yourself with a second investment property though.
 
Back
Top