Whamming BAM a great idea - but is it going to be legal ?

trajan

Registered User
Messages
372
Minister Jennifer O'Carroll MacNeill has indicated that BAM shouldn't bother tendering for the new Maternity Hospital at Elm Park as she'll be mindful of recent experiences with the National Children's Hospital.

You can't stop people tendering if they have the expertise, experience and resources to do a project.

To what extent can you deny a lowest tender the job, I don't know.

Don't get me wrong. I'm 4 square behind the Minister here.

But have the damn civil servants got the tender legalities in order so BAM can't viably sue if they are the lowest bidder - that's the headache.
 
That announcement jarred with me a little too.

Everyone makes mistakes, it's accepting that and learning from them that's important. Suggesting that BAM shouldn't bid sounds like those involved here are incapable of learning from and avoiding these recent mistakes. So, rather than adjust the process and contract language to ensure they can't happen, they just pick another supplier and hope for the best?
 
Come on. She was echoing the public sentiment on BAM. It's just that she can't control things as much as she might like to - and we might like to.

So much was wrong with this project. Wrong location for people across Ireland. The specific site had major issues - known and unknown, knowable and unknowable till actual excavation began. The design was fairly challenging for a tight site. The project management on behalf of the state was grossly inadequate to control the runaway costs. But the main thing BAM played on was the political sensitivity of it all: it had to be proceeded with once started as no government wanted to fail the children of Ireland.

We now have ample experience with building hospitals over the last 30 years. But either we don't have good project managers in this country or else the state overseers are afraid to be led by the bolder ones. I hope we import someone from Spain for the next hospital. But obviously I hope JOM doesn't publicly say so. Just hire the best person and all that.
 
But have the damn civil servants got the tender legalities in order so BAM can't viably sue if they are the lowest bidder - that's the headache.
Hopefully confidentiality of the tender documents would apply and equally hopefully the evaluation process is more thorough than simply picking the lowest price. I'd hope that a verifiable record of projects completed on time and within cost boundaries, the financial stability of the tenderer, positive feedback from the sponsors of completed projects, the robustness and usefulness of the deliverables themselves, and other important criteria would also apply in the selection process. Or maybe not, and we get more and more OPW bike sheds, bits of walls, steps and more children's hospitals and abandoned railway IT projects.
 
Back
Top