Victor Orban attending todays Ireland V Hungary game

Flash in the pan, as yesterday's result seems to corroborate. We'll see how we get on against the Portugee next month, although the media seem to have already given the Icelandic dentist his P45!
Hopefully get rid of John O'Shea as well, given his growing track record of teams going backwards when he is the coach.
 
In all fairness there just isn't the talent needed to qualify for these tournaments in Ireland just now. It's been a long time since we had a full squad of ' Premier League ' standard players. And it looks a long way off now too. We can't even compete with the lower quality teams at present...
It doesn't matter who the manager is ....
 
Hungary losing at home to Portugal has left a glimmer of hope.

An away win against Hungary is vital now. A 0-1 result to nick it. Then beat Armenia at home and pray for two miracle draws against Portugal. That would leave us on 8 pts from 6 games. Hungary to lose twice against Portugal and beat Armenia twice would leave them on 7pts.
 
In all fairness there just isn't the talent needed to qualify for these tournaments in Ireland just now. It's been a long time since we had a full squad of ' Premier League ' standard players. And it looks a long way off now too. We can't even compete with the lower quality teams at present...
It doesn't matter who the manager is ....
60th ranked team in England at the minute is Northampton Town. That's the level we are at. 2 decent players, (Ferguson and Kelliher), a bunch of average players and the rest are there to make up the numbers.
 
60th ranked team in England at the minute is Northampton Town. That's the level we are at. 2 decent players, (Ferguson and Kelliher), a bunch of average players and the rest are there to make up the numbers.
We need more Englishmen on the team. We were at out best when we had a load of them.
 
We need more Englishmen on the team. We were at out best when we had a load of them.
We had the best midfielder of his generation, a gladiator on the pitch (Roy Keane) and FAI couldn't manage to be professional enough to hang on to him... that lesson did not go unnoticed by a lot of qualifying English players.

Just an observation and don't want to take thread off topic.
 
Why would any half-decent English born player of Irish heritage want to choose Ireland over England?
Thinking of Rice, Grealish, even Harry Kane..... Strong Irish backgrounds. The best English born players with Irish heritage will choose England, who at least have a chance to get to a semi or a final. Ireland are lucky to even qualify for anything.

Its a vicious circle though - really good English born Irish players would probably make Ireland a better team and maybe we would do well then.
But then there's the FAI .....
 
Unfortunately we are a long way off the standard of players that we had in Italia 90 or Saipan...sorry to mention the war , but in the context I couldn't avoid it.. These high quality players only come around rarely so we will have to wait until it happens again
 
that lesson did not go unnoticed by a lot of qualifying English players.
Not sure too many young English players would pay attention to something that happened before they were born to some old guy off the TV.

We have some good players, a lot are over-rated (Nathan Collins an example), too many playing in bad teams (Ipswich, Wolves, Southamton) in England where losing became the norm and their confidence is shot. Throw in a 2nd rate manager, a 3rd rate (at best) first team coach and it's a recipie for disaster. Cant afford to sack them, cant afford to pay for replacements.......

Having watched the u21s struggle to bear a mountain top after the Armenia match, hard to find any room for optimism
 
Not sure too many young English players would pay attention to something that happened before they were born to some old guy off the TV.
Was a huge story then to the degree they've recently made a film about it.

The players will have advisors (business managers/agents) and these guys will have been aware of the background to the Saipan incident.

Doubt they'd be advising their clients to play for Ireland ;)
 
or Saipan...sorry to mention the war , but in the context I couldn't avoid it

OK, I've risen to the Saipan bait!

Saipan was chosen (by FAI/McCarthy - two of Keane's adversaries!) as a location for a few days of R&R for the players to unwind after a long English football season before they got down to the serious stuff of preparing for the World Cup. It was never planned to be used as a training base.

It was pretty evident from the encounter in Dublin Airport (where he publicly snubbed Bertie) before the squad departed that the Mayfield Maverick wasn't in a good place mentally, and I suspect that he wasn't capable of either resting or recreating, let alone unwinding ( mind you, the sort of "recreation" that Saipan offered probably wouldn't have appealed to him anyway!)

The subsequent eruption - ostensibly over the lack of balls and parking cones and associated training gear - could have been about almost anything under the sun; the Cork volcano was inevitably going to blow and all that was needed was something to trigger it.

And so it came to pass .......................

*******************************************************************************

Full disclosure: lifelong Shamrock Rovers supporter who had a season ticket to Milltown since the mid-1970s, long before the Kilcoynes bought the club from the Cunninghams in a shrewd property play. Back then Cork Hibs and Waterford were the enemy and Keane's Cobh Ramblers weren't even in the LoI! Oh and also a lifelong ABU!
 
Last edited:
as a location for a few days of R&R for the players to unwind after a long English football season before they got down to the serious stuff of preparing for the World Cup. It was never planned to be used as a training base.

That much is true.

I was firmly in the McCarthy side when the war started. In hindsight Keane was right, but I think he handled it terribly.

Keane had arrived at Forest and then onto Utd and was involved in the Charlton era including '94 WC. There are plenty of great stories of pub and beer shenanigans which Keane was part of.

By 2000-2002, Keane was captain of Man Utd. Utd were dominating the Prem and the standard and attitudes of the game were changing with big money imports and TV investment. Keane had ditched the beer altogether by 1997 while recovering from a career threatening knee ligament injury that he says was sustained while suffering from a hangover.

I've no doubt that Keane saw the writing on the wall for his career at Man Utd if he didnt take control. Alex Ferguson was setting the standards at the club level and he was the captain, competing for the highest honours in Europe.

Then there was the Irish set-up, under McCarthy. I like McCarthy, great servant for Ireland and a good manager. But McCarthy was of the Charlton era - maybe not a keg of Guinness in the hotel room, but not far behind.

Saipan was to be a bit of R&R and a bit of a beer session in the sun. Keane had moved beyond that and as captain wanted to set the standards for to the highest level.

You can R&R without beer, or just a couple of beers, but the name of the game is football. And this was the World Cup.

I think McCarthy had the right idea but he was behind the times in what high-level professional athletes needed for preparation for the biggest tournament of all. The game was changing.

Keane was right to invoke the high standards needed but I think his communication skills were of fire and brimstone and not much in-between.

The film is out now with Steve Coogan playing McCarthy. Looking forward to seeing it.
 
I must say that I was in the McCarthy camp at the time. I felt sorry for him.
Having said that I am a great admirer of Roy Keane too. He played hard but fair in every game. He would have been the first to admit if he had a bad game. He expected everyone else to give 100 per cent , team mates, manager etc. He expected to give 100 per cent as a manager too. And gives 100 per cent an a pundit also. He doesn't care who takes him up wrong or doesn't like him . Roy will never change and that is a good thing .
 
Having said that I am a great admirer of Roy Keane too. He played hard but fair in every game. He would have been the first to admit if he had a bad game. He expected everyone else to give 100 per cent ,
He was a winner. Pure ambition and grit. Impossible not to admire him.I like people like him and have worked with some like him over the years, like having a turbo engine under the bonnet.
 
Keane has two forms of expression - silence and rage. It’s not good for a human being and the “driven professional” argument doesn’t stand up.

Maradona was a much better player than Keane but he was never as hard on his teammates. He accepted their shortcomings and just got on with doing the best he could himself. If he was in Keane’s position in Saipan, there wouldn’t have been a problem.

And as for the argument that Irish players aren’t playing at a high enough level in the English leagues, how high a level does a group of players need to play at to be capable of beating Armenia?
 
Keane was as hard on himself as he was on his team mates though. He allowed for shortcomings but always expected them to give everything they had and that's the difference, in my opinion.
I agree that any group of decent Irish players should be beating Armenia and teams of that 'quality' .
But sadly they are just not capable of giving 100 per cent in every game.
 
Keane recently said he thinks a lot of the current Irish squad are happy playing for championship and lower premier League teams as they're getting a decent wage. They're not driven to achieve more.
 
Back
Top