as a location for a few days of R&R for the players to unwind after a long English football season before they got down to the serious stuff of preparing for the World Cup. It was never planned to be used as a training base.
That much is true.
I was firmly in the McCarthy side when the war started. In hindsight Keane was right, but I think he handled it terribly.
Keane had arrived at Forest and then onto Utd and was involved in the Charlton era including '94 WC. There are plenty of great stories of pub and beer shenanigans which Keane was part of.
By 2000-2002, Keane was captain of Man Utd. Utd were dominating the Prem and the standard and attitudes of the game were changing with big money imports and TV investment. Keane had ditched the beer altogether by 1997 while recovering from a career threatening knee ligament injury that he says was sustained while suffering from a hangover.
I've no doubt that Keane saw the writing on the wall for his career at Man Utd if he didnt take control. Alex Ferguson was setting the standards at the club level and he was the captain, competing for the highest honours in Europe.
Then there was the Irish set-up, under McCarthy. I like McCarthy, great servant for Ireland and a good manager. But McCarthy was of the Charlton era - maybe not a keg of Guinness in the hotel room, but not far behind.
Saipan was to be a bit of R&R and a bit of a beer session in the sun. Keane had moved beyond that and as captain wanted to set the standards for to the highest level.
You can R&R without beer, or just a couple of beers, but the name of the game is football. And this was the World Cup.
I think McCarthy had the right idea but he was behind the times in what high-level professional athletes needed for preparation for the biggest tournament of all. The game was changing.
Keane was right to invoke the high standards needed but I think his communication skills were of fire and brimstone and not much in-between.
The film is out now with Steve Coogan playing McCarthy. Looking forward to seeing it.