Tweet of The Week

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't do social media, I don't have a FB, X or Twitter accounts but where I see this "AI slop" appearing more and more is YouTube
Some of it is very good but the majority is for me unwatchable and as soon as I hear or see that it's AI generated I stop watching or listening

But what has me worried for the future(not mine by the way) is the amount of jobs that AI is going to replace and what that means for society
For example Microsoft have mandated that staff must interact and use AI in their roles and their performance reviews will be accessed on that basis
That to me signals that in the future MS when AI is capable of doing these roles will start cut as many roles as humanly possible
 
I don't do social media, I don't have a FB, X or Twitter accounts

I do, but it's to do with hillwalking not pensions/savings/investments. That said, the Twitter account is one of the first links at comes up on a search for my name (because I'm execution only and there are no 'getting to know you chats', some people do that) so it has been helpful in that regard as clients have mentioned the photos from that activity.

Would I take advice from it or FB or any of the other mainstream social media platforms? No. Would I read the opinions of others on a theme/topic for balance? Yes. I control what I want to use it for and can block the 6% of folk that are just doses. The alternative is akin to a large room of people watching a channel with just one person in control of the remote control. You'd leave the room.

People will gravitate towards platforms that contain factual information from trusted/verifiable sources as they're realising that a lot of what they're reading is just slop (unclear) and their online time is limited.
 
Interesting the Sunday Times highlighted this podcast today.

It’s easy for non-digital natives to say that the internet has ruined everything, so Gareth King’s series is a welcome investigation into how the web has affected a variety of subjects, including journalism, gaming, dating
and broadcast television with contributions from relevant experts. The series offers hope and practical solutions.

 
Would I take advice from it or FB or any of the other mainstream social media platforms? No. Would I read the opinions of others on a theme/topic for balance? Yes. I control what I want to use it for and can block the 6% of folk that are just doses.
I'm the same and as I'm reaching my "elder lemon" years I feel I've got a fairly good grasp of who, what, where and when I need advice
and I have the life experience to decipher between real or not, Ai vs human, good and bad, yadda yadda yadda
People will gravitate towards platforms that contain factual information from trusted/verifiable sources as they're realising that a lot of what they're reading is just slop (unclear)
But as I said above my "worry" is that (very) young people or people yet to be born wont have the skill set to realise this until its to late
What that means for society, I don't know but given the misinformation out there and the rise of the far right, it can't be a good thing
 
What that means for society, I don't know but given the misinformation out there and the rise of the far right, it can't be a good thing
I'm almost as worried about the normalisation of the far left in this country than the rise of the far right.
 
Yes, extremism of either side is a worry for sure but if I had to choose, left it would be
I don't know. It killed far more people in the last century than the far right. I think they are two sides of the same coin, Ultimately they seek to impose a totalitarian version of a utopian ideal at the expense of self determination and democracy. That inevitably leads to the deaths of millions of people.
 
But what has me worried for the future(not mine by the way) is the amount of jobs that AI is going to replace and what that means for society

There's a Dispatches programme on the All4 app at the moment - 'Will AI Take My Job?' that you might be interested in.

Solicitor, Doctor, Musician and Fashions Photographer were 'compared' on specific tasks.
 
Last edited:
An interesting watch and for those interested and have a spare 47 minutes it's also on YouTube as well
Gotta say I wasn't expecting or prepared for how the programme ended, it was a surprise for my few remaining brain cells
 
Solicitor, Doctor, Musician and Fashions Photographer were 'compared' on specific tasks.
Most of what Doctors do can be done using AI. Most of the technology already exists. It's just inertia that's holding it up but medical cost inflation will be the catalyst that drives it.
 
Most of what Doctors do can be done using AI. Most of the technology already exists. It's just inertia that's holding it up but medical cost inflation will be the catalyst that drives it.

I'm rather glad that my recent colonoscopy involved a human being! The small talk was entertaining.
 
Most of what Doctors do can be done using AI. Most of the technology already exists. It's just inertia that's holding it up

This is absolutely untrue. Most of what can be done with AI? There are dozens of different specialties in medicine, some far more amenable to automation and AI than others. You say most of the technology exists - are you saying it is all ethical, validated, safe, ready for deployment, cost effective, funding in place, etc. just inertia stopping us from deploying it? What are all these claims based on?
 
This is absolutely untrue.
Hhmmmm...
Most of what can be done with AI?
Diagnosis, reading of scans and x-rays, minor surgeries, prescriptions etc.

There are dozens of different specialties in medicine, some far more amenable to automation and AI than others.
Agreed.
You say most of the technology exists
Yes.
- are you saying it is all ethical, validated, safe, ready for deployment, cost effective, funding in place, etc. just inertia stopping us from deploying it?
No. Inertia is stopping the investment in infrastructure and the validation required for deployment. It's no more or less ethical than a human delivering healthcare. Taking highly paid doctors out of the process and automating very expensive capital equipment so that it runs 24/7 would also reduce costs significantly. That would make it more accessible and so in that respect more ethical.

My Watch gives the same ECG results as I get from my GP. It can also monitor my blood pressure. The new Apple Watch is FDA approved as a medical device.
We have drones and we have the technology to take automated swabs and minor biopsies. We already test swabs etc in automated machines. Why can't a drone deliver the device to your location to take the swab or look in your ears or down your throat, and then deliver the sample to a fully automated lab, perform a diagnosis, issue a prescription and then deliver your drugs via a drone?

I can currently facetime a doctor and get a diagnosis. That could be an AI soon or the human doctor could be anywhere in the world. They could be working for Amazon Healthcare and they could send the drone etc.

There are already automated systems reading brain scans and diagnosing tumors at a far more accurate rate than doctors can. One such system could read and diagnose every scan in the world each day.

What are all these claims based on?
Reading the news and working in the sector.

It is, of course, the case that much of the delivery of healthcare cannot be automated.
 
Diagnosis, reading of scans and x-rays, minor surgeries, prescriptions etc.
Diagnosing in what specialty? Which scans and x-rays? And which minor surgeries can a computer do?

No. Inertia is stopping the investment in infrastructure and the validation required for deployment. It's no more or less ethical than a human delivering healthcare.

The area of ethics in AI is huge and the more we do the bigger the questions raised. AI systems are developed by humans and we embed in them our own biases.

Taking highly paid doctors out of the process and automating very expensive capital equipment so that it runs 24/7 would also reduce costs significantly. That would make it more accessible and so in that respect more ethical.
What are you referring to? Having CT and MRI running 24/7 with AI reading all the scans? Which AI system can currently do this?

We have drones and we have the technology to take automated swabs and minor biopsies. We already test swabs etc in automated machines. Why can't a drone deliver the device to your location to take the swab or look in your ears or down your throat, and then deliver the sample to a fully automated lab, perform a diagnosis, issue a prescription and then deliver your drugs via a drone?

The technology does not exist in this form. And the cost would be astronomical.

There are already automated systems reading brain scans and diagnosing tumors at a far more accurate rate than doctors can. One such system could read and diagnose every scan in the world each day.

Clinical AI is my area of expertise and I work in an international centre of excellence for healthcare AI.

As a Star Trek fan who would like to retire 20 years early, I love the vision, so I am not trying to be negative or snarky but it is so far from reality.
 
Diagnosing in what specialty? Which scans and x-rays? And which minor surgeries can a computer do?
Really? You’re not trying to be negative or Sarky?

The area of ethics in AI is huge and the more we do the bigger the questions raised. AI systems are developed by humans and we embed in them our own biases.
Agreed. They have the same biases we have.
What are you referring to? Having CT and MRI running 24/7 with AI reading all the scans? Which AI system can currently do this?
CT and MRIs can already be run 24/7… in well run hospitals and healthcare systems. Phillips already have AI assisted MRI’s.
The technology does not exist in this form. And the cost would be astronomical.
Have you any idea how AI works?
The cost would be far lower than having vastly expensive doctors and inefficient healthcare workers run it.

Clinical AI is my area of expertise and I work in an international centre of excellence for healthcare AI.
Not in this country you don’t.

As a Star Trek fan who would like to retire 20 years early, I love the vision, so I am not trying to be negative or snarky but it is so far from reality.
I genuinely find it hard to believe that you don’t see how close we are to most of the above. The race to control the information flows in hospitals is going on for years, mainly between Siemens and GE. With Apple, Google and Amazon all moving into that space it’ll only accelerate.
 
Really? You’re not trying to be negative or Sarky?

Not at all. No point in that. You said "Most of what Doctors do can be done using AI" and that the technology to do it is available right now which is a huge statement so I was asking for some specifics.

CT and MRIs can already be run 24/7… in well run hospitals and healthcare systems. Phillips already have AI assisted MRI’s.

There are lots of AI programmes in radiology and diagnostic imaging, some are fantastic, but most are niche, expensive, and are assisting rather than replacing.

Have you any idea how AI works?

Yes, I do, I have a masters in AI and have been working in the area for years. I have built AI systems and tested them in clinical settings. I have colleagues running international trials on AI systems.

The cost would be far lower than having vastly expensive doctors and inefficient healthcare workers run it.

Hopefully that will happen but we are very far from it right now. Costs in healthcare IT are mind-blowing. Some hospitals can't/won't even fund email access for all staff.

Not in this country you don’t.

Are you saying I don't work in that field? Or just not in Ireland? Or that it doesn't exist in Ireland?

I genuinely find it hard to believe that you don’t see how close we are to most of the above.

Because I have been working in the area for over a decade. Reading the news does not give the full picture.

When you start talking about AI doing biopsies and minor surgeries, it is very confusing. How can AI do something physical like that? Or are you talking about robots? I work with 2 world-leading robotic surgeons, they love tech, but they are the first to say that we need to be cautious about our expectations.

There are lots of exciting things happening in AI that are practical, affordable, and will make visible improvements. Ambient scribes, for example, that listen during consultations and procedures. They allow clinical staff to concentrate on the patient, they document very accurately, and they help humans to catch things that they otherwise might miss. Moving to AI switchboard operators would be fantastic. Using AI to improve the legibility of correspondence is already a big success.

It's very tempting to think AI will fix everything soon in a big wave but the evidence is that it will be incremental. Healthcare is also demand led so as capacity grows it will likely be swallowed up by ever-rising standards and increased patient needs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top