Pat Leahy: Hard to see southern voters agreeing to pay €1,500 to €5,000 each for unity
A plan for reunification has to start with Northern Ireland working better. Can Sinn Féin get on board?
At the Fine Gael ardfheis a study by economist Stephen Kinsella was presented on the economics of potential Irish unity.
Over the course of 50-odd pages, Kinsella sets out in some detail the potential costs of various models and scenarios for Irish unity. Obviously, there are certain variables that hugely influence the total bill. These include the vexed questions of who pays for future pensions, and what Northern Ireland’s share of the UK national debt would be.
The potential costs, he says, range from €3 billion to €25 billion in year one
Kinsella also describes how the costs of integrating the Northern economy (such as it is) by equalising pay, welfare and other elements across the unified country can be understood as costing southern taxpayers while benefiting households in the North. The biggest beneficiaries, he says, will be public service workers, pensioners and those on welfare in the North.
Even in the most optimistic scenario, households in the South would be paying significant amounts to improve the position for people in the North. In one scenario, the first year costs range from €1,500 for each taxpayer in the South to almost €5,000. And remember, the costs are recurring. Again, it is hard to see southern voters signing up for this.
This alongside another IT article yesterday about how our multinational tax take is able to pay for such large public sector expenditure.
David McWilliams: How can Ireland afford to be so generous to public sector workers?
Irish public sector expenditure has grown seven-fold in 30 years. The money is not coming from domestic taxpayers, but from foreign multinationals
My personal view is that unification would be cause massive societal and financial - and potentially worse - problems for the country, and if it coincided with a reduction in the multinational tax take (and multinationational employment levels) would set the country back decades if not effectively bankrupt it.
BUT I expect that financial arguments will lose out to emotional arguments in the debate around any referendum, and the country as a whole would vote with its heart not its head for reunification, and a generation will suffer as a result.
Last edited:
