Tax on bonds

The query that started the thread was answered in post #2.
The query that started the rabbit hole was from @TravisT.

To which you replied that this was all "gibberish"; we're in Ireland not the US.
Is that still your answer? (third time of asking)
If it is then AAM has failed @TravisT as they have received conflicting answers and have no option but to ask Revenue.
Yes it is still my answer. There’s no mention of buying at issuance and I’ve never seen a private individual holding those < 1 year NTMA T-bills.
 
Give GG a last chance to at least concede that he might be wrong. Ideally @TravisT should get a near unanimous answer from AAM.

He should correct this wrong information also.

Post in thread 'Should I ignore a registered letter?'
 
He should correct this wrong information also.

Post in thread 'Should I ignore a registered letter?'
In what way is it ‘wrong information’?

You really need to get a life :)
 
Thanks @Duke of Marmalade and @Corolla for offering feedback and evidence. I was hoping these ‘zero coupon bonds’ were indeed liable for capital gain, alas seems not to be.
The phrase “the blind leading the blind” comes to mind. There is an obvious difference between the taxation of US government bonds and Irish government bonds. Gains on Irish government bonds are tax-tree in Ireland, whereas gains on US government bonds are taxable in Ireland.
 
I return to this question, because it is interesting how AI was dismissed previously.

I asked the following to Google gemini (put it in the Google search field) I get the following which seems to be very accurate..

----------------

For an Irish resident non-trading individual holding short-term zero-coupon US Treasury bills, purchased on secondary market via a US financial broker, and held to maturity, how is the redemption assessable?


1. Assessment of the Discount (Income Tax, USC, PRSI)

  • Statutory Charging Provision. Under Section 18 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (TCA 1997), Schedule D Case III expressly charges tax on "all discounts" as well as income arising from foreign securities. Unlike Irish government zero-coupon securities—which are exempt under Section 45 and Section 607 TCA 1997—returns on overseas government bills issued at a discount to par value are taxed as income rather than capital gains. [1, 2, 3]
  • Timing of Assessment. Because you hold the US Treasury bill to maturity, the discount is taxed in the tax year of redemption (when the income arises and can be turned to account). Standard Treasury bills are not subject to the annual deemed-disposal accrual rules that apply to stripped bonds under Section 55 TCA 1997. [1]
  • Euro Calculation. Even when bought on the secondary market, the taxable discount is the difference between the USD redemption value (par) and your USD secondary market purchase price. Convert that USD profit into euros using the EUR/USD exchange rate on the maturity date.
  • Applicable Tax Rates. The euro-converted discount is added to your total taxable income and charged at your marginal Income Tax rate (20% or 40%), plus Universal Social Charge (USC) and PRSI (where applicable). DIRT does not apply.
  • US Withholding Tax. Provided you have a valid Form W-8BEN lodged with your US broker, US Treasury bill discount interest is exempt from US non-resident withholding tax under the US-Ireland Double Taxation Treaty, so you receive the full par value gross and declare it directly to Revenue.

2. Assessment of the Currency Movement (Capital Gains Tax)

  • Separate CGT Calculation. Foreign government bills and non-euro currency balances are chargeable assets for CGT under Section 532 TCA 1997 (the Section 607 exemption applies only to Irish government securities). Under Section 551 / Section 552 TCA 1997, the discount already taxed as Case III income is excluded from your CGT disposal proceeds so it is not taxed twice. [1, 2]
  • How the FX Gain or Loss is Computed:
    • Allowable Cost: Your secondary market purchase price in USD converted to EUR at the purchase date exchange rate.
    • Net Disposal Proceeds: That same principal purchase amount in USD converted to EUR at the redemption date exchange rate (excluding the USD discount taxed under Case III).
    • Result: If the US dollar strengthened against the euro between purchase and maturity, you have a chargeable capital gain. If the US dollar weakened, you have an allowable capital loss that can offset other capital gains.
  • CGT Rates and Annual Exemption: Following Budget 2027, the standard CGT rate is 31% for disposals made on or after 7 October 2026 (reduced from 33% for disposals prior to that date). Every individual receives a €1,270 annual CGT personal exemption per tax year before any CGT is payable. [1, 2]
  • US Broker USD Cash Balance. When your US broker credits the $100 par value per bill into your USD cash settlement account on maturity, that USD cash becomes a separate chargeable asset under Revenue Tax and Duty Manual Part 19-01-14a until you convert it to euros, withdraw it, or use it to buy another security. [1]
 
because it is interesting how AI was dismissed previously.
Two years ago? It's improving all the time so it's no real surprise if it's better these days. But AI/LLMs can still make egregious errors depending on the prompt, the problem domain, and what data it was trained on. Garbage in, garbage out still applies.
 
Agree, the AI has developed, but as I recall its answer was same as before. It's hard to dismiss its output. I ask cause I'd really like to get an accurate answer.
 
Right, and with the output above, my question is whether it changes anyone's opinion on the tax question - for those posters that stated there is no interest on zero coupon US bills, do you still believe so given the answer above?
 
It seems to me that buying these bonds at a discount to par is similar to buying shares at a discounted price, e.g. through your employee share purchase plan. The value of the discount is subject to income tax not CGT.
 
Last edited:
I slightly re-worded the question to be "For an Irish resident non-trading individual holding German government bonds with a zero coupon interest rate, purchased on secondary market, and held to maturity, how is the redemption assessable?"
These would not be "issued at a discount".

In this case, Gemini's answer was:
"the redemption of a zero-coupon German government bond held to maturity is generally assessable to Capital Gains Tax (CGT) at 33%, unless the security is structured as a short-term discount bill or a stripped bond."

So, it does appear that a key consideration is whether the bond was issued at a discount to par. Of course, this also assumes both answers are accurate. Gemini does cite sources, and one of them is this thread !!!
 
Back
Top