Small Gift Exemption, older kids, 1 gift possibly in a trust

FoxGate

New Member
Messages
2
Hello,


Myself and my husband would each like to gift our 2 children the max Small Gift Exemption of 3K per year, each. We are married . We would like to do this for the foreseeable future – basically as long as we can afford to .

As we understand it, we could gift 6K between us to each child per year.

Child A is 18 and Child B 21.

We do not wish for them to have access to this money now. We don’t see any reason for them to have knowledge about it at the moment. It’s for when they need it for first car, travel, House deposit etc.

Child B has issues which means that we may not ever wish for him to be able to access the money himself and we would be thinking of a trust of some kind for Child B .



We would be happy to invest it for each child rather than the money sitting in a savings account.



How do we go about this?

In order to gift it, does it have to be deposited into an account or investment policy in their names?

How would we set it up in trust for Child B?



Any advice would be much appreciated.
 
Ten years ago we decided we would like to do as you are hoping to do now, so we set up bank accounts for them (our 3 grandchildren) in their own names.
They still do not know about it. We of course told their parents.
We did not put the full 6K in each year but a nice sum has built up for them
 
How did you set up bank accounts for a person under 18 in their own names?
Are they joint accounts with the parent?
 
We set up the kids accounts on line (B of I)website. I think the only thing we needed was their PRSI numbers. As this was 10 years ago things may have changed since.
I have kept all paperwork and statements which are addressed to me. They were in primary school at the but are now in college.
The accounts are each sole name with no attachment to any adult.
 
BoI will eventually look for proof of ID so your 10 years of control may come to an end. And that is the issue @FoxGate, you can no longer open a bank account in the name of someone else, you need proof of ID and the small gift must be given not just set aside in the name of the recipient.

The only thing to do is give the money to your children and counsel them on the use of it. If they appear to squander it in your opinion then you can stop.
 
Child A is 18 and Child B 21.
Both children are adults and, in general, any arrangement whereby you claim to have made a "gift" to an adult, when the adult has no knowledge of it, and no access to or control over the money supposedly "gifted", is extremely suspect. I doubt that it would survive an audit; Revenue would take the view that there is no gift until the recipient is actually able to access the money.

If you want to claim the small gift exemption then you do actually have to make a gift. And the essence of a gift is giving; you have to give them the money. An inevitable consequence of giving them the money is that then it's their money, not yours. They decide what to do with it; you don't.

Except . . .
Child B has issues which means that we may not ever wish for him to be able to access the money himself and we would be thinking of a trust of some kind for Child B .
You don't say what the issues are and I get that in a public forum you may not want to go into detail, which is fine.

What you are talking about is a discretionary trust — one in which the trust property is to be used for the benefit of a person or a small group of people, but the trustees decide when, and in what way, and how much, and in what shares, etc.

In general, Irish tax law does not favour the establishment of discretionary trusts. In some countries discretionary trusts are used to shelter family wealth from tax; that doesn't work in Ireland. Without going into detail, if you put money into a discretionary trust in Ireland you will usually end up paying more tax, not less, than you would have done without the trust. So they are not much used.

(Also, relevantly to your query, in general putting money into a trust is not a disposal for CAT purposes; CAT arises when money comes out of the trust, to the beneficiaries. So if you put €3k per year into a trust for (say) 10 years, and then the trustees decide to pay €30k plus accumulated earnings out to one of the beneficiaries, that's not 10 annual gifts of €3k; it's one gift of €30k-plus. So this isn't an effective way to access and utilise the annual small gift exemption.)

Having said all that, there are special rules affording more favourable treatment for a discretionary trust set up to meet the needs of a person with an incapacity. Obviously we don't know whether your child's issues would amount to a incapacity; they would need to be issues that mean the child is incapable of managing their own affairs. Plus, to qualify for relief, the trust would have to be used exclusively to meet "qualifying expenses" for the incapacitated child; treatment costs, maintenance costs, that kind of thing. The bottom line here is that, if you're looking at a discretionary trust for an incapacitated child, you will need professional advice that looks at your circumstances, and your child's, in more detail than is possible (or appropriate) on an anonymous internet forum. All we can really do is point out that a discretionary trust can be a viable option in relation to a child who is unable to manage their own affairs and, if you if think it might be of benefit in the circumstances of your family, you should go and get professional advice.

The other bottom line is that the overheads of setting up and running a discretionary trust of this kind are probably disproportionate to the value of the trust, if all you're thinking of putting in is €3k or €6k per year for a number of years. They are more commonly used in connection with a will, where an incapacitated person is inheriting hundreds of thousands of euros.

The other, other bottom line is: don't let the tax tail wag the estate planning dog. These are your children; they can receive up to €400,000 each from you free of CAT. Plus, they are adults and perhaps are, or in a few years will be, earning salaries of their own. The annual small gift exemption on top of that is chickenfeed, frankly. If your child with issues has particular needs, focus on designing arrangements that will meet those needs and then worry about those arrangements might be tweaked to make them tax efficient. Do not start with the small gift exemption and then design arrangements with the primary purpose of utilising that. The small gift exemption is not the important thing here.
 
Last edited:
Thank you to all who gave you advice and time to the above - I really appreciate it.
Child B has addiction issues.
 
In my experience, adult children do not access the money, they understand that their parents are doing it for a house deposit etc. In fact, they tend to show little to no interest in the plans. If you have a child with addiction issues, there is a real danger of them using the money to feed their addiction, so a trust is the correct structure for the gift to this child.


Steven
http://www.bluewaterfp.ie (www.bluewaterfp.ie)
 
Child B has issues which means that we may not ever wish for him to be able to access the money himself and we would be thinking of a trust of some kind for Child B .

Child B has addiction issues.
One of my grandparents left their home to a child as a life interest, in order to ensure housing on death. House would become theirs on marriage, if no marriage, on death of child to all siblings. This worked out perfectly well. Adult child with addiction had a home well into old age, were then moved into a care home for a couple of years, on death house sold and distributed the children, including children of a deceased parent.

- There was no “fair deal” as child owned nothing.
- adult child was able to take care of themselves
- not able to organise things like cutting the lawn, taken care of by siblings
- periodic clear out by siblings, but individual was clean, more a disposal of accumulated items, it never was dirty, but a weekly housekeeper would solve such situations
- I’ve no idea about house insurance, I’d imagine never paid or even thought of
- repairs, I recall after maybe 30 years the windows needed replacing, and two siblings got that done under some special grant/scheme
- in later life the adult child could go down town for a daily meal etc they had the dole and could afford it, I think it’s a bit like meals on wheels, so very cheap
- the house was in limbo for a couple of years when the adult child was in the care home
- I can remember the addiction issues, in later life that stopped being an issue, it was not an absolutely desperate situation

But the main thing that helped was they were freely housed and were not causing any problems. Or relatively few problems.
 
Back
Top