Should there be qualified majority voting on defence in EU?

Dinarius

Registered User
Messages
687
Currently, there has to be unanimity in EU voting on matters of defence. This allows, for example, Germany (Israel) and Hungary (Ukraine) to stymie the wishes of what might otherwise be a qualified majority.

Isn’t this a case of the rights of the few - potentially only one country - being allowed to trump the common good of the many?

Qualified majority voting exists in the EU for many issues. I find it alarming that it doesn’t for defence. German guilt and Orban’s toadyism are not reasons to retain the status quo.


D.
 
Surely Gaza is not a matter of EU Defence, as distinct from Ukraine which is a matter of European defence?

It is a matter of war crimes and genocide. That the EU is divided on this, in any way, makes a farce of the EU.
 
Last edited:
I take your point. But, if the Israel treatment of the aid flotilla, for example, was deemed to put EU citizens at risk, and that a unified response was required, it would require all 27 to vote in favour, no?

You're absolutely right about the issue of war crimes and genocide; I was simply citing Gaza as a possible example of a situation where EU interests might require defending. But, undoubtedly our main defence interests lie to the east.

Another reason for an EU defence alliance is that reliance on NATO means reliance on the USA, which we can no longer depend on - and, I think Trump has a point when he says that Europe needs to get its act in gear.

D.
 
But, if the Israel treatment of the aid flotilla, for example, was deemed to put EU citizens at risk,
They were never at risk, its a publicity stunt. Need to listen to RTE with a good pinch of salt. Brian Keenan would be laughing at them.
 
Isn’t this a case of the rights of the few - potentially only one country - being allowed to trump the common good of the many?
The alternative is that an alliance of France and Germany effectively determines whether the rest of the EU goes to war.

Are we ready for that possibility?
 
if the Israel treatment of the aid flotilla, for example, was deemed to put EU citizens at risk, and that a unified response was required, it would require all 27 to vote in favour, no?

No. In international waters every nation has autonomy to defend its citizens. Ideally, the wholesale unity of the EU for the protection of EU citizens would be a powerful deterrent, but it is not required.

EU defence alliance is that reliance on NATO means reliance on the USA, which we can no longer depend on - and, I think Trump has a point when he says that Europe needs to get its act in gear.

I think Trump does have a point for Europe to get its act in gear. I couldn't welcome more wholesomelly the withdrawal of all US military personnel to go back behind the borders where they belong.
They were never at risk, its a publicity stunt.

That is disengenuous. The Mavi Marmara, was attacked by Israeli forces on 31 May 2010 in international waters and nine activists were killed.

Israel does what it wants, no problem - Genocide in Gaza, bomb negotiators in Qatar, seize EU citizens (and Americans) in international waters, block peaceful attempts to provide humanitarian aid.

How can you assume they were never at risk?
 
Because they would not have went if they thought they were. I trust them to know.
Like those on the Mavi Marmara?

Incidentally, are you aware of the publicised drone attacks on the Sumud flotilla?
Are you aware that travelling peacefully in international waters their vessels were invaded by armed personnel who had no legal authority to do so?
Not only that, they were then unlawfully detained against their will, in international waters, and denied their liberty by armed thugs who have no legal authority to do so?
 
Currently, there has to be unanimity in EU voting on matters of defence.
The Common Security and Defence Policy obliges EU States to aid each other of one is attacked. We have a derogation where we can offer our usual tea and sympathy instead of anything meaningful. That said we are a member of PESCO (Permanent Structured Cooperation) so our Armed Forces are aligned to EU (effectively NATO) standards and could be folded in to an EU wide force is the need arouse.
The only unit that could offer any meaningful contribution is the Rangers as they already train with their international counterparts.
 
Back
Top