Moneymakeover Sell Rental Property to become debt free?

Nutso

Registered User
Messages
699
Personal details
Your age: 49
Your spouse's age: 55
Number and age of children: 1, 16yrs

Income and expenditure
Annual gross income from employment or profession: 55,000 approx including bonus
Annual gross income of spouse/partner: nil at present, expect at least 55,000 once employment sourced

Monthly take-home pay: 2,800 at present, expected minimum 5,600 once spouse finds employment

Type of employment - Employee
Employer type: Private

In general are you:
Could manage on current income, but there would be little left over for extras. Spouse living off savings, I am currently saving from my income.

Summary of Assets and Liabilities
Family home value: 400k (estimate - relatively new build would cost approx 547k to build now based on build costs)
Mortgage on family home: 53k
Net equity: 343k

Cash: 15k (repaid approximately 32k debt recently which has lowered cash reserves).

Buy to Let Property value: 500k approx
Buy to let Mortgage: 120k
Net Equity: 380k

Total net assets: 738k

Family home mortgage information
Lender - BOI
Interest rate - 3.4% fixed for 5 years (fixed Jun-25)
If fixed, what is the term remaining of the fixed rate? 4.75 years

Remaining term: 12 years
Monthly repayment: €521 (includes max over payment on fixed rate of 10%)

Other borrowings – car loans/personal loans etc
Do you pay off your full credit card balance each month? Yes
If not, what is the balance on your credit card?

Pension information
Value of pension fund: 40,000 PRSA
Spouse: 51,000 PRSA

Buy to let properties
Value: 500k approx
Rental income per year: 24.5k
Rough annual expenses other than mortgage interest : 8k last year however this included boiler replacement of 5k, so 3-4k probably similar average cost
Lender: PTSB
Interest rate: Tracker ECB +0.8%
Monthly repayment: 1755
Remaining term: 7 years

Other savings and investments:
None

Other information which might be relevant
Life insurance: Mortgage insurance only on both properties - in the event that one of us dies mortgages will be repaid.

What specific question do you have or what issues are of concern to you?
Weighing up selling the rental property and repaying both mortgages.
The new rules due are a concern if required to sell with tenants insitu as we are below market rent in RPZ and low % margin for investors considering purchase. Due to their long tenancy they would be entitled to 224 days notice.
Both of us have low pensions and were accidental landlords due to the housing crash and both of us losing our jobs in construction in 2010. The plan was always that we would hold on to the rental property as a pension, however running some rough figures seems to give the same benefit to selling as holding on to the house for 10 years, but without the headache of looking after the property, tax returns etc.
My thoughts would be to take the balance after debts are cleared and hold in a high interest or low risk investment account, then paying the max tax efficient amount each year to our pensions. Possibly also make some home improvements such as PV panels, reducing home running costs further.
CGT won't be an issue as we bought in 2007 and are unlikely to make a profit after stamp duty, conveyancing fees, stamp duty, loan for refurbishment etc is taken into consideration. It would have to go for more than 530k before CGT would be payable. Location is central north Dublin city.
Having family home mortgage paid would give good security and lower outgoings.
Child plans to attend university in 3 years and would allow saving for this.
Am of the mind that I would rather have a nice life, experiences etc rather than hold on to property for the sake of having assets. In addition I feel it's unlikely that child will wish to attend university in Dublin, which was another reason we were holding on to the property.
Long notice period for tenants would bring us into May, this may not be the best time for selling.

Are there any other factors I should take into consideration?
 
Last edited:
Gross income 24.5k
Net income last year was 10.5k (before capital allowances - 9.5k after capital allowances), likely closer to 15k this year if no other major repairs required, not on notice of anything major required.
 
Your monthly take-home pay looks low to me given your circumstances. Are you sure that figure is correct?

Net rental profit of €15k on a €500k property equates to a 3% net yield. That’s pretty underwhelming TBH.

If I was in your shoes, I would sell the rental, clear your debts and focus on funding your pensions.
 
Monthly take home is my income, excluding bonus, which is usually paid in December. Most years, most of the bonus is used to pay my income tax due on tax return.
Spouse has worked abroad for a number of years but is not currently working and payments have been sporadic for the last 24 months.
 
First of all, look at the investment as a stand alone investment.
Net investment: €380k

Rent: 24k
Interest €120k @ 3% = €4k
Expenses :€5k
Profit before tax: €16k
Profit after tax: €8k

So that is a net return of 2%.

You are paying 3.4% on your mortgage, so that is a better return but it's only €53k so immaterial.

Would I hold onto this investment?

Probably not given the worries about the uncertainty over the future legislation which could permanently impair its value e.g. if you were obliged to sell it with the tenant in situ.

So on its own merits, it should be sold.
 
When you now look at the overall context, the decision to sell is even clearer.

You can pay off your home loan which will get you a return of 3.4% net.

Your pensions are underfunded so this will allow you fund maxing your pensions over the next few years.

And you face third level costs.

So everything screams "Sell now while you can!"
 
Deekie - that's untested at the moment but I hope he'll be able to find something.
Thanks all for your comments. It was only when I ran figures the other day that it seemed to make sense, just wanted to make sure that I wasn't missing something.
 
BTL should be sold as there is a lot of equity, no CGT and a very low return. I’d be buying a new rental with the proceeds, one with a decent yield, instead of paying off the home loan.

Pensions need to be increased.

Getting a job at age 55 could be an issue. Even a minimum wage job like Dunnes would surely bring in 30k.

OP has not mentioned state pension eligibility. That’s VERY important.
 
Bronte - apologies I missed your post originally.
I expect to have full state pension eligibility. I need to check my spouse's record but I expect he should have roughly 20 years contributions to date with another 10 assuming he remains in Ireland - would that give him 75% of the state pension?
 
I need to check my spouse's record but I expect he should have roughly 20 years contributions to date with another 10 assuming he remains in Ireland - would that give him 75% of the state pension?
Should do. 30 years or 1,560 reckonable contributions would mean 3/4ths or 75% of the full rate pension.
 
Back
Top