Saipan

Sister Sara

Registered User
Messages
272
Fearing the worst that old wounds may open sending the country spiraling into an 'unfinished' civil war, I took time to go see Saipan.

Fortunately, it appears to me that the old wounds only affect the generation of people that lived through it, and we are all 26yrs older now with better things to be getting on with. My 36yr old companion had no recollection of the events, and she observed that the demographic of the audience was heavily in the 50yrs+ category.

The movie is good and in fairness I think it deals with all the substantive points in a fair, accurate and balanced way. Very accurate, I would say.
Hardwicke (Keane) and Coogan (McCarthy) are excellent in my opinion.

There is some good humour in the movie and the mood, soundtrack, and montages certainly help the flow of the story.

Without going over all the rights and wrongs, my view at the time was I with McCarthy. That Keane had over-stepped the mark.

Over the years, it was Keane who right. The preparation for the WC was an absolute shambles, a joke. But when it comes to the showdown team-meeting - hard to argue against that Keane over-stepped the mark. There was certainly a personal grudge and disdain that Keane had against McCarthy.

Its not a rush-to-the-cinema movie, it will be easily as enjoyable on TV at home. Worth a watch 6/10, (7/10 if you there at the time)
 
I'd agree with you I think. I was in the McCarthy camp too at the time and in fairness the team did pretty well.
I remember in the penalty shootout going mental shouting at Given to not dive early because it seemed like every time the Spanish
were aiming for the middle of the goal.
I quite like Mark Kermode and he gave it a good review too. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SOwhAK5YvQ
 
The film is a dramatisation and isn't factual that puts me right off and won't be watching. If youre going to make a film about real events they they should make it as it happened.
Getting tired of these dramatisation that conflate fact with fiction all in the pursuit of drama.



 
Last edited:
hard to argue against that Keane over-stepped the mark. There was certainly a personal grudge and disdain that Keane had against McCarthy.
I always admired the way Keane overcame the massive disadvantage he was born with and went on to be so successful.
The massive disadvantage is, obviously, being from Cork ;)
 
I was in the McCarthy camp too at the time. I always did admire Keane though for his honesty as a player and as a pundit. He is 100 per cent behind everything he says. About Ferguson, the ' prawn cocktail crowd'
About the Saipan debacle etc.
Who knows how the team would have done if everything had been normal that year.. We can only wonder.
 
The film is a dramatisation and isn't factual that puts me right off and won't be watching. If youre going to make a film about real events they they should make it as it happened.
Getting tired of these dramatisation that conflate fact with fiction all in the pursuit of drama.

That is the purpose of dramstisation is it not? Otherwise just make a factual documentary?

That said, it is important to get some details correct while others are quite trivial or irrelevant. The Keane attack on McCarthy for being English is, to my surprise not true (I remember the reports about it and took it as true). So now to discover that it is not true, I'm taking two points of the scoring. It is bad form on the part of the director to have included this.

Criticisms over height and age are trivial and irrelevant imo.
 
Over the years, it was Keane who right. The preparation for the WC was an absolute shambles, a joke

Wrong! Wrong! Wrong! Pure Keane_spin. Saipan wasn't about preparation, it was about rest and recreation after a long English soccer season. It was about unwinding, bonding and team building. But Keane arrived deeply depressed and aggresssive and was, I suspect, psychologically incapable of unwinding or relaxing. Hence the predictable and inevitable eruption that ensued.

Can anyone else remember the photos of him sitting on the floor in Dublin Airport and effectively shunning the then Taoiseach - a fanatical Man U supporter - who had turned up to give his best wishes to the team? (Bertie may have been a complete [insert your own adjective here] but as our Taoiseach he was entitled to a bit of respect.)
 
Wrong! Wrong! Wrong! Pure Keane_spin. Saipan wasn't about preparation, it was about rest and recreation after a long English soccer season. It was about unwinding, bonding and team building.

Half-right! Half-wrong!

Have I opened old wounds? :p

Yes, rest and recreation, unwinding, bonding and team building was certainly a key objective of McCarthy's preparations. But as I recall, for about 4-5 days. Not a holiday, but very light routines, exercises etc with ample to time to wind down, golf, swimming, and a bit of a party.

Then the preparation would begin in earnest with a couple of days of proper training before flying to Japan, where a weeks intensive/match-fit training would occur. That's how I recall the preparation was to occur.

And I agree, Keane's attitude was wrong from the off. He had a personal grudge against McCarthy.

That said, the standard of the hotel, the training and gym facilities, catering, travel arrangements were sub-par for professional athletes representing their country going into an international competition.

If we want our elite national athletes to have a bit of a bender then why not a 3-star hotel with inadequate facilities and equipment?

Or, as highly paid professionals - earnings made from football fans attendance, TV subscriptions, should we not expect to prepare to the highest standard in advance of a tournament?

How would our emerging top Athletics athletes prepare in advance of the Olympics? A jolly-up for the boys and girls?
 
Uplifting to know that our rugby lads are currently training around the clock in The Algarve for the big game in Paris next Thursday! (But it leads me to wonder why the flight to Faro included 27 sets of golf clubs, 20 surf boards and 88 geisha girls.)
 
Uplifting to know that our rugby lads are currently training around the clock in The Algarve for the big game in Paris next Thursday! (But it leads me to wonder why the flight to Faro included 27 sets of golf clubs, 20 surf boards and 88 geisha girls.)
The real mystery is where they got 88 geisha girls in Ireland!
 
A great player but somewhat spoiled my trip to Japan for the World Cup as it definitely lessened our chances and polarised the travelling support who split between the two protagonists.
By common consent all discussions on the matter were avoided .
I never really forgave him , a contrarian always in search of an argument who previously avoided a number of Irish games as it didn’t suit him .
 
Back
Top