Sister Sara
Registered User
- Messages
- 272
Fearing the worst that old wounds may open sending the country spiraling into an 'unfinished' civil war, I took time to go see Saipan.
Fortunately, it appears to me that the old wounds only affect the generation of people that lived through it, and we are all 26yrs older now with better things to be getting on with. My 36yr old companion had no recollection of the events, and she observed that the demographic of the audience was heavily in the 50yrs+ category.
The movie is good and in fairness I think it deals with all the substantive points in a fair, accurate and balanced way. Very accurate, I would say.
Hardwicke (Keane) and Coogan (McCarthy) are excellent in my opinion.
There is some good humour in the movie and the mood, soundtrack, and montages certainly help the flow of the story.
Without going over all the rights and wrongs, my view at the time was I with McCarthy. That Keane had over-stepped the mark.
Over the years, it was Keane who right. The preparation for the WC was an absolute shambles, a joke. But when it comes to the showdown team-meeting - hard to argue against that Keane over-stepped the mark. There was certainly a personal grudge and disdain that Keane had against McCarthy.
Its not a rush-to-the-cinema movie, it will be easily as enjoyable on TV at home. Worth a watch 6/10, (7/10 if you there at the time)
Fortunately, it appears to me that the old wounds only affect the generation of people that lived through it, and we are all 26yrs older now with better things to be getting on with. My 36yr old companion had no recollection of the events, and she observed that the demographic of the audience was heavily in the 50yrs+ category.
The movie is good and in fairness I think it deals with all the substantive points in a fair, accurate and balanced way. Very accurate, I would say.
Hardwicke (Keane) and Coogan (McCarthy) are excellent in my opinion.
There is some good humour in the movie and the mood, soundtrack, and montages certainly help the flow of the story.
Without going over all the rights and wrongs, my view at the time was I with McCarthy. That Keane had over-stepped the mark.
Over the years, it was Keane who right. The preparation for the WC was an absolute shambles, a joke. But when it comes to the showdown team-meeting - hard to argue against that Keane over-stepped the mark. There was certainly a personal grudge and disdain that Keane had against McCarthy.
Its not a rush-to-the-cinema movie, it will be easily as enjoyable on TV at home. Worth a watch 6/10, (7/10 if you there at the time)