RTE interview with James Browne, Minister for housing (21 Oct)

That we are even allowed to have this discussion here now is extraordinary. I fully expected my initial post raising the issue to be deleted and the post closed. For years since the migration project began in earnest in 2022 any dissention has been ruthlessly suppressed. Any one who raised concerns was immediately labelled racist and a far right extremist. Sinn Fein even tried to have an amendment added to the hate speech bill that would have criminalized criticism of migration policy. We have also been conditioned to ignore the evidence of our own eyes and ears in relation to our streets becoming less safe and who was being given "social" housing in all the new estates being built to address the "housing crisis" RTE with their €750 million in state funding and all the mainstream media outlets have been fully on board. Only X with its right wing extremists has challenged what we are being told.
Two major narratives have been to the forefront

1. Migrants coming here are "doctors and engineers" . Health workers necessary for our health service and those coming to fill skill shortages. And an economic benefit to our country
2 Alternatively they are refugees fleeing "war and persecution" and we have "international obligations" to accept and support them.

Although though it may already be too late at least it is becoming more generally accepted to at the least question migration policy. Ireland has had massive wealth over the last few years. Most of the corporate billions have been used to fund this policy. We are only beginning to see the results.
 
Alternatively they are refugees fleeing "war and persecution" and we have "international obligations" to accept and support them.

The Taoiseach has stated that 80% of AS are actually economic migrants.

The 94 American AS are clearly not fleeing "war and persecution". The same goes for all AS from Albania, Georgia, etc.
 
1. Migrants coming here are "doctors and engineers" . Health workers necessary for our health service and those coming to fill skill shortages. And an economic benefit to our country

This is generally true, in respect of those with work visas.

They typically:
(1) fill skills shortages
(2) pay income tax
(3) don't claim social assistance
(4) don't apply for social housing



It is not true in respect of UKR refugees and bogus AS, who both impose huge costs on taxpayers.
 
Minister for Social Protection, Dara Calleary, in response to a parliamentary question from Deputy Nolan, show that of people receiving social protection payments 347,736 were recorded as holding a non-Irish nationality:

------

Minister for Housing James Browne said that nationally around 50% of those in emergency accommodation are non-Irish citizens, and in Dublin that figure is 58% and rising.
He added that they have "every right to housing".
Speaking to RTÉ's This Week, Mr Browne said: "They have a right to remain here, but they do tend to have, I suppose, a bigger challenge around socio-economics, around being able to afford a home, and what we're trying to do is find a way to provide them with homes as well.

---------

These figures exclude the 128,000 migrants that have been granted irish citizenship since 2016.
Unlike other countries there is no requirement to be self supporting or to be able to speak basic english to get citizenship
 
Most of the corporate billions have been used to fund this policy
Any figure? Do you mean that most of the 28 billions that foreign own multinationals multinationals paid in 2025 have funded the migration policy?
Minister for Social Protection, Dara Calleary, in response to a parliamentary question from Deputy Nolan, show that of people receiving social protection payments 347,736 were recorded as holding a non-Irish nationality:
Among them, 182000 are receiving child benefit, often for Irish children. There are also about 11k receiving contributory old age pension.
 
Another entertaining interview with Minister Browne who won't answer the question about when rent levels will reduce.

Obviously rent levels will never go down, no more than the price of cars or Cadbury's Dairy Milk will ever reduce. But of course the minister is afraid to say it out loud.

The worrying thing is the level of anger in the comments, ranging from frustration to out and out landlord bashing. Great fuel to the fire for far left and far right parties.
 
Why does Ireland need such a large number of new houses and apartments every year and who are they for?

Sinead O'Sullivan lays out why Ireland is failing on housing, health etc in a lengthy article (while long her articles are enjoying to read)

https://www.butthistime.com/p/gaslighter-denier

She basically produces a four strands template as to the why and characterises this as the political parties and politicians over the last decade or so gaslighting the people they're supposed to serve.

First is the economic model around foreign direct investment only or mainly which in turn has become a tax dependency due to the largely multinational company based corporation tax take the model brings in, second this model requires mainly immigrant labour with nearly 2/3 of job growth going to non-Irish and this brings with it increased housing needs, third is the delivery inability or unwillingness perhaps of failing to provide new homes, hospitals, schools, GPs etc for the new population and people born here, fourth is the fighting of this inability or policy decision to fail to solve problems with throwing billions on these issues such as HAP, treatment purchase outside the state which perhaps makes the problems even worse by not addressing the root causes in each area.

It's worth a read.

1795203504195.webp
 
Back
Top