Hi all,
Looking for opinions on whether to keep or sell my first home. Posted on a different forum and while i was leaning towards keeping , i am confused again
Property 1: Bought in 2019 for €180k, now worth around €340k, with only €36k left on the mortgage (€900/month at 4.15% variable). It’s a 2-bed/2-bath end-of-terrace with a large south-facing garden.
An estate agent has advised it would rent for around €2,300/month. Gross yield is around 8.1%, but after management fees, insurance, maintenance, 5% vacancy allowance and tax, I'm estimating the net yield at around 3.1–3.4%.
Our forever home cost €450k and has a €396k mortgage with 29 years remaining. We're currently paying €1,960/month at 4.15% variable, although I can fix for four years at 3.2%, bringing this to around €1,750/month.
For context:
So essentially:
Keep: Rent it for €2,300/month and retain a property with very little debt as a long-term asset. I'd then try to make overpayments on our main mortgage.
Sell: Use the roughly €300k equity to knock a large chunk off the €396k mortgage, increase our emergency savings and maximise my pension/AVCs. Beyond that, I'm honestly not very investment savvy and wouldn't really know what I was doing with ETFs or shares.
I was leaning towards keeping it because of the 8.1% gross yield, but the 3.1–3.4% net yield has made me question whether having €300k+ equity tied up in a rental makes sense while carrying such a large mortgage on our family home.
What would you do: keep the rental or sell and significantly reduce the mortgage?
Thank you for your advice!
Looking for opinions on whether to keep or sell my first home. Posted on a different forum and while i was leaning towards keeping , i am confused again
Property 1: Bought in 2019 for €180k, now worth around €340k, with only €36k left on the mortgage (€900/month at 4.15% variable). It’s a 2-bed/2-bath end-of-terrace with a large south-facing garden.
An estate agent has advised it would rent for around €2,300/month. Gross yield is around 8.1%, but after management fees, insurance, maintenance, 5% vacancy allowance and tax, I'm estimating the net yield at around 3.1–3.4%.
Our forever home cost €450k and has a €396k mortgage with 29 years remaining. We're currently paying €1,960/month at 4.15% variable, although I can fix for four years at 3.2%, bringing this to around €1,750/month.
For context:
- Gross Salary: mine €84k (public sector) , partner 50k (semi state) , net home pay 7700 a month
- Pension pot: approx. €30k from previous employment for me
- No AVC's for my partner
- Haven't maxed my pension/AVCs
- Cash savings: approx. €12k
- Age: 37/partner 39
- We have a pre-schooler
So essentially:
Keep: Rent it for €2,300/month and retain a property with very little debt as a long-term asset. I'd then try to make overpayments on our main mortgage.
Sell: Use the roughly €300k equity to knock a large chunk off the €396k mortgage, increase our emergency savings and maximise my pension/AVCs. Beyond that, I'm honestly not very investment savvy and wouldn't really know what I was doing with ETFs or shares.
I was leaning towards keeping it because of the 8.1% gross yield, but the 3.1–3.4% net yield has made me question whether having €300k+ equity tied up in a rental makes sense while carrying such a large mortgage on our family home.
What would you do: keep the rental or sell and significantly reduce the mortgage?
Thank you for your advice!
Last edited: