Moneymakeover Rent out property or sell and pay down mortgage on main residence?

Tati2020

New Member
Messages
2
Hi all,

Looking for opinions on whether to keep or sell my first home. Posted on a different forum and while i was leaning towards keeping , i am confused again

Property 1: Bought in 2019 for €180k, now worth around €340k, with only €36k left on the mortgage (€900/month at 4.15% variable). It’s a 2-bed/2-bath end-of-terrace with a large south-facing garden.

An estate agent has advised it would rent for around €2,300/month. Gross yield is around 8.1%, but after management fees, insurance, maintenance, 5% vacancy allowance and tax, I'm estimating the net yield at around 3.1–3.4%.

Our forever home cost €450k and has a €396k mortgage with 29 years remaining. We're currently paying €1,960/month at 4.15% variable, although I can fix for four years at 3.2%, bringing this to around €1,750/month.

For context:

  • Gross Salary: mine €84k (public sector) , partner 50k (semi state) , net home pay 7700 a month
  • Pension pot: approx. €30k from previous employment for me
  • No AVC's for my partner
  • Haven't maxed my pension/AVCs
  • Cash savings: approx. €12k
  • Age: 37/partner 39
  • We have a pre-schooler
Another important factor is that Balbriggan has been my main residence, so if I sell now, my understanding is there would be no CGT on the gain.

So essentially:

Keep: Rent it for €2,300/month and retain a property with very little debt as a long-term asset. I'd then try to make overpayments on our main mortgage.

Sell: Use the roughly €300k equity to knock a large chunk off the €396k mortgage, increase our emergency savings and maximise my pension/AVCs. Beyond that, I'm honestly not very investment savvy and wouldn't really know what I was doing with ETFs or shares.

I was leaning towards keeping it because of the 8.1% gross yield, but the 3.1–3.4% net yield has made me question whether having €300k+ equity tied up in a rental makes sense while carrying such a large mortgage on our family home.

What would you do: keep the rental or sell and significantly reduce the mortgage?

Thank you for your advice!
 
Last edited:
I sold a second property last year that came back to my full control after divorce the year before. I concluded that becoming a landlord was too burdensome and risky for me. The regulatory environment for landlords has arguably become even more onerous and problematic since then. Hence the number of people avoiding or even actively getting out of the landlord business.


In my opinion you should sell and maybe focus on boosting your joint pension cover. But maybe a full Money Makeover would shed light on some reason that it might make sense for you to hold onto it...

 
Another important factor is that Balbriggan has been my main residence, so if I sell now, my understanding is there would be no CGT on the gain.
You have a year after it ceases to be your PPR to sell it and claim full PPR relief on any capital gain assuming that it was always your PPR and never rented out previously. After that year has elapsed some portion of the gain may be assessable for CGT.
 
Well would you buy a house for 340k to get around 4%, with a load of headaches for an inexperienced landlord who has a large home mortgage.

That’s a very tidy gain with no CGT! Interest rates are on the up - if it were me I’d put it on the market tomorrow.

You need to do the Money Makeover.

Have you ever been a landlord? Do you want to?

My view is to sell, reduce home mortgage, max out pensions. You need to think about a pension for spouse.
 
Last edited:
To put a number on the CGT point Premos and ClubMan made: Revenue counts the last 12 months of ownership as time you lived there, and the rest of the relief is split by years lived in over years owned (their Carla example on the PPR relief page works it the same way).
So if you lived there from 2019 to 2026, rented it out and sold in 2031 at today's €340k, you'd have owned it about 12 years with 8 counting as occupied. A third of the €160k gain would be taxable: about €53,300, less the €1,270 exemption, at 31% is roughly €16,100, before selling costs. Rent it for ten years instead and it's around €25,900, and any price growth on top gets taxed at the same fraction.
That's on top of the tax on the rent each year, which at your salary goes at 40% plus USC and PRSI.
 
Personal details

Your age: 36
Your spouse's age:
Partner's age if not married: 39

Number and age of children: 4-year-old


Income and expenditure
Annual gross income from employment or profession: 84600
Annual gross income of spouse/partner: 50000

Monthly take-home pay: 7600 combined

Type of employment - e.g. Employee or self-employed. Employee
Employer type: e.g. public servant, private company.

Me: Public servant

Partner: Semi state

In general are you:
(a) spending more than you earn, or
(b) saving?

I am generally saving rather than spending more than I earn. I have regularly saved approximately €2,000 + per month for the last five years.

Our current cash savings are relatively low because we used a significant amount of our savings towards the deposit for the second property + renovations

Our approximate monthly expenditure is:

Family home mortgage: €1,960

Childcare: €500

Household bills: €500

Groceries: €500-600

Regular savings: €2,000 -3000

Other expenses such as insurance



Summary of Assets and Liabilities
Family home value: 550000
Mortgage on family home: 396000
Net equity: 154000

Cash: 12000
Defined Contribution pension fund: I am a public servant and pay into a public sector pension scheme ( Single Public Service Pnesion scheme 2013) . I also have a separate defined contribution pension worth approximately €30,000.

My partner works in the semi-state sector and also pays into a public sector pension scheme. No avc’s

Company shares : None
Buy to Let Property value: 340000
Buy to let Mortgage: 36000

Total net assets: 500000 combined


Family home mortgage information
Lender - BOI
Interest rate – 4.15%
Type of interest rate: tracker, variable, fixed. variable Variable / 29 years term

If fixed, what is the term remaining of the fixed rate?
If tracker, what is the margin e.g. ECB + 1%

Remaining term: (Original term is not relevant) 29
Monthly repayment: 1960

Other borrowings – car loans/personal loans etc

Do you pay off your full credit card balance each month? No loans
If not, what is the balance on your credit card?

Pension information

ME: HSE Single Public Service Pension Scheme (2013), plus a separate €30,000 DC pension.

Partner: Semi-state/public service pension scheme.

Neither currently makes AVC contributions.

Buy to let properties
Value: 340000 bought for 180k in 2019
Rental income per year: Potential 27600 gross
Rough annual expenses other than mortgage interest : 3600
Lender BOI
Interest rate 4.15% 3.5 years left on the term
If fixed, what is the term remaining of the fixed rate?

Gross rental Yield 8.1% , with a net of approx. 3.2-3.4% net after tax.

The property has been my main residence until recently so no capital gains tax if I sell.

Other savings and investments: None


Other information which might be relevant


Life insurance: We both have life insurance for the home mortgage


What specific question do you have or what issues are of concern to you?

Our main dilemma is whether to sell the second property or retain it as a rental investment.

The property is currently worth approximately €340,000, with €36,000 remaining on the mortgage. It could potentially generate €27,600 gross rental income annually, representing a gross yield of approximately 8.1%.

However, after expenses, mortgage interest and tax, I estimate the net return on the equity tied up in the property would be approximately 3.2–3.4%.

We also have a substantial mortgage on our family home (€396,000 at 4.15%) could fix at 3.2% for 4 years.

If we sold the second property, we could potentially release approximately €304,000 before selling costs and any tax, which would allow us to significantly reduce our family home mortgage, and possibly be mortgage free in our early 40's

We are also both members of public service pension schemes, although neither of us currently makes AVC contributions.

Would we be better off selling the property, reducing our family mortgage and increasing our pension contributions, or retaining it for rental income and potential long-term capital appreciation?

Our priority is to build long-term financial security for our family and make sensible decisions for retirement.

Thank you!!



 
I'd agree with what all the other landlord and ex-landlord poster have said here.

You should ask yourself:

1. Have you studied the new rules? Are you willing to let your property in these circumstances with likely even more restrictions going forward

2. Have you studied all the criminal sanctions imposed on landlords generally for paperwork or filing mistakes?

3. Have you read the RTB case study posts on here showing the pro-tenant bias of the RTB and where landlords have to pay thousands in compensation to their tenants.

4. Could you cope with a situation where a malicious tenant who damages your property and doesn't pay rent is in situ for two or three years with the support of Threshold and the RTB. Will you have funds available to pay your legal costs?

Landlords on here with years of experience are getting out or reducing their exposure. I would think that demonstrates this is not the type of business for a novice to get involved in.

Also, does your 3.4% return take into account that money will have to be put away for refurbishment in the future. Kitchens, bathrooms, floors, furniture, white goods all need to be replaced and sooner rather than later if the tenant doesn't look after them.

Also, the only way to operate now (and even then it is risky) is to confine your tenants to the young, well off, professional and mobile. Is there a large market for that type of tenant where the house is? If not, you may ultimately end up playing social housing landlord to a long term tenant on a permanent basis.
 
Thank you!!
Firstly well done you on immediately responding to our advice to do the MM !

My advice is, sell investment, pay major chunk off home mortgage, sort out pensions ( not my expertise - as regards the investing bit - but my gawd we’ve benefited from all decisions we took in this) .

Aim to be mortgage free by 55. I think it’s of benefit to pay a mortgage until then. A) good discipline B) relatively speaking it’s saving C) banks like you - you NEVER know- easier to borrow when in the system D) 55 is a good age, it’s the pivot on job opportunities and health.

Have another child, or two. Costly. Very affordable for you.

Look closely at life insurance.

Have fun.
 
You shouldn't underestimate how fortunate you have been to buy a home in 2019 at age 30 and in the 7 yrs since then it has almost doubled in value... and you can now lock in that gain tax free.

Those rates of capital appreciation in property are unsustainable. Net rental yields are likely to stay flat or fall going forward due to rising costs, taxation and regulation limiting by how much you can raise rent to cover all those outgoings.

It might feel like a step back in wealth building to sell your first home because you go from having two properties to one. But by dramatically reducing your new home mortgage payments you free up cash flow to divert savings in to better yielding investments and reduce stress and complications in your life.

Given your age and secure jobs you are in a fantastic position to build wealth over the coming years and possibly retire early. You could both simply max out your AVCs and also annual contribution limits to the upcoming Personal Investment Account (PIA). Equity based investments in these two such as All World Index funds will likely yield you far greater returns with less risk and stress than holding on to property as an investment.

The value you and your partner could accumulate in your PIAs alone over the next few decades could help pay for the purchase of a property or many other options for you and your family.
 
It might feel like a step back in wealth building to sell your first home because you go from having two properties to one. But by dramatically reducing your new home mortgage payments you free up cash flow to divert savings in to better yielding investments and reduce stress and complications in your life.
Not to mention diversifying away from over concentration in a single asset class/geographic region - namely Irish residential property.
 
Back
Top