No increase to maximum payment levels for Jobseekers pay related benefit in Budget 2027.

This thread is about the lack of an increase in JPRB, not a discussion on Ireland's employment rate.
There may be a connection, though. If the government wants to increase the employment rate (and, spoiler, governments usually want this), and if it thinks that the rate of JPRB is a factor that influences people's decisions about working or not in the (from the government's point of view) wrong direction, then allowing the real value of JPRB to decline is a rational choice.
 
@TomEdison
JPRB is the only benefit payment available to workers who become fully unemployed. These are the people who have paid the increased rates of Prsi which the government raised for the purpose of giving these workers a pay related unemployment benefit.

These are the hard working people who have, mostly through no fault of their own, been made redundant. Their unemployment benefit is strictly time limited to 9 months and is reduced in three stages during this period.

These are the so called workers who get up early.

The government have reneged upon their unemployment benefit contract for these workers.

On the other hand the government continue to offer increased unemployment payments to long term claimers of means tested Jobseekers allowance. This is paid for unlimited time periods.

Workers who lose some employment, but continue to have part time or subsidiary employment have also been rewarded by having their unemployment entitlement increased in all recent budgets. They remain entitled to claim Jobseekers benefit.

To quote you, if the government wants to make a rational choice regarding not rewarding unemployment, they should stop budget increases to JA and JB.

JPRB should be index linked to inflation to support the unfortunate full time workers who suffer the indignity of full unemployment.
 
Last edited:
These are the hard working people who have, mostly through no fault of their own, been made redundant.
I agree with your post but can we stop saying that everyone who works is hard working? They might have had a nice easy job.

The pertinent point is that they paid their PRSI and many were on a good income so they will want to get back to work on a similar income and are not likely to go on "the social" as a lifestyle choice.
 
They might have had a nice easy job.
As in what type of employment?

What is easy for one person could be hell for another.

If a person is highly qualified or skilled they would generally find their work easy. These skills and qualifications are generally hard won and the worker is deserving of their rewards.
 
As in what type of employment?

What is easy for one person could be hell for another.
Sure, so one person might be working hard and the other finds it easy. Both are getting the job done and you should get paid for what you get done, not for how hard it was for you to do it.

If a person is highly qualified or skilled they would generally find their work easy. These skills and qualifications are generally hard won and the worker is deserving of their rewards
It's not a big deal, I'm just pointing out that the throw away phrase "hard working (insert person or job title)" is meaningless.

It's up there with "I worked hard all my life". That's just as stupid and meaningless. We shouldn't get a pat on the back for not dying young and who knows if someone worked hard at all, let alone worked hard all their life. If you retire at 65 and live until you are 85 then you definitely didn't work hard all your life. You'd have to keep working until you are 85 for that to have happened.

There are lots of highly paid jobs that are easier than lower paid jobs. If you work indoors and get to sit down when you are working (like I do) then you don't have a hard job. For example I don't think anyone would say that being an architect is harder than crewing a deep sea fishing boat but the architect gets paid more.

The subject of this discussion is pay related unemployment benefits. How hard you work and how well you are paid may have a nebulous enough relationship. One's pay is usually down to the economic value of your labour and the demand for that labour.
 
If you work indoors and get to sit down when you are working (like I do) then you don't have a hard job.
Lucky you, if you find that easy.

Sitting down indoors for an extended time period would be hell for me.
 
Last edited:
For example I don't think anyone would say that being an architect is harder than crewing a deep sea fishing boat but the architect gets paid more.

I think you might be surprised at how poorly architects can get paid.

And that’s after seven years of education / practice / exams.

I also wouldn’t say it’s a stree free job.

Of course there is some truth to your point but I think in general the link between higher pay and “harder” is stronger than portrayed.

Anyway regardless of how hard they are the ones paying the prsi but the increases go to those who don’t.
 
JPRB is the only benefit payment available to workers who become fully unemployed. . . . The government have reneged upon their unemployment benefit contract for these workers.
Robo — I am not saying that the government is right to do this. I am saying that this is a possible explanation for why the government does this.
 
I think you might be surprised at how poorly architects can get paid.

And that’s after seven years of education / practice / exams.
How long you spend training acquiring skills should have no bearing on what you get paid. What matters is the market value of the skills you acquired. My son is studying history and politics. He'll probably do a masters after his degree. The market for his skills is very limited and they are of a low market value.
 
How long you spend training acquiring skills should have no bearing on what you get paid. What matters is the market value of the skills you acquired. My son is studying history and politics. He'll probably do a masters after his degree. The market for his skills is very limited and they are of a low market value.
Sure. And therefore he's not making this investment in the expectation of enhancing his earning ability.

But if you want architects, or surgeons, or whatever, you need to recognise that it costs a great deal of money for someone to become an architect, surgeon or whatever — not just the actual costs of pursuing the course of study for so many years, but also the opportunity costs of not earning a salary, or having only very low earnings, for the many years that it takes to qualify. If people can't recover that investment, then many of them will be discouraged from making it, or will simply be unable to make it, and you will have trouble recruiting/retaining the number and/or quality of architects and surgeons that you want.
 
But if you want architects, or surgeons, or whatever, you need to recognise that it costs a great deal of money for someone to become an architect, surgeon or whatever — not just the actual costs of pursuing the course of study for so many years, but also the opportunity costs of not earning a salary, or having only very low earnings, for the many years that it takes to qualify. If people can't recover that investment, then many of them will be discouraged from making it, or will simply be unable to make it, and you will have trouble recruiting/retaining the number and/or quality of architects and surgeons that you want.
Exactly, so the market value is decided by the economic value of the job and the relative scarcity of labour. The supply of labour is determined by the expectation of future income and the investment in time and effort to acquire the necessary skills.

Very few people want to be Plasterers any more because it's highly skilled, physically hard, happens in a dirty and relatively dangerous environment and is in a cyclical sector. That's why good plasterers are charging €400+ a day. Same goes for Bricklayers.
 
Very few people want to be Plasterers any more because it's highly skilled, physically hard, happens in a dirty and relatively dangerous environment and is in a cyclical sector. That's why good plasterers are charging €400+ a day. Same goes for Bricklayers
Also the culture around the working from home phenomenon has made trades jobs even more unattractive relatively speaking in the last decade. If you are young and you see someone over in spain or portugal living in a holiday resort for a few months working as a "digital nomad", how is a trade going to compare with that? I think AI is threatening alot of those "dream jobs" now though.

Also physical trades like plasterers are very hard to do after 50 because your joints are wrecked ,walking around on those stilts are brutal for the knees
 
Not only that, but if made redundant. the cap of €600 weekly earnings for statutory redundancy has not changed in decades.
They basically fail to index everything they can get away with. That limit was set on 1 January 2005, and (per the CSO CPI calculator) would have to be €895.42 today to have kept up. Or the other way round, in real terms it is now worth €402.05, or 33% less.

You can play CPI bingo with basically anything. All the €1,270 allowances that were £1,000 converted to euro at €1.27... CGT allowance was set in 1980! It would be €6,415 today to have held the same value. In real terms, it's worth €251 today vs when it was set.

€115k income limit for pension contribution relief was set in 2011, where in 2008 it was at €275,239 and was indexed annually. Against 2011, it would be €155k today and in real terms is now €85k; against 2008 it would be €372k and in real terms is now the same €85k.

We lose so much to fiscal drag, but nobody seems to know much or care about it outside of pointy headed circles (present company etc etc)
 
Add to the list.

Age tax credit not increased.

Transferable 9k of 20% tax band between married couples has not increased.

Household benefits package electricity allowance has not been increased.
 
How long you spend training acquiring skills should have no bearing on what you get paid. What matters is the market value of the skills you acquired. My son is studying history and politics. He'll probably do a masters after his degree. The market for his skills is very limited and they are of a low market value.
Aren't those the exact qualifications you need to become Taoiseach? :D
 
Back
Top