New Comparison Tool for health insurance

quick update on this - ive been working on enhancing the site in the last few weeks.

one gap a few touched on was day-to-day cover (gp, physio, consultant etc) - it was basically a yes/no on whether a plan covered it or not. ive now gone each plan and pulled 19 separate data points just for day-to-day (the %, the €-per-visit cap, and the annual visit limit, across gp, nurse, consultant, physio, radiology, plus minor injury clinic). that's now properly factored into the score instead of a rough flag.

ive also added a scenario builder called "Total Health Costs" (https://www.medplan.ie/total-healthcare-costs) - you put in what a realistic year looks like for you (gp visits, hospital nights, procedures) and it works out the actual total cost - premium + whatever isnt covered - across every plan on the market, cheapest first. it also makes it easy to see where a lower premium with a higher excess/shortfall actually starts costing you more than a lower-excess plan, once you cross a certain number of nights or claims and also what effect the day-to-day benefits have on your annual health costs.

data extraction piece is more advanced so the plan data accuracy should be much better than before.

still in beta, would love more feedback like the last round - it was genuinely useful
 
Very impressive tool! One glitch I've observed on a Chromebook: after clicking Reset on My Priorities, the comparison chart displays blank.
 
Very impressive website. It was very easy to use on my android phone. I try to look at health insurance every year when it is up for renewal but this website is (by far) the easiest comparison tool I have seen.

Maybe the HIA should purchase the tool from you? I have bookmark the site to use again on the future - thanks again.
 
Really excellent job.
That four quadrant scatter diagram is the absolute business for giving a 40,000 foot view on things.
I recently moved to VHI and put quite a lot of work into choosing what I thought suited us best.
Once I entered my policy and set my priorities in the tool it was gratifying to see a nearly empty upper right quadrant.

By contrast if your lower left quadrant is empty you know you've picked an absolute turkey!

I'm seriously impressed, this is what the HIA site should be like.
 
Some additional feedback in this thread:


I've found that tool poor tbh (no offence to the creator!) It flagged plans as having better cover that didn't, they actually had worse cover so was wasted time looking at them - health insurance is a minefield so designing an app must be tricky so it's not meant as a criticism more a user warning.
I don't know if it changed since launch but I thought I remembered it being useful but when I checked it just now to compare my current plan (Level Health Plan B 300 Day To Day) against the market it also suggested plans as being cheaper with better cover which were not. :confused:
 
Both of us in our seventies. My main concern is heart related and my wife has lots of ortho problems. We are both on Prosper advanced and see they have cut the ortho to a 40% shortfall. Any good plans for end of this year. Very difficult to navigate.
 
We are both on Prosper advanced and see they have cut the ortho to a 40% shortfall.
This is a point that hasn't really been the case until a year or two ago, and its that many plans, including enhanced and high tech plans, are cutting benefits. Would be useful to have a way to cover that because it is the difference for some between staying on an expensive plan or cutting back because the benefit you were paying extra for is no longer there.
 
an expensive plan or cutting back because the benefit you were paying extra for is no longer there.

and if you do pay the extra to get the cover for ophth and ortho then they appear to put lots of high excesses and lower the day-to-day expenses cover. It is then a minefield to figure out which works best for each individual :(
 
Would be useful to have a way to cover that because it is the difference for some between staying on an expensive plan or cutting back because the benefit you were paying extra for is no longer there.
This is the problem. No credit for paying a high premium for years to ensure full coverage which can then be stripped away at next renewal.
 
Not can! it will be stripped away by the time you get out of the 2 year waiting list on your older plan. Impossible to get any value out of them from what I see yet they always seem to portray that caring attitiude.
 
eastmeath, I missed this when you first put it up - it will be very useful when it comes to renewing my cover. Thank you
:)
 
Back
Top