MFF high risk strategy is rated at risk level 4. Is this a bad deal for young participants?

Robovac rider

Frequent Poster
Messages
437
A young participant say mid twenties, will have a 40 year locked in investment span.

This is because MFF Retirement benefits are only allowed at age 66.

Risk level 4 is not the best strategy for this person.

They should be aiming for risk level 5 or 6.

While MFF offers very low management fees, this advantage will be more than cancelled out over the investment span because the investment gains will be reduced as the actual risk is set at a medium level.
 
Last edited:
Hopefully, they nudge the risk upwards over time.
That would be a massive political risk.

The members who have contracted into the MFF High risk strategy at level 4 would then have a case if their investments lost value as a result of a risk level increase without their consent.
 
Last edited:
The members who have contracted into the MFF High risk strategy at level 4 would then have a case if their investments lost value as a result of a risk level increase without their consent.
Surely the point of auto-enrolment is that consent is implied until opt out?
 
The point of auto enrolment is to force people into the scheme and make them responsible to opt out during a very limited time window.

Choice was given to people to opt for a risk level they are comfortable with or were given qualified advice to select.

Auto enrolment should not allow MFF management or the government the right to change a members chosen risk level.

The MFF high risk strategy has been set at level 4. If a person has chosen or been advised to opt for this strategy they have chosen or been advised to take on a medium risk level.
 
Last edited:
Risk level 4 is not the best strategy for this person.

They should be aiming for risk level 5 or 6.
Perhaps it's a case of not letting the perfect (higher risk/volatility funds most likely offering better returns over the long term) be the enemy of the good (getting people who might otherwise have no DC pension coverage into the net)?
 
Risk level 4 is not the best strategy for this person.
The Act agrees:
(3) The risk levels for the purposes of this Part are—
(a) the higher risk level, consisting of AE provider schemes with a risk rating of 5, 6
or 7,

(b) the medium risk level, consisting of AE provider schemes with a risk rating of 3
or 4,
(c) the lower risk level, consisting of AE provider schemes with a risk rating of 1 or
2,
Definition of Default Strategy
(4) Where subsection (2) does not apply, the appropriate risk level, subject to
subsection (5), is:
(a) where the period before the participant reaches pensionable age is more than 15
years, the higher risk level;
 
Last edited:
The plot thickens. The Irish Life fund is the only one that qualifies as High Risk. Does that mean that Irish Life is sweeping up the vast majority of MFF investments at this early stage
1793277512207.webp
 
The Irish Life fund is the only one that qualifies as High Risk.
This fund is currently shown as risk level 4 on the MFF website.


Screenshot_20261029-132459.webp
 
Last edited:
This fund is currently shown as risk level 4 on the MFF website.
I think the problem is with the PRIIPS regulations. It is essentially using recent past performance to determine risk levels and markets have been so positive you would need Bitcoin (or bonds :)) to reach the higher risk ratings :confused:
 
Last edited:
Does that mean that Irish Life is sweeping up the vast majority of MFF investments at this early stage
The website says your pension will be split between the three fund managers, but it doesn't say in what proportions.

MyFutureFund works with three different Investment Managers to spread out risk.
 
The website says your pension will be split between the three fund managers, but it doesn't say in what proportions.

MyFutureFund works with three different Investment Managers to spread out risk.
The Act allows that there can be any number of investment managers at each level but that allocation at each risk level will be divided equally amongst those that are available at that risk level.
AE Act said:
(2) Where there is more than one investment management provider, an amount to be
transferred under subsection (1) shall be divided by the Authority equally between the
providers.

The statement that MFF works with three different managers does not preclude there being only one for a particular risk level. Though I presume that all three funds have been divided equally notwithstanding that some (all) have not achieved risk levels higher than 4.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top