Man City debacle - will there be trouble for its auditors ?

trajan

Registered User
Messages
372
It says here that Manchester City FC overstated its income over the years of its current ownership by some £855 million.

I'm wondering where this reality leaves Man City's auditors. In recent years it's become normal for major companies to change auditors. But will that allow a departing audit firm to evade its responsibilities in having given the "true and fair" statement in previous years ?

I'm guessing that only Big 10 audit firms (or else a firm with special expertise in auditing of major sports clubs) would have the capabilities to deal with the various accounting and international tax law issues arising in such work.

And I'm remembering Enron and Arthur Andersen.

I suppose it highlights the moral hazards inherent in the higher professions. Take an honest path, you get a name among the business community of being an outrider for the tax office and struggling for clients. Take a more 'open' approach and you're a wideboy and someone no respectable person would want to be seen trading with.
 
Last edited:
From my perspective all we are seeing is further confirmation that vast sums of wealth concentrated in the hands of few ultimately breeds a culture of corruption. Juventus, Barcelona, Chelsea in recent times, and now Man City.

These are the ones that have been caught.

Infantino's relationship with Trump.

The attempted European Super League a few years back was nothing more than an attempt by the business side of elite clubs to set up a mouth-watering revenue stream and nothing to do with supporters, grassroots, tradition.

I'm sick of how this sport is 'governed'. I say this as a lifelong Liverpool supporter. Visited Anfield twice in last 3 yrs. The famous atmosphere is sucked dry by hoards of visiting tourists attending the game spending £££'s in souvenirs, jerseys. No harm to them (I'm one of them), but the business side of football is squeezing out the loyal local support in favour of us visiting supporters.

Get down to your local League of Ireland ground and dump this gross corruption.
 
Radical stuff, Sara !

I was wondering about more community ownership and elected administration of the pro clubs like continental clubs have - though most are just majority owned by members and have small shareholdings by say major sponsors. Bayern have small stakes owned by Allianz and Adidas. Real and Barça are 100% member owned.

If it was effected here, members would have to elect competent oversight committees so that the complexities of administration could be both monitored competently and explained fairly to members. The elected President and his/her team might not stay on the straight and narrow otherwise.

But tougher enforcement is needed too. A lot of solicitors firm have gotten into client account trouble as a result of small solicitors firms having no great accounting expertise but still handling very large sums from disposals, compensation claims, etc and also being the direct fee-payer to the barrister. It's easy to see how (for good reasons) they'd be tempted to pay out to a needy case from the client account even though the funds to validly make this payment hadn't yet arrived into the client account. Much more challenging scenarios arise within a LOI football club with players constantly looking for wages, bonuses, medical care expenses, etc and receipts form sponsors and gate takings being much slower.

Though I guess we have to sort out the FAI first. God Almighty - how could any financial controller face that job first thing on a Monday morning :eek:
 
A lot of solicitors firm have gotten into client account trouble as a result of small solicitors firms having no great accounting expertise but still handling very large sums from disposals, compensation claims, etc and also being the direct fee-payer to the barrister. It's easy to see how (for good reasons) they'd be tempted to pay out to a needy case from the client account even though the funds to validly make this payment hadn't yet arrived into the client account. Much more challenging scenarios arise within a LOI football club with players constantly looking for wages, bonuses, medical care expenses, etc and receipts form sponsors and gate takings being much slower.

This is a very valid point and goes to the heart of how the legal profession is governing itself.

It is however 2026, and a profession that is rooted in days of Magna Carta and before, needs also to recognise that it is increasingly subject to 'inadvertent practices' to put it mildly, and needs serious reform.

Standards have fallen and to such a point that entire industries or products are at now at risk.

Maybe I'm being over dramatic, but in my opinion the Premier League brand is seriously damaged over this affair.
 
Back
Top