Liability for a fire brigade charge

B

bond-007

Registered User
Messages
3,171
Just wondering, who is liable to pay a fire brigade charge? Is it the owner of a house or the person who called them out to a fire, eg a passerby?

Reason I ask is that the local council are chasing a person who does not own the house that the fire was in, he just happened to be passing and noticed flames and like a good citizen he called the fire brigade.

Now the council are chasing him for the money as he was the one that called them out. Surely this is wrong?
 
[broken link removed]?
Incident-related charges

 Most local Fire Services in Ireland will charge a flat rate of between 90 euro and 130 euro for attending a chimney fire or other domestic fire or emergency. If the Fire Services have to attend a fire or other emergency larger in scale than a domestic fire, such as a forestry fire or a fire at commercial premises, they will seek to recoup the entire cost of this service from the company or landowner. Generally, this cost would then be recovered by the landowner or company from their insurers.
Click to expand...
Sounds like the property owner is liable?
 
Seems non-sensical. Can you get hold of someone at senior level (SEO or Director of Services) and appeal to their common sense?
 
Most local Fire Services in Ireland will charge a flat rate of between 90 euro and 130 euro for attending a chimney fire or other domestic fire or emergency.
Click to expand...
Wow. For some reason I just assumed that our taxes paid for this in full.
 
efm said:
Well, if the fire happened in Cavan then there is no charge if someone dies - I still haven't decided if this is a good thing or not!
Click to expand...

That's an interesting one alright... hopefully it isn't for motivational purposes!:eek:

But in fairness it would save a lot of hurt and outrage if someone lost a loved one in a house-fire, and then got a bill from the Fire Brigade! So at least fair play to them for not being heartless bureaucrats.

...the local council are chasing a person who does not own the house that the fire was in, he just happened to be passing and noticed flames and like a good citizen he called the fire brigade.

Now the council are chasing him for the money as he was the one that called them out. Surely this is wrong?
Click to expand...

Actually, just had another thought on this. If people start to get the impression that calling a fire brigade to help others out could leave you with a bill, that can only result in someone, somewhere deciding not to bother, and a possible tragedy as a result. Those in charge should issue a press statement or something to clarify.
 
I was in a minor road accident last year caused by an old lady, she got quite a shock so I called an ambulance for her and the Gardai. seven minutes after the call the fire service appeared (the only serive I hadn't asked for!). About six weeks later I got a bill for €600 from fire service. Although they did a fine job on site, I didn't call them, didn't need them but since I made the call I was responible to pay.
 
Jack The Lad said:
Did you contest the legitimacy of the bill?

I presume your insurance covered it?
Click to expand...


The old lady admitted liability from the off. Thankfully nobody was hurt although I think her car was written off, So when I got the first bill I ignored it, the second one I give to my solicitor he passed it on to the ladies insurance company. I haven't heard anything since. If I ever witness an accident I 'll use a public phone or somebody else's phone to report it.
That day when I called I didn't give my name and when they asked me for my number, in the confusion I give them half of my current number and the second half of an old number, and they still found me. there's a lesson in there somewhere!
 
bond-007 said:
... the local council are chasing a person who does not own the house that the fire was in, he just happened to be passing and noticed flames and like a good citizen he called the fire brigade.

Now the council are chasing him for the money as he was the one that called them out. Surely this is wrong?
Click to expand...
I'm sure a newspaper somewhere would be interested in this, Good Samaritan left with huge bill etc. Reading this post, if I were to see a fire in the next while, I think I would ask first am I going to be charged and if they said yes, I would have to seriously consider what to do next.
 
DavyJones said:
The old lady admitted liability from the off. Thankfully nobody was hurt although I think her car was written off, So when I got the first bill I ignored it, the second one I give to my solicitor he passed it on to the ladies insurance company. I haven't heard anything since. If I ever witness an accident I 'll use a public phone or somebody else's phone to report it.
That day when I called I didn't give my name and when they asked me for my number, in the confusion I give them half of my current number and the second half of an old number, and they still found me. there's a lesson in there somewhere!
Click to expand...

Amazing.

Thanks for getting back with that info DJ, a real eye opener!
 
Reading this post, if I were to see a fire in the next while, I think I would ask first am I going to be charged and if they said yes, I would have to seriously consider what to do next.
Click to expand...
Weighing things up, this kind of crap wouldn't stop me calling the fire brigade if I saw a house on fire.
I can argue the bill later.
 
The fire brigade are looking for €600 for the call out which was to a private house. Seems way over the odds based on the figures quoted above.

I have told this person to write back to the council denying liability and asking them on what legal basis are they chasing him. We shall wait and see what response he gets.
 
some councils have a policy of sending fire brigade to every car accident - no need for them to be requested. Once 999 call is placed then fire brigade sent out.
 
sandrat said:
some councils have a policy of sending fire brigade to every car accident - no need for them to be requested. Once 999 call is placed then fire brigade sent out.
Click to expand...

I'm guessing that's partially to deal with oil-spillage, with a view to preventing another accident later on.
 
leghorn said:
Weighing things up, this kind of crap wouldn't stop me calling the fire brigade if I saw a house on fire.
I can argue the bill later.
Click to expand...


I agree with you, honestly, surely no one in their right minds wouldn't hesiitate to call the emergency services if they thought a life was at risk?
 
eileen alana said:
I agree with you, honestly, surely no one in their right minds wouldn't hesiitate to call the emergency services if they thought a life was at risk?
Click to expand...

presumably you mean

I agree with you, honestly, surely no one in their right minds would hesiitate to call the emergency services if they thought a life was at risk?
Click to expand...
 
Rmelly - Thank you for highlighting my error, very sweet of you, I did spot it after I posted and before I coud edit I had to go and see to a more pressing emergency:)
 
eileen alana said:
Rmelly - Thank you for highlighting my error, very sweet of you, I did spot it after I posted and before I coud edit I had to go and see to a more pressing emergency:)
Click to expand...

hope that emergency isn't going to cost you €600
 
Apologies for dragging this forum back into play here but the reason I have is because I was talking to a friend of mine today who told me that the fire brigade will charge the caller of a 999 call about €500 for the attendance regardless of whether it is a house fire (even if not own home!!) or a wheelie bin fire!! I would not believe her until I read the threads on this - surely this cannot be true? I thought this was a urban myth until now! I have just moved back from the UK where I lived a number of years and over there it is not an issue, you call the fire brigade to a situation you believe needs resolving without fear of getting an invoice - thats what Council Tax contributes to!) I appreciate that anyone with a conscience would not hesitate in calling the emergency services if it was warranted but unfortunately not everybody appears to have a conscience! Would the fear of getting a bill for several hundred euros actually put someone off from calling even for an apparently 'minor' incident such as an out of control bonfire near residential buildings, a potential forest fire or even the old chestnut of a cat stuck up a tree?? Please can anyone clarify this for me as I still refuse to believe that someone who is only trying to help their community can be financially punished for this?? Many thanks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top