Your argument in respect of 30k being paid to Law soc students just doesn't stand to reason. The bottom line is that a law soc student gets no more than 18k per annum after tax/prsi into his or her pocket. It may go some way to explaining why so many take on second jobs at bar work or waitressing. Furthermore, a lot of students are so desperate for apprenticeships that they are agreeing not to be paid during the course and to pay their own law soc fees, indenture registration fees etc.
As for why the fees are so high in the law soc, this is of little relevance to a student and doesn't alter the fact that the fees are prohibitively high, meaning many PPC students have to take out loans to fund their education. Regarding the teaching of trainee solicitors, while I would be of the opinion that the PPC1 remains at a high standard and is a good, intensive teaching course, I would argue that the PPC2 is of a poor standard to the extent that it is effectively a waste of over 4k. There is a huge amount of free time, topics are not considered in any depth and students are forced to pick subjects in areas of law which at that stage of their traineeship, they know they will likely never practice. Personally I think to scupper the PPC2 would be advantageous financially for both the law student and the training solicitor.
As for why the fees are so high in the law soc, this is of little relevance to a student and doesn't alter the fact that the fees are prohibitively high, meaning many PPC students have to take out loans to fund their education. Regarding the teaching of trainee solicitors, while I would be of the opinion that the PPC1 remains at a high standard and is a good, intensive teaching course, I would argue that the PPC2 is of a poor standard to the extent that it is effectively a waste of over 4k. There is a huge amount of free time, topics are not considered in any depth and students are forced to pick subjects in areas of law which at that stage of their traineeship, they know they will likely never practice. Personally I think to scupper the PPC2 would be advantageous financially for both the law student and the training solicitor.