Is Carton House committing commercial hari-kiri by making poor relations from county GAA squads when bigger fish come by . . .

trajan

Registered User
Messages
372
I wonder how many big professional soccer clubs come to Carton House Training Camps each year.

Maybe 2 or 3.

Yet hardly enough to chase off the county GAA squads filling the schedule in-between.

Putting aside the massive national mores faux-pas of their recent decision to snub Armagh county football squad's training camp so as to have soccer pitches ready for the Man United training camp, I doubt if such a decision is commercially sensible . . .

Unless Purple can explain to us otherwise, of course :)
 
I know very little about Soccerball or Football. More of a Hurling and Rugby man myself.

The question is on commercial viability of Carton House Training Camps without GAA clubs/county panels using it.
 
The question is on commercial viability of Carton House Training Camps without GAA clubs/county panels using it.
I know even less about that.
My autistic nerd-ism hasn't led me down that particular rabbit hole yet.
 
The question is on commercial viability of Carton House Training Camps without GAA clubs/county panels using it.
I don't think any of us have the pertinent information to answer that question, and perhaps Carton House management have already answered it.
 
. . . and perhaps Carton House management have already answered it.

You mean they "answered it" by their recent decision, i.e. that CH see creaming their clientele as more profitable than going mid-market ?

If so, I see no basis for this decision, as I implied in my question.
 
You mean they "answered it" by their recent decision, i.e. that CH see creaming their clientele as more profitable than going mid-market ?
They are a business and should be seeking to maximising their profits in the medium term.
In this case they have picked the more profitable of two UK sports teams. ;)
 
You mean they "answered it" by their recent decision, i.e. that CH see creaming their clientele as more profitable than going mid-market ?
Where is the evidence that the 'creamed' anyone? They are a business and not a charity, they should make commercial decisions on the basis of what is in the long term interest of their owners.

Lots of businesses offer different tiers or service to different their customers.
 
I saw a reference earlier to Carlton House picking the most profitable of the two UK teams.
Hardly the case , United lost £33 million last season , the sixth season in a row they have lost money .
Their current gross debt including borrowings stands at £1.3 billion .
They certainly have picked the most profligate of the two teams.
 
I saw a reference earlier to Carlton House picking the most profitable of the two UK teams.
Hardly the case , United lost £33 million last season , the sixth season in a row they have lost money .
Their current gross debt including borrowings stands at £1.3 billion .
They certainly have picked the most profligate of the two teams.
More profit for them. If they choose loss making Manchester United (the Catholic team in Manchester) or profit making Liverpool (the Protestant team in Liverpool) instead of a Gaelic football team from a different part of the UK what isn't losing money it's of no consequence to them. What matters is who is going to pay the most.
 

The exceptional facilities at Carton House enable teams to train, work and relax in a private and exclusive environment. The training facility hosts two full size soccer pitches, two full size rugby pitches and a GAA (Gaelic Football and Hurling) pitch of equal dimensions to Croke Park. The newly laid pitches, exclusively aimed at professional sporting teams, are conducive with top international professional standards. Located in a sheltered, fully enclosed section of the Carton House Estate the planning of the facility has been meticulous, ensuring both excellent pitch conditions and privacy.
-- from the CH website https://www.cartonhouse.com/meetings-events/training-facilities/training-camps


Well, the quotes from Armagh Gaelic football coach McGeeney and reports from those writing on the matter suggest that the GAA sized pitch was pre-marked for soccer. (Perhaps this was done due to the fact that Ireland can be rainy and intensive use of the 2 soccer pitches over the 3-4 day period Man United were there could have made them unsuitable for further training work, hence the third pitch was held in reserve for them and marked accordingly.) On discovering this McGeeney asked for the GAA pitch to be re-lined to GAA size, but this was not agreed to by CH management. Though we know nothing of the CH - Armagh GAA arrangements, the latter seem to have had a clear understanding that a GAA size pitch would be readied for them so they could do their prepping for the League Final against Tyrone.

Of course, CH may well have the contractual scope to do what they did - that's not the issue here and Kieran McGeeney can fight his own corner in any case.

My thoughts on this matter relate to the commercial viability of training camps aimed at exclusively high performance professional sports teams. Of course this question cannot be separated from the overall benefit to CH Hotel in its entirety since professional teams will likely spend much more on accommodation, specially-prepared food, beverages, use of the two attached golf courses, use of audio-visual rooms and analysis software, hire of special equipment, use of specialist medical services by players, in-hotel entertainments, etc.

Yet even despite the much higher total revenue per head resulting from prioritizing bookings from professional teams, I wonder if CH will be able to attain adequate occupancy from the latter group - whose custom must be highly coveted by other training venues not only the British Isles and continental Europe but also in resorts like the Caribbean, Dubai and Florida. Indeed, according to news reports, the decision for their recent training camp was only made after their exit from the FA Cup in mid-January. Other destinations like the Middle East were considered but the Iran War made that impossible and Carton House was fortunate in being a convenient fall-back alternative with a short flight and similar weather to MU's Carrington training centre.

As I see it, to get 2-3 of these professional soccer team camps a year would be very good going for an Irish venue. And despite the greater return per person during these camps, I do not see adequate return to justify the risk of excluding the revenue - and goodwill - from the much more frequent training camps for Irish amateur sports teams.

But that's just me, as the man said. And I'm someone who at times has a problem taking the hotel sector seriously let alone someone who knows the economics of operating a successful business in that sector. Hence my question.
 
If they choose loss making Manchester United (the Catholic team in Manchester) or profit making Liverpool (the Protestant team in Liverpool) . . .

This one deserves a leathering from old Brendan, Purple.

MU are not the Catholic team in Manchester - even in the days of no foreign players in English soccer. Neither was Liverpool the Protestant team in Liverpool. Rushy was a Catholic, as was Tommy Smith.

Both teams had a good mix of CoE, Methodist, Catholic, CoS, Baptist, JW, etc players and staff.

This is the first occasion I've ever heard of a major English soccer team being associated with any denomination.

And of course in today's Premier League, I would say the major denominations across all teams are Islam and none.
 
This is the first occasion I've ever heard of a major English soccer team being associated with any denomination.
My father lived in Liverpool in the 1960's and Liverpool was very much the Protestant team with Everton being the Catholic team. Now they are oligarch and Arab Oil teams.

Manchester United have a long connection with Ireland and Matt Busby was a devout Catholic, hence the association. Manchester City were founded by members of a Anglican Church. Now they are also oligarch and Arab Oil teams.
 
Back
Top