Irish Rail now strictly enforcing tickets

Brendan Burgess

Founder
Messages
58,598
I don't use the train that much and have always found it hard to predict my train times. It might be ok taking an early morning train to Cork, but what time would I return. Sometimes the ticket inspector told me I had booked a later train but never made an issue of it.

Now it appears that they are putting the boot in.


Jane could not book an open ticket for a return from Dublin to Portarlington because you can't book an open ticket online.
She travelled back on an earlier train than the train she booked.
The ticket inspector said she was on an early train and she needed to contact the office next day and gave her a piece of paper which she put in her pocket.
It turned out to be a fine of €126 for travelling without a ticket.

She appealed, but it was refused.

The nonsense of this is that I have free travel now. I can book a train and not travel on it.

This is not Ryanair. It's public transport in Ireland. People should be able to book open tickets, maybe without a reserved seat, and travel on whatever train they like, assuming there is room.
 
I'm wondering is this possibly due to (a) the increase in rail travel in recent years and (b) the similar increase in those entitled to free travel? I have seen incidents on trains recently where arguments break out over people sitting in pre-booked seats and refusing to give up the seat. There are clearly capacity issues at peak times and there may be a tightening of rules.

The days of almost empty trains on mainline routes might be over, as it's seen as a more viable option for a large cohort (and the fact that fares have reduced in relative terms in recent years.)

On an allied note, I was on a bus into town last week (E1) and I saw three fairly burly ticket inspectors join the bus - at around Leopardstown I think. One went upstairs while the other two positioned themselves in the space behind the stairs. They watched as people boarded, tapping their Leap cards and had some success with a few chancers at UCD skipping past the scanners. I suppose this is a good thing to see - I presume they have some data on fare dodging.


Iarnród Éireann delivered its strongest year ever in 2025, carrying 55 million passengers as demand continued to grow for intercity, commuter, and regional rail journeys.

Luas also celebrated a record‑breaking year, with over 55 million passenger journeys across the Red and Green lines.
 
So Irish Rail wants to distribute the load as much as possible.

The most heavily booked Cork to Dublin train is that 17.25. So they charge a bit more for that to encourage people to go on earlier or later trains.

The punter pays €30 for 17.25 but €25 for any other time.

But the punter shows up at 16.25 and happy days for Irish Rail. It takes the pressure off the 17.25.

The problem is if the punter books a specific seat on the 17.25 and Irish Rail can't sell it because it's booked and it goes empty.

A few solutions to that.
1) If you book a seat, you must travel on that train. A bit harsh.
1A) If you book a seat and want to travel on an earlier train, you must change it online or at the ticket desk and pay €10.
2) If you book a seat and want to travel on a later train, you must cancel the earlier booking and pay €10.
3) If you book an open ticket, you can't book a seat and you will be asked to wait until everyone who has booked has got on. A bit difficult to organise. Requires a lot of staff who will get a lot of hassle. But probably only at peak times.

But the overriding principle should be to encourage public travel and not to catch people out.
 
you can buy an open ticket at the station, just not online.

There is some logic to that. If you're present at the station ticket office or machine you're obviously travelling - and will be returning.

My guess is that people were booking without travelling in either direction. (There's a reason why you can only book an open return - and not an open outward journey.)

Edit: I may not be correct on the last part of the above - although I can't find any info on it.

Here's the AI answer:


No, you cannot book an "open" outward ticket online. Standard online tickets through the Iarnród Éireann website are time and date specific and include a mandatory seat reservation.
Irish RailIrish Rail +2
However, you can purchase an Open Return ticket at station ticket offices or vending machines. If you use an Open Return ticket, its outward portion is only valid for travel on the specific date shown on the ticket.
Irish RailIrish Rail +4
 
Last edited:
Financially isn't that good for Irish Rail if I book and don't travel? I assume an open ticket means a specific day.
 
So if I book a ticket and want to return on an earlier train, I go to the ticket office or machine and change it.

Seems reasonable.

If I travel later, it's a bit more problematic. I should cancel my original journey in good time.
 
1A) If you book a seat and want to travel on an earlier train, you must change it online or at the ticket desk and pay €10.
2) If you book a seat and want to travel on a later train, you must cancel the earlier booking and pay €10

This seems the logical solution. The pain is that if you buy a return ticket travelling for example Friday and Monday, you cant change the Monday return portion at all once the Friday ticket is printed/used. Not at the ticket desk or anything. It means if your business meeting finishes up an hour early or you get delayed on Monday, you need a whole brand new ticket. Poor service and a changeable ticket for a small admin fee is not a big ask.
As it stands if you go on a different train to one you booked you won't have a seat guaranteed so you lose out already compared to your original booking
 
There is some logic to that. If you're present at the station ticket office or machine you're obviously travelling - and will be returning.

My guess is that people were booking without travelling in either direction. (There's a reason why you can only book an open return - and not an open outward journey.)
The above makes since and I agree 100%
The nonsense of this is that I have free travel now. I can book a train and not travel on it.
so you are part of the problem they are trying to fix
I got an email alert on the above change some time ago,
This is not Ryanair. It's public transport in Ireland
I hope not, if you asked at the station their is a good chance you night find out why,
I asked and I don't know for sure if I got the correct reply but I will share the reply I got from the person checking the tickets
For safety braking and other Issues for quick turn around they add carriages in lots of 4 if extra room is needed,
They do not like adding Extra Carriages possibly leaving some other line short and finding out later the people who booked missed that train and possibly turned up earlier or later expecting to be carried on the train the removed carriages from so everyone can get to their destination and back on time,
A fine of 126 euro looks very cheap to me,
 
Last edited:
Irish Rail were always very flexible. Cork to Dublin for the day, meeting finished early or there is no traffic on the quays and you might make the earlier train. As long as you had a valid ticket (ie for the day in question you could travel on that earlier train). It was called a fully flexible train ticket. My work can change their minds a thousand times about meetings so the opposite can happen and I only make the 6 pm rather than the 5 pm train. Obviously I have lost my pre booked seat but they will still let you board.

The inflexibility now is very depressing. After paying for a ticket cork Dublin return on a Tuesday why not give the punters full flexibility to travel on any available train. I always found the staff very helpful and flexible so this is a big change of policy.

The only thing to do is buy single tickets and remember to change the booking if it is looking like you need a different train.
 
The Irish Times article seems to suggest that any "clampdown" enforcement on tickets is only happening at Heuston. Is that the case?

They also mention an "open ticket" but no such ticket category is mentioned on the Irish Rail website so what are they referring to?
 
I travel regularly from Dublin to Cork and have found the trick is to book two one way tickets. If you book a return and print out your ticket in the station or download it on your phone you are required to use the return leg you have booked and can't rebook yourself onto another service. I have regularly changed my booking up to an hour in advance online
 
The most heavily booked Cork to Dublin train is that 17.25. So they charge a bit more for that to encourage people to go on earlier or later trains.

The punter pays €30 for 17.25 but €25 for any other time.

But the punter shows up at 16.25 and happy days for Irish Rail. It takes the pressure off the 17.25.

The problem is if the punter books a specific seat on the 17.25 and Irish Rail can't sell it because it's booked and it goes empty.

A few solutions to that.
1) If you book a seat, you must travel on that train. A bit harsh.
1A) If you book a seat and want to travel on an earlier train, you must change it online or at the ticket desk and pay €10.
2) If you book a seat and want to travel on a later train, you must cancel the earlier booking and pay €10.
3) If you book an open ticket, you can't book a seat and you will be asked to wait until everyone who has booked has got on. A bit difficult to organise. Requires a lot of staff who will get a lot of hassle. But probably only at peak times.

IR doesn’t charge a premium for a specific time from what I see.

They have Low (which are limited and sell fast), Semi Flex and Flex but the prices generally seem the same regardless of time.

I suspect as low sell out people who don’t need Semi Flex just book what’s available.

The issue is that in 2020 Irish Rail changed the definition of Semi Flex. I am almost certain it allowed you go one before or one after, no online change required. Obviously no seat guarantee.

The new rule lets you change online in advance, up to 1 hour perhaps.

Except they never enforced the change and it probably went unnoticed due to Covid by most.

I regularly get out of a meeting early, the window of change has closed and just go for it. I often ask security at the gate in Heuston and have had ticket inspectors look at my ticket. No issue. I am usually just the one train early.

The fact you can’t change if you are on a return is just stupid but as others said the solution is to buy two singles.

I’ve lots of colleagues on the train not aware of the change. They just say “I have a flex, I’m okay to go early” and well who could argue with that when I inspectors often check and don’t comment.

I would have thought there would be a legal argument around rules being in place but no history of enforcing.

They need to do some coms and fix the ability to change the return as that’s the part most need flex on.

They also need to update the app as tickets have to be bought on the website not Irish rail app.
 
Make trains free for everyone during off peak times and charge everyone during peak times.
Open tickets should cost the same as a peak time ticket.

Free travel for the elderly is a throw-back to a bygone era when older people were poor. It's not necessary anymore.
 
Make trains free for everyone during off peak times and charge everyone during peak times.
Don't agree with this. Off peak trains can still be busy and you will have lots of people booking and not turning up. You also have people doing a day return to cork just because it's free, who would not do it if it was a tenner each way, taking space from somebody who needs to travel.
Lower cost off peak definitely would be welcomed which tbf they do to an extent

The buy two singles and not a return will be my future method - thanks for the tip. Crazy to have the hassle of 2 purchases just to have more flexibility mind you, especially now they have digital QR code tickets
 
Free travel for the elderly is a throw-back to a bygone era when older people were poor. It's not necessary anymore
they tried to remove free travel from pensioners at peak times a few years ago because of capacity constraints and there was uproar, I don't understand why if you are retired you have loads of free time anyway to travel off peak for free.
 
Back
Top