Indo - "There is no cost of living crisis for majority of people in Ireland says IBEC CEO"

Its the basic essentials that have gone up the most, potatoes, bread, eggs etc. Potatoes have almost doubled in the last 5 years and looks like more rises due to shortages and drought all over europe this year. Also the ukraine war with russia targetting ukrainian grain ships in black sea has hit supplies of wheat into world markets. Also both russia and ukraine have difficulty even harvesting crops due to labour shortages. The wheat price stabilised for years after start of the war but now its going to rise again due to the drought in europe aswell. The rise in fertilizer prices and cuts in usage also hit crop yields. Therefore all the basic foodstuffs have alot more inflation to go.
 
I have 6 in my house, two children and four adults. If I'm careful and frugal I can do the weeks shopping for €150. If I buy what I want then it is double that. I don't buy any processed food and cook everything from fresh ingredients. In the past when money was tight I found that it was far more expensive to buy "cheap" processed food than cook from raw.
 
On the main topic of "There is no cost of living crisis for majority of people in Ireland" it is worth noting that wages (and welfare) in general are increasing slightly ahead of the rate of inflation so the proposition still stands.
 
The important thing about inflation is that it is personal. The CPI is not representative of all cohorts.

In our index, the parts with the largest increases in the 12 months to September 2026 were Housing, Water, Electricity, Gas & Other Fuels (+9.5%), Education Services (+8.9%) and Transport (+7.5%).

The largest monthly decreases were recorded in Recreation, Sport & Culture (-1.9%) but the CSO note that "this was the third consecutive month in which no ECOICOP division recorded an annual decline".

Within the categories that experienced the largest increases, the driving factors were 1) Home heating Oil, Mortgage Interest, Electricity and Local Authority rents 2) Tertiary education 3) School transport, Diesel, Petrol.

In Ireland, there are 1.8m households. Of those, c. 900k are households with children. In relation to mortgages, there are c. 700k houses that have a mortgage of some value in Ireland.

As far as I can see, the "majority of people" may not be in a cost of living crisis. But families with children/young adults and a mortgage certainly are. If the significant proportion of your income is spent on recreation and/or you don't commute to work (i.e. the retired, the late career/pre-retirement and the state dependent), you probably shouldn't be projecting your own experience bias into the debate.

 
Last edited:
On the main topic of "There is no cost of living crisis for majority of people in Ireland" it is worth noting that wages (and welfare) in general are increasing slightly ahead of the rate of inflation so the proposition still stands.

While wage inflation is generally correlated to the inflation index (and typically awarded on that basis), inflation is concentrated in particular baskets. In other words, wage inflation is not applied on the basis of e.g. your housing status (whereby owning your home outright insulates you from a large inflation effect, but having a mortgage/renting exacerbates the inflation effect).

Inflation/Earnings index correlation is not the most appropriate indicator in my view.
 
While wage inflation is generally correlated to the inflation index (and typically awarded on that basis), inflation is concentrated in particular baskets. In other words, wage inflation is not applied on the basis of e.g. your housing status (whereby owning your home outright insulates you from a large inflation effect, but having a mortgage/renting exacerbates the inflation effect).

Inflation/Earnings index correlation is not the most appropriate indicator in my view.
I agree. The problem in the economy is the value of labour relative to capital, or to but it in economic terms, the labour share of the economy. If you own your own home you are fine. If you are renting or have a relatively new mortgage, then you are going to struggle. In most cases that makes more of a difference than your income.
 
I agree. The problem in the economy is the value of labour relative to capital, or to but it in economic terms, the labour share of the economy. If you own your own home you are fine. If you are renting or have a relatively new mortgage, then you are going to struggle. In most cases that makes more of a difference than your income.

I think we agree on this. It's a "cost of earning" crisis - people don't get to keep enough of their own money.
 
There is a difference between purchasing power and cost of living crisis. My income hasn't increase since 2020. My husband wage has not followed inflation (only about half the inflation increase). So our purchasing power has decreased. However we are not in a cost of living crisis situation. That's what happened for a substantial portion of the population.
 
I think we agree on this. It's a "cost of earning" crisis - people don't get to keep enough of their own money.
Taxation takes a cut of "their money". The issue is how much of the wealth they help to create, through a combination of their labour and their employers capital, goes to them. When labour gets between 40% and 50% everything works fine. When it gets less than 40% working people get poor.

What's happening in Ireland is the State is getting a small cut of wealth created elsewhere and redistributing it locally so that the gap is closer than it would otherwise be.
 
I'd like to know who suggested that there was a cost of living crisis for the majority? I don't think that is reasonable.

I think 'crisis' needs to be defined.

If 3 out of a hundred people are enduring poverty then that is a crisis for them, not the other 97. With good social supports, which we have in this country, then nobody needs to starve or freeze to death and ideally they afforded opportunity to pull themselves out of a crisis. If that figure is maintained over the years then its not a crisis for the country.

If however that number starts to increase incrementally over time to 4, 5 maybe 6 people out of a 100, and even with the provision of good social supports it continues to rise then its not just a crisis for 6 people - persons 7,8 , 9 and 10 are looking over their shoulder wondering are they next to fall into a poverty trap or a cost of living crisis.

And I think that is what is occurring when we talk of cost of living crisis, more and more people are increasingly worried about their livlihoods and being able to afford the necessities of life without using up all their resources or going into debt.
 
In 21st century Ireland 1 child going cold or hungry is unacceptable. I spent some time today at Feed Our Homeless and it was a wake-up call for me. They're not only assisting rough sleepers but employed families who are struggling to put food on the table and heat their homes. I frankly don't care what anyone in IBEC says. I don't accept that this is a crisis for them: it is a crisis for all of us. It's not good enough.
 
I don't accept that this is a crisis for them: it is a crisis for all of us.

In case you thought I was being disregarding in anyway just to state when I state crisis for them I was thinking fundamentally that first and foremost it is a crisis for the individuals, families etc caught in poverty, while not necessarily a crisis for everyone else - that is reality.

There is always poverty, disadvantage, misfortune, to greater or lessor extents, it would be unreasonable to expect all of us to feel a state of 'crisis', all of the time.

I know there is poverty, disadvantage and misfortune today. I don't feel personally it is a crisis for me and my family or for the majority, but I can emphatise with those who are struggling.

If the numbers of those struggling is increasing in spite of all the supports then those of us not feeling in crisis would be well minded, at a bare minimum, to start paying more attention.

Hope that makes sense.
 
Back
Top