Google announces steps to ban scam ads
- Thread starter GSheehy
- Start date
Brendan Burgess
Founder
- Messages
- 54,765
Great news.
The bit I like the most is "Google will require financial services advertisers to complete verification based on their authorisation from the Central Bank of Ireland or other appropriate regulator. Advertises who are required to complete the process and do not, will not be allowed to show financial services ads."
The above is what I proposed in the prior thread on this and also what I said to the CBI in an email. Maybe someone is listening.
The proof will be in the pudding. Scams continue to be posted in Google Adwords. Google have not yet introduced this new procedure.
Makes so much sense that only authorized firms can advertise on Google.
Thanks @Brendan Burgess for helping push this issue strongly.
X (full of scam ads) and Meta need to adopt the same procedure.
The bit I like the most is "Google will require financial services advertisers to complete verification based on their authorisation from the Central Bank of Ireland or other appropriate regulator. Advertises who are required to complete the process and do not, will not be allowed to show financial services ads."
The above is what I proposed in the prior thread on this and also what I said to the CBI in an email. Maybe someone is listening.
The proof will be in the pudding. Scams continue to be posted in Google Adwords. Google have not yet introduced this new procedure.
Makes so much sense that only authorized firms can advertise on Google.
Thanks @Brendan Burgess for helping push this issue strongly.
X (full of scam ads) and Meta need to adopt the same procedure.
Last edited:
Has Google fixed the problem? No. Not yet anyway.
The scam deposit adverts and unregulated financial entries continue to advertise on Google.
Awful and shameful that Google is letting this still occur.
How long can it take Google to implement their new procedure?
The scam deposit adverts and unregulated financial entries continue to advertise on Google.
Awful and shameful that Google is letting this still occur.
How long can it take Google to implement their new procedure?
Last edited:
Just curious, where do these ads appear for people?
In the search results?
In the margins of a Google search page?
Somewhere else?
I don't see any ads on Google but that could be because of my home setup including an old (formerly Android) TV box that I pulled from the local WEEE recycling cage and which I repurposed to brun Pi-hole on Armbian Linux to eliminate most advertising etc.
en.wikipedia.org
en.wikipedia.org
In the search results?
In the margins of a Google search page?
Somewhere else?
I don't see any ads on Google but that could be because of my home setup including an old (formerly Android) TV box that I pulled from the local WEEE recycling cage and which I repurposed to brun Pi-hole on Armbian Linux to eliminate most advertising etc.
Pi-hole - Wikipedia
Armbian - Wikipedia
The scam deposit adverts continue in Google deposit key words searches.
This scam has reappeared again:
Better Rates Today
The company claims to be based on Custom House Quay. Not a chance.
I have reported similar ads over the last week and Google have rejected all my reports.
Google need to adapt their new procedure of insisting that firms advertising financial products are regulated as a matter of urgency or someone needs to force them to.
This scam has reappeared again:
Better Rates Today
The company claims to be based on Custom House Quay. Not a chance.
I have reported similar ads over the last week and Google have rejected all my reports.
Google need to adapt their new procedure of insisting that firms advertising financial products are regulated as a matter of urgency or someone needs to force them to.
Last edited by a moderator:
I just received an email from Google. Google has removed the "Better Rates Today" scam based on the report that I sent.
Mad how the reports to Google sometimes work. And sometimes don't work. But it should never get to the stage of having to be reported, these scams should be caught sooner.
There are still 2 companies that keep coming up in Google searches for deposit products that are making bold claims about their products. Namely, Moneda Capital and Investabill. Does anyone know anything about these 2 companies?
Mad how the reports to Google sometimes work. And sometimes don't work. But it should never get to the stage of having to be reported, these scams should be caught sooner.
There are still 2 companies that keep coming up in Google searches for deposit products that are making bold claims about their products. Namely, Moneda Capital and Investabill. Does anyone know anything about these 2 companies?
Last edited:
euroDilbert
Registered User
- Messages
- 330
My assumption is that they don't have systems or people capable of distinguishing fake from real ads (certain types anyway).
Also, they don't care enough.
Any point in ganging up on Google?
If any complainer wants to add my voice (and substantial weight!) to their complaint PM me the text and link to the ad and I'll add my email address address and jiggle the wording to confuse the AI.
I am of course working on the basis that complaints originating here are genuine and that the mods don't object. I won't mention any AAM connection or my correspondent.
This is scam-buster week on the BBC and they're tackling scammers based in what seem to be mainly Indian call centres. Great initiative.
If any complainer wants to add my voice (and substantial weight!) to their complaint PM me the text and link to the ad and I'll add my email address address and jiggle the wording to confuse the AI.
I am of course working on the basis that complaints originating here are genuine and that the mods don't object. I won't mention any AAM connection or my correspondent.
This is scam-buster week on the BBC and they're tackling scammers based in what seem to be mainly Indian call centres. Great initiative.
100% agree with this. On many regulatory and compliance fronts, Google (and the majority of their fellow travellers) do the absolute minimum that they can get away with, and on many occasions put their huge resources into circumventing the spirit if not the letter of consumer protection regulations. Any improvements that have taken place are the result of EU enforcement.
Dr Strangelove
Registered User
- Messages
- 2,098
I find it bizarre that they don’t put more effort into this as they are eating their own tail by not rooting out scam ads. Consumers will no longer click and advertisers won’t spend.
For example I gave up on Facebook Marketplace as it was so riddled with scammers.
For example I gave up on Facebook Marketplace as it was so riddled with scammers.
I gave up on Facebook full stop. The odd time I do need use it now (usually to get information on small businesses that don't have a website) I find that wading through so much "content" of the "we thought this might interest you" variety so off-putting that I get off it as fast as I can.
Just got yet another deposit scam removed from Google AdWords.
The scam was near-identical to previous deposit scams.
This time Google took action based on my report (it seems to be random as to whether Google take action or not) and removed the advertisement because "doesn't follow Google’s policies".
When on earth will Google start applying their policies (which they told the media would including checking that the deposit taker is regulated by the CBI/national regulator) at the beginning when the scammer submits the advert to Google?
The scam was near-identical to previous deposit scams.
This time Google took action based on my report (it seems to be random as to whether Google take action or not) and removed the advertisement because "doesn't follow Google’s policies".
When on earth will Google start applying their policies (which they told the media would including checking that the deposit taker is regulated by the CBI/national regulator) at the beginning when the scammer submits the advert to Google?
Last edited:
A deposit scam that I got Google to remove a few weeks ago has now reappeared in their adverts.
I reported it yet again.
This time Google told me the ad does not violate their policies. This is despite the fact that the deposit taker is clearly unregulated (which Google are supposed to check), and Google saying just a few weeks ago that this same advert violated their policies. Utterly inconsistent and incompetence behaviour by Google.
I reported it yet again.This time Google told me the ad does not violate their policies. This is despite the fact that the deposit taker is clearly unregulated (which Google are supposed to check), and Google saying just a few weeks ago that this same advert violated their policies. Utterly inconsistent and incompetence behaviour by Google.
Last edited:
I got a Google ad just now for an entity the Central Bank recently issued a warning about:
www.centralbank.ie
Have reported with link to the above. The scammer website even links to the main Central Bank website!!
Better Rates Today – Central Bank of Ireland Issues Warning on Unauthorised Firm
Better Rates Today – Central Bank of Ireland Issues Warning on Unauthorised Firm. This investment scam is an example of a “comparison website scam”, where fraudsters set up a website purporting to help consumers find and compare different investment or savings products.
Have reported with link to the above. The scammer website even links to the main Central Bank website!!
Sounds like people, with the best will and intentions in the world, may be fighting a losing battle trying to get takedowns on stuff like this with increasingly unregulated online corporate behemoths like Google. What's the point? Why not just ignore what are presumably obvious scam ads, use a different search engine/digital ecosystem, and/or give up on trying to white knight people who are probably going to get scammed one way or another anyway?
Last edited: