Gareth O'Callaghan: Is it finally time for an honest debate about selling RTÉ?

Persia

Registered User
Messages
851
Gareth O'Callaghan: Is it finally time for an honest debate about selling RTÉ? https://share.google/8gOQQdgN7I3oOFdjh


"If selling a share in RTÉ guaranteed the station’s future while still retaining its public service remit, then why not call the debate? The station clings to an expectation that the cavalry is coming in the shape of a taxpayer bailout. What if next year when the public funding package runs out the cavalry doesn’t come?

As I write, I’ve just checked listings for RTÉ2. With the exception of the World Cup, every programme is a repeat. That might have been acceptable when our viewing choices were limited, but this is not the summer of 1996."

Personally I agree with this. Its a white elephant constantly caught on the wrong side of audit findings and scandal. Time to get shot of it and the TV licence.
 
Nah.

Let's do an Obasanjo and just sack everybody and start again.

No more UCD or TCD graduates. No one hired can be a friend or relative of an existing employee at any level.

Sensible shoes and sensible salaries, please.

Public forum (just register on the rtepubliccontrol.ie website) for disciplinary and editorial policy matters.

P.S. No Christmas parties at Montrose.
 
Question to Gareth O'Callaghan

Who in their right mind would buy RTÉ as a going concern, and with full transfer of financial and personnel undertakings ?

Answer

I don't know anyone so foolish.

Any entity, existing or starting up, with an intention to provide largely public service TV content would surely distribute their channel via satellite or broadband rather than the terrestrial transmitter/transponder network - which I think has already been offered for sale ~ 2002 but Der Ahern found few takers.

What else would the buyer get out of RTÉ ?

• A plague of understandings-to-buy-content from small production companies led by entitled, connected and boring individuals

• A responsibility to keep in constructive employment 1,500 + employees even when their final product is deemed disagreeable by viewers

• A colossal pension fund hole

• A long-term lease on a premises and large car-park at Montrose, Dublin 4 that is not saleable to anyone else
 
I can see a situation in the not too distant future where RTE is dramatically reduced in size with just one TV channel and probably 2 radio channels with programming very much "public service" and sports.

Whilst I have access to RTE, yesterday's all Ireland was the first time I tuned in voluntarily for a long time.

In June I was on a few days break and two of the days it was raining - the self catering TV only had Saorview and didn't have mirroring or casting. It was excruciating.

Ended up watching Netflix on a laptop

It's not just RTE - Virgin offered dreadful options too.

Soaps, appalling reality TV and dreadful quizzes seems to be the standard fare these days. It simply pushes most people to streaming.
 
I agree. I watch the news and fair city on RTE 1 . I never watch RTE 2 . Virgin Media 1 sometimes...but not the other ones...
We usually watch re runs on the player ...
The Clinic is one and Mrs joer watches re re runs of Frasier,,,friends,,,golden girls etc.
It's even hard to find something decent I Prime even with the high amount of content....
 
. . . and probably 2 radio channels with programming very much "public service" and sports.

Radio 1 and Lyric ?

All right but cut down on the so-called current affairs in the morning time on Radio 1. Most of us just can't take it.

And dump Marty Whelan from Marty In The Morning on Lyric. Do not replace him with the other Marty (Morrissey) - get George Hamilton instead for mid-brow stuff.
 
Other than live sport I never watch RTE or Virgin (Just slightly repackaged ITV really). I watch the news on Channel 4 the odd time. I never watch ITV or BBC. That said I watch very little TV anyway. If there is something I want to watch I record it so I don't have to sit through the adverts. The RTE player is unusable.

RTE Current Affairs is very left wing and their international news coverage is rubbish. C4 news, The Guardian and the New York Times are all reasonably good. The Financial Times website is by a long way the best news source for international news. I'm not sure who RTE is aimed at but it certainly isn't at anyone under 60 who wants to be informed or entertained in an intellectually stimulating way.

My children never watch live TV.
 
The RTE player is unusable.
They have improved it and I find its now reasonably good - WAY better than it was last year.
Watched the match on it and I didn't notice the difference from watching on saorview.
 
RTE Current Affairs is very left wing and their international news coverage is rubbish.

Considering the RTÉ budget I'd say they do too much international news. They have permanent correspondents in London, Brussels, Washington, New York, Eastern Europe and 2-3 rovers backed up with Montrose editorial staff.

Old Downesy seemed to be out there for years. Likewise with Crowley in Jerusalem.

Far be for me to sing Fill A Rún Ó to you but realise that the Financial Times has much deeper pockets and a wider remit regarding foreign affairs.
 
Watched the match on it and I didn't notice the difference from watching on Saorview.

By God I did.

There are often untimely interruptions and streaming delays.

If you turn down the sound for the ads (a medical necessity, I believe) and don't turn it back up again after they end, you will often lose your streaming as they will take your download capacity and return it to the streaming pool.

News and big games are certain to have numerous interruptions. Even popular programmes like the one last night on RTÉ1 on the Irish censors, will have lots of breaks too.
 
Considering the RTÉ budget I'd say they do too much international news. They have permanent correspondents in London, Brussels, Washington, New York, Eastern Europe and 2-3 rovers backed up with Montrose editorial staff.
RTE is about three quarters the size of the FT in revenue terms. Not a million miles away, though a bit is an apples and oranges comparison as they are very different organisations.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top