GAA Club Championship

Leper

Registered User
Messages
2,359
There were two cracking games on the television over the weekend covered by TG4. Saturday St-Thomas's (Co-Wexford) V Ballyhale Shamrocks(Co-Kilkenny) hurling and on Sunday we had football Dingle (Co-Kerry) V St-Finbarr's Co-Cork).

The hurling game was terrific with both teams trading score for score. Ballyhale were leading by one point going near time added on and the Co-Wexford team drew level with an excellent score and seconds later were awarded a free from which they won the game by one point. St-Thomas's being underdogs did not relent although they trailed for much of the first half. Their Banisteoir spent the entire game standing one one spot near the sideline and hardly spoke, moved, gesticulated for the whole game. Only, he had "Bainisteoir" written on the back of his tracksuit top you'd think he was a member of the public. Obviously, he had a plan and decided to stick to it. Great to see the underdog winning.

The Football game on Sunday was excellent too. St-Finbarr's lead for the majority of the game. Approaching fulltime Dingle were awarded a "double" free where the ball was advanced 45 metres because of not releasing the ball. A two-pointer resulted from the free and Dingle won the game by one point. The referee was within his rights to award the free and I was delighted he had the guts to do so.

Both games were a terrific advertisement for the GAA.
 
Should frees be "doubles"? I get the point for scores from play but not for frees outside the 40m.
 
They shouldn't be @Purple . A 45 only counts for a point so it's a bit strange to award 2 points for a free which is closer in. Jim McGuinness pointed this out early in the year but the rule remains for now. We will end up with specialists on each team purely for their long range free kick skills if they don't change it. We already have the goalkeeping position being more valuable for a good kicker than a good keeper so I don't think we want to extend it further.
 
Somethings had to be done about Gaelic Football Rules. The game was ruined and not entertaining. I think it was Jim Gavin had a hand in the changes of rules. They are speeding the game up as it had become very droll. Anything that will improve the entertainment, I'm supporting. I don't care if the GAA are stealing ideas from Afghan sterile Turkey Races in Afghanistan.
 
What was ever wrong with the traditional backs and forwards. There was a tussle on every part of the pitch, entertainment for every fan of the game.
Every time the rules are changed, nowadays , makes it only worse , in my opinion. I'm talking about football, of course.
 
What was ever wrong with the traditional backs and forwards. There was a tussle on every part of the pitch, entertainment for every fan of the game.
Every time the rules are changed, nowadays , makes it only worse , in my opinion. I'm talking about football, of course.
Ah no completely disagree with this. The vast majority of the rule changes have improved the game no end. The solo and go has been the biggest game changer, it's a fantastic rule change. The 3 players back/up is also a positive as it gives players a bit more room. Not being able to pass back to the goalkeeper in your own half is another improvement as that was ruining the game. The two pointer from play adds great excitement, especially in the closing stages.
The game now is infinitely better than the borefest we were witnessing over the previous few years where teams literally knocked the ball over and back to each other while two walls of defenders watched them.
 
We will have to agree to disagree on this one.
( Do you remember the backs and forwards) game.
I watched the all Ireland football final this year and, I stuck with it, and didnt think it was good at all. I honestly haven't enjoyed watching a game of football for years and unless it changes won't watch one again.
Give me a game of hurling anytime , which is backs and forwards and that is why it is such an exciting game , in my opinion.
 
Back
Top