Experience switching fibre broadband providers (Eir to Virgin)

ClubMan

Registered User
Messages
60,046
Just in case it's of any use to anyone else...

My Eir 12 month contract finishes tomorrow and I didn't want to pay the much higher non-new customer monthly cost. 30 days ago I called them and gave them notice that I was ending the contract at the end of the 12 months. They didn't really give me any hard sell to keep me. Just to be clear, the service was perfect and the few times that I needed to contact them they were easy to contact and very helpful, but I just didn't want to pay the out of contract price.

About 3 weeks ago I ordered VM (500Mbps + basic TV for €45 p.m. with €105 credit after a few months) via Switcher.ie. Immediately VM contacted me about installation. I asked them if I could hold off until 13th July and they said that that was fine. In the meantime they installed the cable from the pavement shore to the cable box outside my house while I was out.

Today the Actavo guy arrived c. 10am (my slot was 8am-1pm) and completed the installation inside the house which took about an hour. He had to drill another hole in the external wall beside the OpenEir cable. But the inside installation was cleaner than the OpenEir one as he routed the stripped small fibre optical cable stripped of its shielding to the living room and the wall box. The VM model/router has an integrated ONT so there's no ONT mounted on the wall and the thin optical fibre goes direct to that.

Obviously he left the OpenEir cable/terminator box/ONT alone. Their installation was a bit messier with the fully shielded optical fibre cable (about the thickness of a coaxial cable) brought into the living room from outside. The Actavo guy said that this isn't strictly compliant with fire regulations and that the optical fibre cable should be stripped inside the house. I'm not that bothered but the stripped cable is a lot tidier/more discreet than the ugly black shielded cable. But it's not a huge deal.

The broadband and TV service were enabled and are working fine and I just had to log into the modem/router to change the admin password and WiFi name and password so that I don't have to reconfigure devices that were connection to my old network.

All in all it went pretty smoothly from the point of view of scheduling things so that there was no down time and minimal payment for two separate services and also the physical and technical installation processes.
 
This is the cable box outside the house. Top cable is the new VM one, bottom one is the pre-existing Eir one.

1000028666.webp

The two cables going into the house. Again top is VM, bottom is Eir.

1000028668.webp

This is just inside the door. The Eir cable is the still shielded black one, the box is the VM box from which the bare/unshielded optical fibre cable is routed to the living room. The latter is so small it's difficult to see. The crack/broken plaster is from the OpenEir installation last year - I never got around to patching it.

1000028669.webp

This is inside the living room. The lower two boxes are the OpenEir terminal box and ONT, the top is the VM box.

1000028670.webp

The optical fibre cable comes direct from the VM wall box into the VM modem/router which has an integrated ONT. In contrast the Eir modem/router (now removed) connects to the Eir ONT using an ethernet cable.

Hope that clarifies? If you need any further info let me know.
 
Very neat job looks like you got an installer who cares about his work.

So with EIR you have to have 2 boxes inside the house (connected to each other) but with VM it's all contained in the one ? Have i understood you correctly?
 
So with EIR you have to have 2 boxes inside the house (connected to each other) but with VM it's all contained in the one ?
Yes, two Eir boxes (optical terminator box - not sure what it's officially called, and ONT) in the living room. For VM there's a small "terminator box" where the cable comes into the house and another one in the living room.

As mentioned before, the Eir ONT connected to their modem/router using an ethernet cable (not pictured in my photos). With VM the optical cable comes from the living room box into the modem/router which has an integrated ONT.
 
Yes same VM setup here. The Eir - 2 box setup would be a deal breaker for me.

Thanks for the detailed information and follow up, very useful.
 
Yes same VM setup here. The Eir - 2 box setup would be a deal breaker for me.
Why? It's not really a big deal in my experience.
And VM do a have two boxes too.
Although the VM installation with the routing of the unshielded fibre optic cable is definitely much more discreet than the thicker OpenEir shielded one.
 
Thankfully I don't need to work, from home or anywhere else, these days, but for the last 12 months my Eir service was rock solid.
 
Seems ridiculous they had to bring a second fibre cable in to the house when there already was one. Eir and VM both use the Open Eir network.
 
Eir and VM both use the Open Eir network.
No. VM use their own infrastructure, at least in my area. And several other providers now also use it. Vodafone, Sky, Digiweb and maybe a few others if I recall currently what the guy told me yesterday.

Edit:
Edit 2:
1000028682.webp
 
Last edited:
Back
Top