employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay rise

L

lync

Guest
Hi all

My mother has just been told by her employer that they cannot afford to be given the national pay increese is this legal?

lyn
 
Re: wage rise ?

Does her job fall under the remit of this scheme? I don't think that all do. Certainly most or all jobs that I have had were not impacted by these agreements. If she is a member of a union then she should ask them.
 
Re: wage rise ?

Even if her employer is signed up to the agreement I think there is still a "get out" clause for the employer. They say that they cannot afford to pay, so in that case your mother can ask for proof. She is entitled to see the proopf
 
Re: wage rise ?

Nellie123 said:
They say that they cannot afford to pay, so in that case your mother can ask for proof. She is entitled to see the proopf
Click to expand...
Are you suggesting that they give her their accounts to shift through? I'm not so sure that she is entitled to see proof. As I said before it's voluntrqary for the private sector to award pay rises.
 
Re: wage rise ?

It is up to the employer unfortunately. These are difficult situations for an employee. What she could do is ask them can they review the situation on a quarterly basis and try and get them to give her an idea of when a raise might be possible.
 
as the above said..up to the employer... it's a kop out,some companies do it unfortunately :(
 
scuby said:
as the above said..up to the employer... it's a kop out,some companies do it unfortunately :(
Click to expand...

How do you know that it's a "kop out" without knowing who the employer is what their trading circumstances are or the people involved.
It's that sort of stupid attitude that puts businesses out of business.
 
The only get out clause is inability to pay by the employer and that must be proven by opening the books for assessment.
For sure, if she is a member of a union then she is entitled to National Wage Agreement even in the private sector.

There are several Labour Cout judgements along these lines. All rulings available online.
eg from a recent ruling:-

Application of the Terms of Towards 2016

"Towards 2016" includes a provision whereby a Company may claim inability to pay the terms of the agreement. In such circumstances an assessor may be appointed for the purpose of evaluating the economic, commercial and employment circumstances of the Company and the Court may issue a binding decision pursuant to Clause 1.9(ii) of Towards 2016. However, the Company has not availed of these provisions in this case.

In all circumstances, the Court recommends that the terms of "Towards 2016" should be applied to the workers rates of pay, and the following increases should be paid with retrospect effect from the following dates:

3% from 1st January 2006
2% from 1st July 2006
2.5% from 1st March 2007
2.5% from 1st September 2007

Implementation.

The terms of this recommendation should be implemented within one month from the date on which it is issued.
 
Last edited:
Re: employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay ris

Purple said:
How do you know that it's a "kop out" without knowing who the employer is what their trading circumstances are or the people involved.
It's that sort of stupid attitude that puts businesses out of business.
Click to expand...

i have had personal experience with it !! that's why i said it.............

how can my "stupid attitude" put a company out of business ?
 
Re: employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay ris

Just because an individual is a member of a T16 Participating Union does not entitle them to T16 Process.

Company is under no obligation to open their books to anyone.

But as this case covers "Custom and Practice" , and employer has broken the practice, you have a claim.

I think it is incumbent on employer to supply data to employees detailing his inability to pay T16, most employees are sensible enough not to endanger their jobs, if this option is not available, you need to put case into Labour Courts.
 
There is nothing in legislation to saying employees have to get a pay rise. If she is a member of union they may fight for a raise on her behalf but if your mother is employed in the private sector then she has the option of staying put at the pay she is on or seeking employment elsewhere. If she considers she is being paid too little for the work she does then I'd advise her to look for another job at a better rate. wonder what her employers reaction would be if she handed in her notice?????
 
Re: employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay ris

So good you would have ta say it twice !!

Wheras their is no legislation stating employers are obligated to give pay rise, the OPs mother was a part of the T16 pay round, and as such would expect the agreement to be honoured, if possible.

The T16 deal encompasses a lot of modernisation clauses for participants, and was agreed between IBEC,ICTU and Government , this model is used in a good few countries (Sweden etc ..) and works quite well.

Never been a fan of " If you are,nt getting pay raise, leave" brigade, not everyone has skillsets that allows them to walk out , and immediately get another job , also if you have mortgage , other loans , would you have the bottle ??
 
Is there a possibility that the employer is trying to cut down on his staff and that this is his way of doing it, ie hoping they will leave of their own accord?
 
Re: employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay ris

How do you know that it's a "kop out" without knowing who the employer is what their trading circumstances are or the people involved.
It's that sort of stupid attitude that puts businesses out of business.

how can my "stupid attitude" put a company out of business ?
Click to expand...
I must say I fully agree with Purple. I also don't see why unauthorised employees should have the right to nose around in company accounts, outside of those which are submitted to the CRO.

I would agree that it is stupid to suggest that employees should be given pay increases to an extent that makes the viability of a company suffer. In such a scenario, the company will probably go bust, putting all employees out of a job.

For sure, if she is a member of a union then she is entitled to National Wage Agreement even in the private sector.
Click to expand...
Let this be a warning to those employing staff.
 
Re: employer says that they cannot afford to give the national wage agreement pay ris

Ask employer .... the scheme is flexible in the sense that your employer maybe in IBEC , but not implement T16.



If you have not had payments up to now , you are not.
 
I must say I fully agree with Purple. I also don't see why unauthorised employees should have the right to nose around in company accounts, outside of those which are submitted to the CRO.
Click to expand...

I would assume that the official audited accounts, as published on the CRO website, would be the ones used to determine inability to pay. This information is in the public domain.
 
Outside of the Public service and the banks and the usual suspects such as the ex semi state bodies, I don't know any company that pays the t16 rises. My understanding is that it was not compulsory for a company to sign up for this in the first place and that the "unable to pay" clause applied if they had signed up and subsequently decided they couldn't afford to pay. Am I right or wrong?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top