Eir Pension - Transfer Value of Defined Benefit

Abbeyside

Registered User
Messages
7
Background
My wife joined the scheme in 1981, left Eir in 2001 and reached age 60 in July 2023. She did not draw down her benefits at this time.
In March 2025 received estimated retirement options, the options included a transfer to another arrangement
In August 2026 requested up to date estimated retirement options, the options stated " Transfer values are only available to members who satisfy all of the following conditions are under 60, have left the service of Eir, are not in receipt of a pension from the scheme, and hold a preserved benefit in the scheme. As you do not meet all of the above requirements, we are not able to offer you a transfer value under the scheme"
This would be inline with eBrief 161/25. However legislation has not changed.

This decision was appealed to the Trustees of the Eircom Superannuation Scheme 1988 but the appeal has failed. This decision is now being appealed to the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport, which ultimately I fully expect to be referred on to the Minister of Finance. I also intend to request a ruling from the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman

A technical opinion request was made to revenue, on whether the member could transfer to another arrangement, their response was that they couldn't answer the request. This is now with the Tax Appeals Commission awaiting their ruling.

What I would like to know if there are any members of the forum that are in the position of

1. In the Eir scheme and were allowed a transfer value after reaching their Normal Retirement Age
2. In the Eir scheme and were allowed a transfer value on appeal
3. Members of any other Defined Benefit Scheme that treats tye above differently.
4. Any member who has requested a technical opinion from Revenue, Minister for Culture, Communication and Sport, Minister of Finance, Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman.

If so could you please get in touch directly with myself as what is happening is unconstitutional and I will be fighting this to the end if that means a judicial review so be it.
 
Preliminary nitpick: You keep saying “I intend to request a ruling . . .”, “I will be fighting . . . “, “please get in touch directly with myself . . .”, etc. But you have no standing here. This is your wife’s pension; any dispute is between her and the trustees of the scheme.

I think what your wife is missing here is — what do the rules of the scheme say?

In the two years after she left service, your wife had a statutory right to the payment of a transfer value (Pensions Act 1990 s. 34). However she didn’t exercise that right and, now, whether she can get a transfer payment made depends on what the rules of the scheme say.

You’ve been looking on her behalf at what Revenue have to say about this. But it’s important to understand that Revenue has nothing to say about what your wife is entitled to. Their concern is what benefits the trustees of an exempt approved pension scheme are allowed to provide. All that she can hope to establish through enquiries of this kind is whether exempt approved pension schemes, in general, are allowed to provide transfer payments in respect of deferred members in her circumstances.

If she establishes that pension scheme trustees may not provide such a transfer payment, that’s an end to the matter, since the scheme rules will certainly include an overriding rule that no benefit is to be provided that exempt approved schemes are not permitted to provide. But if she finds that a scheme is permitted to provide such a transfer payment, it doesn’t follow that she has a right to have such a payment made; there is no rule of law that all exempt approved pension schemes must provide all benefits that are allowed under the tax regime.

So, if she establishes that a transfer payment is possible under the tax regime, whether your wife has a right to one then comes down to the terms of the trust deed and rules that govern the Eir pension scheme.

- They may provide that the trustees must make a transfer payment in respect of a deferred member situated as your wife is.

- They may provide that the trustees may make such a transfer payment.

- They may be silent about the matter (in which case no transfer payment is possible; the trustees can only provide benefits for which the scheme rules provide).

The steps she needs to take in order to get the trustees to make a transfer payment (assuming that is possible) will depend on exactly what the rules say, and in particular whether they confer an entitlement on her, or merely give the trustees a discretion — as in, she will follow a different course of action depending on whether she is seeking to enforce an entitlement which the trustees have failed to recognise, or to challenge the exercise of a discretion that she does not like.

So that’s where this investigation needs to start — the trust deed and rules that govern the scheme.
 
Last edited:
The general rule is that once you have passed the scheme normal retirement age, a transfer is not permitted. A transfer to a Buy Out Bond may be allowed after the NRA if the transfer is made within 2 years of them leaving the employment.
 
When you get to the constitutional court Trustees will also argue that your wife has no loss. Many will dispute this argument but they will show the judge the tv is calculated on an actuarial basis based on the deferred pension.
 
The general rule is that once you have passed the scheme normal retirement age, a transfer is not permitted.

OP doesn't tell us what the normal retirement age is in the Eir pension scheme (and we should note that this may not be straightforward;; there may be different NRAs for different classes of member). 65 is the most common NRA; 60 is also found; anything else is fairly unusual.

He does say that his wife turned 60 in July 2023, which makes her 63 today.

In March 2025, when she was 62, she was given the impression that her retirement options included a transfer payment.

In August 2026, at the age of 63, she was told that her options did not include a transfer payment, apparently because she was over 60. (She seems to satisfy all the other conditions.) Unless the scheme rules changed in the meantime, that would imply that the March 2025 notification was incorrect.

So:

- It may be that her NRA is 60; the March 2025 notification was simply in error about her entitlement to a transfer payment, and the August 2025 notification is correct.

- Or it may be that her NRA is 65, but the scheme rules do not provide transfer payments after age 60, and the March 2025 notification was in error.

- Or it may be that her NRA is 65, the rules do provide her with a transfer payment, the March 2025 notification was correct, and the August 2026 notification is in error.

It's not really possible to take this much further without looking at the scheme rules, which will determine both what transfer payments are offered and what the OP's wife's NRA is.
Trustees will also argue that your wife has no loss.
Very possibly. If it's established that the wife did not have a right to a transfer payment and that the March 2025 notification was a misrepresentation of the position, then — speculating here — the wife might seek damages for misrepresentation. If so, the trustees will certainly argue (among other things) that she hasn't suffered any damage, because instead of the benefits that she could have secured with a transfer payment, she has a deferred pension, which is equivalent (i.e. it has the same value).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top