Dept. of Housing issues letter to people who have given Notice of Termination

Does anyone have any idea how is the 0.4% of the overall market calculated?
I did look at this number and thought that it was actually very low but just read over it. Obviously that's not the full story.
 
He's cherry picking the data to further his own agenda;
I wonder how he could even cherry pick it, it seems outright wrong. If this is the kind of data that's being presented to the housing committee, they are going to be very much mislead.
 
Does anyone have any idea how is the 0.4% of the overall market calculated?

Maybe he secretly meant per month ? Even that would be closer to 0.6%.

NoTs per month = annual / 12 = 18,531 / 12 = 1544.25
NoTs per tenancy per month = 1544.25 / 240751 = 0.6%

It could be per month over a different window of time.
 
Is the email actually coming from the Dept of Housing or the RTB? I am asking because it is a breach of GDPR for the RTB to prove personal data to another entity, unless you have agreed to the sharing of data in advance.
 
Is the email actually coming from the Dept of Housing or the RTB?

I had wondered about that.

1765104971914.webp
 
I received the letter from the Dept of Housing, Local Govt and Heritage. Got it in the post on Friday.
 
So much could have been done in the budget for small landlords, like aligning with the rent a room scheme in terms of income before tax, but they did nothing.

They are doing nothing here with these letters either, sure no one believes them anymore.
 
They are doing nothing here with these letters either, sure no one believes them anymore.
Yes, we've been told so many lies at this stage - the RPZs were limited to Dublin and Cork City centre and would last three years, we were getting tax relief, the RPZs were being lifted, the RTB is a neutral organisation etc. etc.

This is just the latest bate and switch
 
Maybe he secretly meant per month ? Even that would be closer to 0.6%.
Maybe he is secretly including AHB tenancies and Council tenancies ;)

Also, if you exclude the Cost-Rentals incorrectly included in the Register, the percentage of NoTs is higher
 
This is from the comments section on the article in the Journal.ie - a common view, I would imagine

original

Jim Connolly4y
40mins ago
Got THREE begging letters to withdraw notices. Hopefully a bottle of whiskey next time. I WONT bite. No trust left. Very few non fund type landlords left after February.
 
Maybe he is secretly including AHB tenancies and Council tenancies
That was my thinking too. They do form part of the overall rental market. However, if included to form the 0.4% figure, they should be included for all stats. Otherwise, it's the x % of statistics are made up on the spot stuff (where x = any number you want or need it to be)..
 
He added that a share of the total number of tenancies – which is recorded as 240,751 – who have received notices to quit represented 0.4% of the overall market.

Its simply grossly misleading as he states those that "received" NOTs, which presumably is every live tenancy in receipt of an NOT. It doesn't say its per month (or whatever arbitrary period backs out to 0.4%). That someone like this who makes up facts for a national news outlet can speak to a housing committee is a scandal.

Even if he did try to somehow cherry pick, and do a contrived monthly number, he would have to go all the way back to Q4 2024 which shows as 0.38% for that period (calcs below)

Maybe the guy did a 3 weekly period? I find it nuts.


1765115793784.webp



Its also worth nothing that even if a tenant is past their notice date to move out, and is over holding, the LL is still legally obliged to register them (including in cases where tenant is not paying rent). These show in the tenancy register making the denominator bigger, but many would not be included in the numerator in my annual number from earlier (as many of these NOT's would have been issued before Q4 2024).
 
He must have done something along those lines. It is the only way he could come up with the number he did. AHBs and Student Accommodation shouldn't be included. The amount of NoTs there must be tiny. Also, the issue is PRS specific so that is the number (less cost-rentals) which should have been used.

It just shows what we are dealing with. He is a 'housing expert', has the ear of the Oireachtas Committee and the Department of Housing very likely. He makes up his stats to create a 'nothing to see here' narrative. He has been widely quoted denying the landlord exodus based on the very questionable RTB numbers.
 
The whole issue relating to Housing statistics from RTB/ Government and questionable "housing experts" who have the ear of Government and a click bait media is very questionable.
In summing up I have to say that Trust in Government has been shattered on this subject and will be very difficult to repair even in the medium term
 
As I have said before I just cant understand how they get away with lying all the time.
Now they are sending misleading letters lying to landlords who just want out of this fixed game where the goalposts move all the time.
Is there no accountability here at all for the lies from official sources. Im surprised at this point they arent posting on Truth social.
 
I wonder if anyone in the media is going to pick them up on the lies as they wheel out the media machine to follow up on the letters.
They will be given free airtime with nobody taking them to task as they repeat the lies on the radio and in the papers over the next week.
 
Back
Top