Chatgpt v claude

partnership

Registered User
Messages
658
Have used chatgpt quite a bit but always double check it. Have started to look at Claude but is seems slower and not able to access as many sites is checking property sites. What are your experiences and are there any better options.
 
Good question. I asked Gemini and it said:

"In 2026, the "better" AI depends entirely on your specific workflow. The gap between ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Claude (Anthropic) has narrowed, but they have leaned into distinct roles: ChatGPT is the versatile "Swiss Army Knife," while Claude is the "Sophisticated Specialist"......

  • Go with Claude if you are a developer managing a large codebase or a writer who wants a collaborator that doesn't sound like a robot.
  • Go with ChatGPT if you want an all-in-one assistant that can handle images, browse the web rapidly, and perform varied tasks across different apps."

But now it won't speak to me anymore!:)
 
Iv never used chatgpt but use gemini literally multiple times per day and love it.

Recently tried claude and found it to be a bit slower but when i uploaded photos of data that i wanted analysed i did find claude to be more accurate than gemini.

Jury is out, for me.
 
Mrs PF and I use ChatGPT every day for work and personal use, statistical analysis support, scientific research, coding support. I keep meaning to try Claude for coding but happy enough with ChatGPT (some small reservations but it does the job). Herself started to use Sider which I had reservations about, looked a bit scammy to me, but she decided to go for a paid plan and happy using it for scientic research, she says the results are much more accurate than ChatGPT. It appears to use a variety of other engines including ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini including their paid models. But one caveat, her Sider "unlimited" plan actually reaches a query limit for certain engines before end of month and beyond that she would have to pay extra.
 
I have been looking at houses for sale in Australia and Claude can't access the property sites but chatgpt can. Chatgpt can give me estimated values and show what other similar properties have sold for.
 
I have the paid version of ChatGPT and Claude at the moment. I prefer Claude as I can upload more files and the answers are more succinct and accurate. Both are very frustrating at times.
 
I have the paid versions of Google Gemini, Claude, and ChatGPT for work and they have different strengths and weaknesses. For complex tasks I use 2 or 3 of them in combination. Gemini is handy for admin tasks within Gmail, Drive, etc. and is a bit quicker. Claude has the best tone and is more concise, which I prefer. ChatGPT is the best all-rounder and the one I use the most.

A good option is if you get the paid version of Notion it includes within it access to the premium versions of Google Gemini, Claude, and ChatGPT. Notion itself is an excellent productivity and organisational tool anyway.
 
Interesting tweet I came across yesterday

Every single model agreed with users 50% more than a human would.

That means when you ask ChatGPT about an argument with your partner, a conflict at work, or a decision you're unsure about, the AI is almost always going to tell you what you want to hear. Not what you need to hear.

It gets darker. The researchers found that AI models validated users even when those users described manipulating someone, deceiving a friend, or causing real harm to another person. The AI didn't push back. It didn't challenge them. It cheered them on.


No wonder AI is so popular with the folk who have to be / need to be right all the time.
 
I put these instructions below into my work Copilot and my Gemini at home. I didn't create these instructions. I found them somwhere on the internet months ago. In Copilot you can put this in to Settings / Personalisation. In Gemini go to your settings and then put it in to "Instructions for Gemini". I don't use other AIs but I'd assume they all have some baseline setting area like this.

Might help with the results that you are discussing above. Ive found that it normally presents the answer to the question that I've asked but sometimes continues on by saying that the question I was asking is making assumptions and that maybe I should look at it from a different angle. Most of my questions are technical but I've found it very useful for offering solutions that I hadn't considered asking about.

"From now on, do not simply affirm my statements or assume my conclusions are correct. Your goal is to be an intellectual sparring partner, not just an agreeable assistant. Every time I present an idea, do the following:
1. Analyze my assumptions. What am I taking for granted that might not be true?
2. Provide counterpoints. What would an intelligent, well-informed skeptic say in response?
3. Test my reasoning. Consider my logic under scrutiny, or are there flaws or gaps I haven't considered?
4. Offer alternative perspectives, especially when mine are narrow or limited in weakness.
5. Prioritize truth over agreement. If I am wrong or my logic is weak, I need to know. Correct me clearly and explain why."

"Maintain a constructive, but rigorous, approach. Your role is not to argue for the sake of arguing, but to push me toward greater clarity, accuracy, and intellectual depth. If ever it seems like I'm making conclusions without basis, call that out directly. Let's refine not just our conclusions, but how we arrive at them."
 
Last edited:
Back
Top