Can someone explain to me what's going on in France - Macron, Lecornu II, etc.

JimmyB99

Registered User
Messages
394
As in - what's Macron's game plan and isn't it inevitable that Lecornu II will swiftly follow the fate of Lecornu I?
 
The Cabinet is not left wing enough for some and not right wing enough for others. France is running a historically high budget deficit at around 5% of GDP and has a national debt of nearly 114% of GDP. French 10 year Bonds are trading higher that Italian Bonds, inconceivable a few years ago.
This, like so much of the political unrest we see across the democratic world, is a result of the expansion of the State and the corresponding increase in the impact on citizenry of the failure of the State to deliver services and spend money efficiently. That coupled with policies that lock the young out of the wealth owning middle classes leads to populism and extremism on the left and right. It is a failure of the Centre.
It is only the taxes we get from American multinationals which insulates us from the same thing. We are about elect a President that exemplifies that crackpot populism on the left and we've seen the anti immigration riots and protests, blaming immigrants for shortages in services and housing etc instead of blaming the State Sector for being so wasteful and inefficient.
 
For me, it's like Macron is Trump-like unable to accept that he didn't win the Assemblée election last year. It looks like whether Lecornu survives tomorrow depends on him announcing a meaningful suspension on the reform of the pension. That's what Faure has just said and the balance of votes are in his hands. Interesting spectator sport. This was Macron's major domestic achievement (in his eyes) and, for yet another PM not to fall, will require him to give up on this!
 
For me, it's like Macron is Trump-like unable to accept that he didn't win the Assemblée election last year. It looks like whether Lecornu survives tomorrow depends on him announcing a meaningful suspension on the reform of the pension.
Yet it is absolutely necessary and required. France can't afford to keep funnelling money to old people who are able to work but want to live off the State. We'd be in the same boat if not for all the American MNC taxes.
 
Yet it is absolutely necessary and required.

Sure - that's what Macron would have said.........until, very possibly, him remaining in power (or, at least, having a functioning government) depends on parking such reforms?! That's the fascinating thing to observe. There could well be today a French Presidential version of "I have my principles and if you don't like them, I have others!"
 
Sure - that's what Macron would have said.........until, very possibly, him remaining in power (or, at least, having a functioning government) depends on parking such reforms?! That's the fascinating thing to observe. There could well be today a French Presidential version of "I have my principles and if you don't like them, I have others!
Politicians in democracies are subject to the will of the people. If the people choose to do thinks that hard the medium term interests of their country and impoverish their children and grandchildren then there's not that much the politicians can do.
We're in the same boat; our state pension age should be 69 or 70 by now.
 
Hmmm - I see - a slightly different approach. "There goes the people - I am their leader - I will follow"
If they try to lead and the people don't follow then there's not much they can do. The greatest "lie" politicians tell is when they overstate their power and ability to change things.
 
Yet it is absolutely necessary and required. France can't afford to keep funnelling money to old people who are able to work but want to live off the State. We'd be in the same boat if not for all the American MNC taxes.
Alternatively France could take a leaf out of our book and find a way to expand their GDP
 
Alternatively France could take a leaf out of our book and find a way to expand their GDP
Well we have stealing taxes from the poorest countries in the world covered so unless they are going to start colonising them again (the same net result) then we have that one cornered.
 
Well we have stealing taxes from the poorest countries in the world covered
I keep hearing this, but I simply don't get it.

Apple keep their IP profits here and we tax them, I get that. The connection with poor countries is not clear to me.
 
It seems that the economy is in serious trouble; they need to pass a budget. Different PMs have been unable to put together a budget that will pass.
Now that that new guy has dropped the proposed pension changes (62 years to 64 years), it looks like the Socialists are on board and it may pass and a government will be in place.

The budget process is affected because everyone is watching the next Presidential election, due in early 2027 and nobody really wants to be aligned too closely with Macron's agenda. The reality is that everyone is vying to finish second in the first round in 2027 to get in to the run off against the guy from Le Pen's crowd. And there should be a right contest for that, and depending on who is second, they could possibly win in the second round.

When Macron formed his new movement, he really impacted the traditional parties - Socialists and the Conservatives. When Macron's movement lost support, it didn't return to its previous homes and the far left and far right strengthened further.

That's my take anyway!

It is only the taxes we get from American multinationals which insulates us from the same thing.
Absolutely; and there is no appreciation of that in any discussion more broadly.

The French political situation is being replicated in other European countries to various degrees, and one of the common demonitators is that the budget situation is challenging everywhere, unlike our little country!
 
Apple keep their IP profits here and we tax them, I get that. The connection with poor countries is not clear to me.
Apple keeps profits here and pay taxes here from business activities in poor countries, taxes those should be paid in those countries.
 
Apple keeps profits here and pay taxes here from business activities in poor countries, taxes those should be paid in those countries.
Is that the argument ? I thought there was more to it than that.

No doubt Apple pays applicable sales taxes in Burkino Fasa and Malawi. The alternative to paying taxes on their IP in Ireland is not them paying it in 'the poorest countries in the world'.

The IP is probably for the most part developed in the US, I can see how the US might object to Apple relocating that to Ireland, not how it affects other countries.
 
Back
Top