Breathalysers in vehicles

mathepac

Registered User
Messages
9,535
Should this be the law here?

"The head of the State's medical bureau, which tests for drink driving, has called for changes in the law to allow the courts to direct repeat offenders to install breathalysers in their cars.

The small breath-testing machines, known as ignition interlock devices, prevent motorists starting their vehicles if they are over the limit for alcohol consumption.
"

This is several steps beyond the law in France and prevents the vehicle starting unless the driver gives an alcohol-free breath to the wired-in device. Apparently "all new cars manufactured in the EU since 2022 are capable of being fitted with the devices"

I'd suggest making fitting one of these devices to the cars of drivers convicted of driving over the limits for alcohol or other drugs mandatory on top of the current legal penalties. Perhaps broaden the remit of NCTS to fit and test these devices before licences/driving privileges are restored.

If, as Professor Dennis Cusack, Director of the Medical Bureau of Road Safety says, "alcohol is a contributory factor in about 30% of all road traffic crashes" then it doesn't require much debate as a potential life-saving measure.

That of course still leaves us with at least these pre-implementation problems:

a) pre-2022 vehicles
b) the presence of intoxicants other than alcohol
c) intoxicants not detectable by breath-testing.

Thoughts?
 
We don't need breathalyser machines in our cars. We have a police force who should be allowed to do their job and not be hampered with motorists asking "Do you know who I am?" I'm driving in Spain for the past few weeks and shortly I'll need a check list, tow-bar and trailer to accommodate all the stuff the law demands on motorists in Spain.
 
We don't need breathalyser machines in our cars. We have a police force who should be allowed to do their job and not be hampered with motorists asking "Do you know who I am?" I'm driving in Spain for the past few weeks and shortly I'll need a check list, tow-bar and trailer to accommodate all the stuff the law demands on motorists in Spain
Agreed and should be allowed breathalyse any driver at any time without needing a reason. And setup a checkpoint without prior paperwork. We need to wake up.
 
Professor Dennis Cusack, Director of the Medical Bureau of Road Safety says, "alcohol is a contributory factor in about 30% of all road traffic crashes

That 30% figure isn't specifically related to drivers and also includes pedestrians with any alcohol who are involved in fatal crashes.

Plus - given that breathalysers don't measure alcohol limits accurately it'd be a legal minefield. Roadside breath tests are not used in court cases to determine what levels of alcohol are present. (It's not illegal to drink alcohol and drive - once you are under the legal limits. It doesn't allow for much but anyone having say a pint or a glass of wine or two with a meal would be well under any limits.)
 
To quote Professor Dennis Cusack, Director of the Medical Bureau of Road Safety "We still have a big drink-driving problem," he says. "We know that there were over 300 drivers who had samples sent in by the gardaí, having been arrested more than twice, and some of them were up to 10 or 11 times over [the limit] for both alcohol and drugs" No mention of drunken pedestrians there.
Plus - given that breathalysers don't measure alcohol limits accurately it'd be a legal minefield.
Why? A technical device fitted to a driver's own car prevents them starting it under certain conditions, where's the legal minefield?

Alcohol-based mouth-wash an issue? Use an alcohol-free one such as that supplied by Listerine, for example, available in a supermarket or pharmacy near you, just ask.

I wonder how difficult it would be to integrate readings from the saliva-based drug-testing swabs into the in-car immobilisers?

€1,000/1,500 / vehicle for every intoxicated driver convicted before the Courts, with the convicted party paying - a bargain if it saves one life or saves one innocent person suffering life-changing injuries. The insurance companies could help here too by throwing their weight behind the proposal.

We don't need breathalyser machines in our cars.
It's the difference between being proactive and reactive.Just in case there are any former Garda Commissioners or Garda spokes-persons reading this, proactive means to act before an event/crash/incident, reactive means to act afterwards.

I'll need a check list, tow-bar and trailer to accommodate all the stuff the law demands on motorists in Spain.
A topic for AAM Espana maybe? :)
 
If Prof. Dennis Cusack, Director of Medical Bureau of Road Safety is right in that we still have a big drink-driving problem in Ireland the obvious solution is to increase fines and jail sentences for the offenders and let the Gardaí vigorously prosecute. I say "let" because the amount of such cases thrown out because of Justice Delayed is Justice denied or some other technicality and interference by politicians, senior gardaí etc. And we need more garda checkpoints and more respect for our gardaí.

Every year I see reports of the huge amounts of drink/drug drivers "caught." Our courts should be full of such offenders every week. But, when it comes to prosecution there are far far more "caught" people not being prosecuted. I don't have the figures, but no doubt some journalist could easily get the figures under some Freedom of Information Act.

For the record we're in Andalucía for the past six weeks and I've been breathalysed twice in that period by the Policía Local. No problem as far as I'm concerned; I haven't drank alcohol in 30 years. I do much more driving in Ireland and have never ever been breathalysed there.
 
For the record we're in Andalucía for the past six weeks and I've been breathalysed twice in that period by the Policía Local. No problem as far as I'm concerned; I haven't drank alcohol in 30 years. I do much more driving in Ireland and have never ever been breathalysed there.
I'm not disagreeing that we need better and more enforcement but we have some of the lowest rates of road deaths in Europe. Ours are lower per 100,000 population than Spain. If we measure it in deaths per 100,000 kilometres travelled as of 2023 we are at 3.5 deaths per 100,000Km travelled. Spain is 3.8. The USA is 12.3. The UK is 2.5. We could be better but we could be way worse.
 
To quote Professor Dennis Cusack, Director of the Medical Bureau of Road Safety "We still have a big drink-driving problem," he says. "We know that there were over 300 drivers who had samples sent in by the gardaí, having been arrested more than twice, and some of them were up to 10 or 11 times over [the limit] for both alcohol and drugs"
I do have some sympathy for those caught just over the legal limit, but I think people who are way* over the legal limit should be put off the road until their case is heard in court....car impounded, license handed over and insurance company notified.



* Not sure what way would be defined as, but may be 3+ times over?
 
If you're over the limit, too bad, you should be prosecuted. "Just over the Limit" is over the limit and prosecution should follow. Then there's the thought that people caught the "morning after" should be treated more favourably. No to that too. Let's pave the way for fast drink-driving prosecution. I won't even mention the "just once off" drinking-driving, prosecute.
 
To repeat - it's not an offence to drink alcohol and drive - once you're under the limits. Roadside breath test machines can't be used in evidence - a further, more complex breath test has to be taken (twice) at a Garda station - and the motorist has to be observed for 20 minutes before any test to ensure they don't consume anything after being arrested. That's the way it works.

See page 4 here:


Will the preliminary roadside test stand up in court / be used in court?

The roadside test is not evidentiary; it is only a preliminary test .A further specimen of blood or urine will be required which will be taken in the Garda station and analysed by the MBRS and the results of that test will be used in court as evidence.


If roadside machines - which are tested by Professor Cusack's Medical Bureau - can't be used in evidence how can a device fitted to a car be able to detect whether someone is over the legal limit? That's where the legal minefield arises. Someone who is not over the legal limit could be prevented from going about their business if such a device were to prevent their car from starting. Not making any moral judgement here - and there are many who would say those repeat offenders should have a lifetime ban.

(I'll be out on the M50 later today and I'll witness crazy, dangerous behavior - mainly people changing lanes suddenly, shooting from outside lanes to exit ramps without signalling, causing other drivers to hit the brakes narrowly avoiding pile ups. There'll be zero enforcement.)
 
Last edited:
If roadside machines - which are tested by Professor Cusack's Medical Bureau - can't be used in evidence how can a device fitted to a car be able to detect whether someone is over the legal limit?
I haven't seen any suggestion that the devices would be used in evidence, that's not how they operate in other jurisdictions. Clearly they would prevent the individual from drink driving and so are intended to prevent the offence taking place, not to allow and then record it.

and the motorist has to be observed for 20 minutes before any test to ensure they don't consume anything after being arrested.
The waiting period is to ensure enough time for full absorption into the blood stream. For similar reasons the blood or urine samples must be taken within 3 hours or driving for consideration.
 
Last edited:
they would prevent the individual from drink driving and so are intended to prevent the offence taking place,

And that's the legal minefield. The offence is driving over the limit. There's no offence if the driver is within the limits and you may be preventing them from going to work, collecting a child from school etc. (Yes, I know that they should have thought of all that before committing the original offences and there wouldn't be much sympathy for them). In order to work there would have to be a legal ban on all alcohol consumption for those repeat offenders and perhaps that could happen.

I can't see it happening anytime soon - apart from on a voluntary, trial basis on a very small number of cases.
 
In order to work there would have to be a legal ban on all alcohol consumption for those repeat offenders and perhaps that could happen.
Why would that be required here when it's not elsewhere? What's unique about Irish drink drivers?
 
I'll be out on the M50 later today and I'll witness crazy, dangerous behavior - mainly people changing lanes suddenly, shooting from outside lanes to exit ramps without signalling, causing other drivers to hit the brakes narrowly avoiding pile ups. There'll be zero enforcement.
I drive on the M50 twice a day. While there is dangerous driving, people not indicating, people hogging the middle lane etc statistically it's probably the safest road in Ireland.

I've been driving for over 30 years and the quality of driving is way better than it was 30 years ago. Younger drivers are much better trained and more skilled than young drivers were when I started driving. The statistics back that up as despite a big increase in population and a massive increase in cars on the road there has been a significant reduction in road deaths over that period.
 
What's unique about Irish drink drivers?

I dunno - possibly because we have a similar legal system to the UK - where the courts can't order offenders to install interlocks.

(The drink drive limits are higher in England at 80milligrams - compared to Ireland's 50mgs. There's been huge resistance to lowering them to protect country pubs.)
 
Last edited:
I dunno - possibly because we have a similar legal system to the UK - where the courts can't order offenders to install interlocks.
Most other countries operating this system are not mandating their installation. They offer them as an alternative to a lengthy driving ban. Mandating would likely require the state to pay for installation where the models I've seen indicate the driver must pay.

If there was a concern, perhaps its one of allowing the wealthy avoid a driving ban. Austria is one of the more expensive models I've seen with a cost to the driver of €5,700 to have the system in place for 2 years.

The cost benefit analysis carried out on the trial here gives a lot more details.
 
I do have some sympathy for those caught just over the legal limit,
I have zero sympathy and zero tolerance.
but I think people who are way* over the legal limit should be put off the road until their case is heard in court....car impounded, license handed over and insurance company notified
Bear in mind they haven't been prosecuted or found guilty of any crime yet Maybe give them the option of fitting the interlock to their car or giving up their driving privileges pending trial.
 
I dunno - possibly because we have a similar legal system to the UK - where the courts can't order offenders to install interlocks.

(The drink drive limits are higher in England at 80milligrams - compared to Ireland's 50mgs. There's been huge resistance to lowering them to protect country pubs.)
And their road deaths are half of ours.
They have around the same number of police per capita so it's not resources and it's not the law.
I suspect the difference is enforcement and the courts system.
 
Back
Top