Bad Service from Solicitor

M

MandaC

Registered User
Messages
1,784
My mum was injured in an accident in January, unfortunately she is still off work and has had to pursue an injuries claim. She did not feel up to dealing with PIAB, etc, herself so we appointed a Solicitor for her. That was about 3 months ago. The Solicitor said the first thing he would do was obtain her doctors report. Three months later and there is still no sign of it. My mum has phoned three times in the last week, and the Secretary was to follow up, she then needed to speak to the Solictor/Book keeper to follow up, my mum has been promised calls back which never materialise.

They sent her a letter asking if she was able to attend a Doctors examination for the other side. I sent them a fax confirming ok. The same letter was sent again to Mum twice (after I had sent the fax) requesting she confirm to them, even though they had previously confirmed receipt of the fax. Also, the address details they gave us for the other side's doctor was incorrect and I spent Friday morning driving around town(which I hate) and eventually found the place by default.

I phoned the Solicitor's office on Friday and requested an update on Mum's behalf, still no call back. Today, I sent a fax listing the queries Mum has and requested that she is called back urgently. Still no call back.
Dealing with the Solicitor is turning out to be a nightmare, and I do not feel she has received the professional service that she deserves.

Does anyone know if it is possible to have the file moved as we have no confidence in this practice at all? Are other Solicitors reluctant to take on such cases.

Any advice would be much appreciated.]

Many thanks,

MandaC
 
It is possible to move the file, but you must pay the current solicitor first. They should be no problem with another solicitor taking on the case.

I am currently having probs with a solictor handling an uncontested probate. I keep writing nasty letters threatening law society action. Not even the threat of a compalint to the law society phases them. Why are they so cocky/arrogant?
 
I'd say sending threatening letters is not much good, but what should work is calling every hour on the hour asking for an update. That will soon start to piss them off and hopefully they'll pull the finger out.
 
MandaC- a good idea if you are anxious about a file in a solicitors office is to make an appointment to see them. You can then talk to them face to face. If you are still unhappy, vote with your feet, but you will have to pay any costs incurred to date. BTW your mothers solicitor is not able to talk to you about your mothers file without her express consent- client confidentiality, so make sure your mother goes, not just you.

Bond007, perhaps the reason the solicitor is not phased by threats of law society reports is that they have done nothing wrong. We live in a culture where everyone wants everything NOW. Unfortunately even with best efforts, some probates can take up to a year and longer.Are you the executor? The solicitor acts on the executors instructions, no one elses.
 
Yes, in cases like this, the 'squeeky wheel' method is the best way to get action.

Just keep annoying them, and eventually they will have to oil it.
 
Vanilla said:
MandaC- a good idea if you are anxious about a file in a solicitors office is to make an appointment to see them. You can then talk to them face to face. If you are still unhappy, vote with your feet, but you will have to pay any costs incurred to date. BTW your mothers solicitor is not able to talk to you about your mothers file without her express consent- client confidentiality, so make sure your mother goes, not just you.

Bond007, perhaps the reason the solicitor is not phased by threats of law society reports is that they have done nothing wrong. We live in a culture where everyone wants everything NOW. Unfortunately even with best efforts, some probates can take up to a year and longer.Are you the executor? The solicitor acts on the executors instructions, no one elses.
Click to expand...

Yes I see your point Vanilla, but that does not excuse at least an simple explanation from the solicitor to set things straight to the client.
 
Yes I agree, at least in relation to MandaC, it does sound like the solicitor should have talked to her mother. But we all make mistakes so if you make an appt and in actual fact he or she is progressing the file, then maybe this will satisfy her mother.
 
Just to let you know. I went for the initial consultation with my mother and the Solicitor, so the Solicitor is aware that Mum is in total agreement for the case to be discussed with me, in fact, Mum felt it would be better if that was the way it was done, because to be honest, she lacks confidence dealing with legal issues.


In reality, there must have been at least 10 calls placed to the Solicitor and two faxes and not one call has been returned. I am also annoyed about the careless mistakes, ie sending us into town to the wrong address on a wild goose chase. I personally do not think this is an acceptable way to treat clients. Mum is to visit the Doctor today, and now she has to ask the doctor if her Solicitor has been in touch because she has been unable contact her own representative.Thats no way to do business. I work in a taxation consultants and we would not survive if we ignored clients that way. Because we are a busy practice, sometimes we have to turn away clients or refer them to another practice because we feel it is better to offer a professional service, than to fob people off with sub-standard service. I would have preferred if the Solicitor was honest from the get go and we could have consulted someone who can offer the service that is deserved.

Sorry for the Rant, I am just fuming at the moment.
 
Vanilla said:
Bond007, perhaps the reason the solicitor is not phased by threats of law society reports is that they have done nothing wrong. We live in a culture where everyone wants everything NOW. Unfortunately even with best efforts, some probates can take up to a year and longer.Are you the executor? The solicitor acts on the executors instructions, no one elses.
Click to expand...

Its almost 2 years since the matter was left to them. I put the matter in his hands 2 days after the death. The inquest was 18 months ago. The matter is straight forward. They had all the details.

I had to do their donkey work in calling up insurance companies etc. They don't respond to letters or phone calls. Their staff are rude on the phone. Promises to return calls are empty. The only thing that stirs them is the occasional threatening letter.

They just don't care and they know that nothing can be done to them. If any other business was ran in this manner there would be no business left.

I am sorry now that I didn't do probate myself.
 
You didnt answer my question as to whether you are the executor or not, but I assume given your level of involvement that you are. It sounds to me like the service you are getting is very poor- why are you accepting this? If you are the executor you are entitled to take the file elsewhere after paying them for the work done to date. I assure you not all solicitors are like this- I believe the client comes first, if they are not happy with the level of service I provide, ultimately I will lose out on future work and indeed on referrals.
 
forget the solicitor at this stage and deal directly with the PIAB they will send you all the forms you need, since your month had the accident in Jan she has to go the the PIAB first in any case so all your solicitor is doing is preparing a file for the PIAB. Go direct they are very very helpful
 
Current indications are that applicants who deal directly with PIAB instead of through a solicitor fare worse in terms of the amount of compensation awarded.
 
Vanilla said:
You didnt answer my question as to whether you are the executor or not, but I assume given your level of involvement that you are. It sounds to me like the service you are getting is very poor- why are you accepting this? If you are the executor you are entitled to take the file elsewhere after paying them for the work done to date. I assure you not all solicitors are like this- I believe the client comes first, if they are not happy with the level of service I provide, ultimately I will lose out on future work and indeed on referrals.
Click to expand...
Yes I am the executer.

The problem is I can't pay anyone till probate is granted and I can get money from the estate. If I had the means I would pay the bad solicitor off and have his bill taxed.

I am sure he knows that I cant pay him off and is thus continuing to knock me around.
 
If you are really unhappy it is possible that your old solicitor might accept an undertaking from your new solicitor to pay them their fees ( once taxed if you feel it necessary) out of the proceeds of the estate. Alternatively, you could get your new solicitor to give an undertaking to a bank for a loan to pay off the old solicitor. Chances are if relations are bad between you and this solicitor, they will jump at the chance to pass the file on.

If you feel you should stay with the old solicitor for whatever reason, I feel a direct approach is the best. Threatening with a complaint to the law society every now and then will only make relations poor- make appointments and meet the solicitor in person and enquire as to progress. And keep doing it. If you are about to land in his or her office, I'm sure the file will get their attention.
 
Just to update the above. I contacted the Solicitors Office on Tuesday. He was not there so I got his Secretary. Explained that Mum was not having her calls returned and if they were too busy to deal with the case, I would be able to deal with PIAB directly myself on her behalf. We had thought about lodging the application forms direct with PIAB ourselves, and I would have had no problem in doing that, but I believe that if you need legal advice, you leave it in the hands of a Solicitor, if you need tax advice, see a Tax Consultant, etc. I have seen first hand results of DIY tax work!

Anyway, the Secretary was great, knew all about the file and explained what had moved and what hadn't. I explained if we are not kept informed of any updates, then we would rather do it ourselves. I have the Secretary's contact details now so Mum can call her if she needs reassurance. Have an appointment for Tuesday next week to complete the PIAB documentation.
 
His practice wouldn't be on one of the roads off Leeson Street in Dublin by any chance as he sounds like the tosser that worked on a case for me? He would eventually return a phone call after a month only to tell me something that he had told me two months previously as "new news". He used forward the other sides correspondence to me, ask me to read it, and then to I had to instruct him what to do. When I said to him "are you not supposed to be advising ME" he would say over and over "I act on your instructions". It got really bad when I had to dictate letters to him and proof read them before they were posted. I still have bad dreams about him and I would say that he upset me more than "the other side".
 
Are you referring to the solicitor off Pembroke Street who is not very "Kean" , I used him once and what a GOB$hite , ended up going to the Law Society, moving the file without paying a penny for the bad service, but I have to say once the Law Society stepped in and I provided them with some off his ridiculous correspondence he totally pulled away from the matter.

Vanilla, one point I have with your feedback is that you keep mentioning paying a solicitor for the work they have done, that’s fare enough if they can prove it but quite often when you move away from the solicitor they always slam in a ridiculous fee and to be honest would you pay any other service provider if they treated you in the same way.



PIAB at the moment is working wonderfully and to be honest people are receiving higher awards through mediation and also significantly higher awards when they go to Court. It has cut out quite a good deal of bogus claims which was never an issue with some solicitors. But this increase in awards has all been introduced by the "Book of Quantum" which is on the PIAB website. Also remember any funds that your solicitor has at the end of the settlement will come from the award as PIAB and most insurers do not pay for legal fees unless the matter proceeds through to the old road.

I think you should read the PIAB site and call them on their helpline, at the end of the day it is not rocket science.
 
90210- you are entitled to ask for your costs to be taxed if you don't agree with the amount. In relation to PIAB, at the end of the day people who go to PIAB unrepresented are in my opinion doing themselves a disservice- it makes sense that having a legal representative who has experience in what and how to claim for various matters will be better than going before them unrepresented. Yes, you will have to pay your legal fees, but they will be earned.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top