Appeal success

Nellers

Registered User
Messages
18
Hi, after much waiting and sending HMRC more information for my appeal for Class 2, I received my letter today granting the appeal. I’ve 20 years to buy back at Class 2. Off to the bank tomorrow to get this done and dusted. Thanks to everyone that has posted their individual cases, it so helpful and in particular to @DannyBoyD whose sage advise was clear and precise with the volume of queries he dealt with.
 
Thanks folks - I'm delighted so many folks have been able to avail of this.

No obligation at all to do so, but if anyone would like to pay it forward, a donation to the Samaritans in memory of my mother would be much appreciated.
 
Hi guys, for people like me who worked in numerous places from 2009 to 2019 in Ireland. How detailed were you when filling
in the paperwork for the appeal to pay class 2. I had a permanent job in the Uk which I left, but my plans changed and
then I temped afterwards for a few weeks before I came home. To this day I cannot remember the agency who got me
the temp job or even how long I worked for. My mind is just blank. HMRC want the details of my last job in the UK also. SHould
I just give them the name of the permanent job I had.....I actually have my last payslip from that job.
 
Also for years that I didnt work in Ireland I have prsi S contributions, can these be used to pay class 2? Thanks
so much.
 
Hi, I wasn’t sure of dates that I started working when I returned to Ireland and used a rough guess for the dates, I did call to the social welfare office to request my records of prsi payments that was posted out to me which I included in my appeal. I think they’re more keen to see that you worked up until you left the UK. I would use a best guess scenario.
 
I wrote an appeal letter, but they never acknowledged it or responded per se. I did an SAR to no avail. I had a good phone call where they were straight that I needed better records, and they couldn't help me. Just odd they never acknowledged the appeal
 
@mmclo when I sent the 2nd appeal where they requested the information to be laid out in a table style so it was easier for them to read. It was showing as completed on my HMRC gateway account within a few days of them receiving it.
 
Thanks, my situation is fairly clear despite all this, I have to try and stand up 3 years (of 4) that are not in their system despite the fact i can see the pay packets as clear as day in my memory and got rebates (not relevant according to HMRC) so need to set aside some dedicated space to work on it and spend time in UK I think. As I had the CF83 in on time, I'm thinking I can take my time on that as 11 years off UK pension age
 
Hi just wanted to share my good news and thank you to all who helped. My appeal was successful, instead of paying all at class 3. I can
now pay with a mixture of class 2 and 3 according to my work prsi record in Ireland since 2006. Some years were all class 3 but still feel
so lucky to have a pension from the UK. An unexpected bonus. Fair play to them, must be costing them a bomb. I just cant get my
head around it. All my communication was by post and took nearly two years to get there.
 
@Dopey1 I have just joined this forum and would be grateful if you can let me know how you managed to get the class 2. I have had a nightmare dealing with them over the last two years. I was awarded class 2 to buy back the years and then the wrote back after I made the payment saying it should have been class 3 so they refunded me and I have been trying to appeal the decision since but getting nowhere.
 
I have been trying to appeal the decision
What do you mean by 'trying to appeal' - have you actually submitted an appeal? Or are you saying you don't know how to do it?

If you did submit an appeal, did you include documentation & your grounds?

Have you had a response? what was the response?
 
Yes I have submitted an appeal but they are now saying it was a mistake that I was awarded class 2 but I have heard that many others were issued a class 3 rate after originally receiving class 2. They asked me for details of my Irish pension so I sent that back in July with copies of all correspondence received from them to date plus all my letters.
 
Hi everybody. I sent the payment in for the shortfall and It was rejected because it was outside the 31 days.
Just got the letter today, it was dated 4th november. When I got the shortfall letter it too arrived about 12 days after the date so I
assumed there would be some wriggle room with payment. I got it 8th September. They must exactly mean the date of the letter then no matter when it arrives. They are going to refund my payment. Has this happened anybody else, should i try to appeal it. I did wait a bit before I paid it as I was waiting for to get the money together, they received it 12th October.
 
Is that it then because the letter didnt come till two weeks after the date.....would it be worth ringing them
 
Back
Top