2 litre plastic milk cartons

This is a food safety issue, so be sure to complain. The manufacturer will act if it is a food safety issue. Although I heard one professional say particles smaller than 3 mm are not considered a risk. Hopefully they will listen and make changes.
 
I’ve reported the same issue with the health department and they aren’t interested. Dunnes milk is ready bad plastic coming from tops
 
Does anyone have a picture? I notice white flecks occasionally but it just crumbles when you touch it so it's only dried milk.
Curiously the flakes that come off the semi-translucent Avonmore cartons with the blue lids are also white! I read a report recently looking at microplastics in bottled water that found concentrations in glass bottles was higher than in plastic ones.
 
What is this fuss about the microplastic in the milk? It is all over the place-in the water, in the air, in the soil, in every bit of food you eat.
The average human swallows the amount of a credit card per week. This intake is increasing all the time. Most of it is excreted in one or more ways. But some is deposited for ever in our bodies.
It is OUR lifestyle which creates this situation. Don't blame "The Industry".
 
This is only an issue since the unremoveable caps came in.

Since Dunnes removed the silver plastic seal from the bottles it does not appear to be as much of a problem. The unremovable cap is a stronger screw version and is better.
 
Since Dunnes removed the silver plastic seal from the bottles it does not appear to be as much of a problem. The unremovable cap is a stronger screw version and is better.
There is nothing better about the unremoveable caps. Just causes milk to spill.
 
Just causes milk to spill.

I have found that since they did away with the internal sealed silver cap the new ones are much easier to tighten and the milk does not spill. I buy a lot of milk and find the 2 litre bottles fine. Haven't tried the 3 litre ones which a lot of people seem to prefer because they are probably better value.
 
Are we talking plastic cartons or the cardboard Avonmore ones? I can taste the plastic in the milk itself out of the plastic bottles so I only buy the cardboard stuff.
 
Seriously! I can always taste a difference.
blind test required to verify your results. There may well be a difference, as the bottles are exposed to light and the tetrapaks aren't, but they're both using plastic to contain the liquid.

Personally I try to buy milk in tetrapaks as there's less plastic waste involved, though against that the plastic bottles are probably more likely to see the plastic recycled. But against that again, plastic recycling is largely a sham, so in summary, I don't know.
 
Note the carton ones are lined in the same polyethylene that the plastic ones are made
well I can also taste the plastic from the plastic cartons, and I know lots of people that experience the same thing and consequently only buy tetra pak cartons not plastic. Obviously its only some people that experience this but there must be some thing to it. The tetra pak also have foil and yes a thin layer of plastic but its obviously different to full plastic cartons.
When I googled the topic AI gave an answer that said the taste can occur from leaching of styrene from the plastic into the milk. It can occur with cheaper low quality , translucent plastic combined with UV light if not stored in darkness, Best to use tetra pak or plastic containers that are not translucent.
 
Last edited:
The tetra pak also have foil and yes a thin layer of plastic but its obviously different to full plastic cartons.
They're lined with polyethylene, same material the plastic jugs are made from but some do note a taste difference.
 
They're lined with polyethylene, same material the plastic jugs are made from but some do note a taste difference.
Yes but it's only a thin film and the UV action on the milk and plastic does not occur because light cannot get through the carton.
However tetrapak I remember was out before plastic milk containers i remember back in the 80s even though producing tetrapak containers is not as simple as producing plastic containers. So obviously some reason why it was used first, maybe the transition from glass bottles to plastic would have been noticed by far more people in the taste testing so going first to tetrapak first then to plastic was the way they went. I'm just thinking out loud here by the way?
 
However tetrapak I remember was out before plastic milk containers i remember back in the 80s even though producing tetrapak containers is not as simple as producing plastic containers.
Tettrapaks are made by folded and bonding sheets of a card with a layer polyethylene layer. The technology to produce those is pretty simple and has been around a lot longer than blow moulding.

I'm just thinking out loud here by the way?
Same, and we're probably thinking off-topic in terms of taste imparted versus the original concern of 'plastic' pieces being released through opening the container lids.
 
Back
Top