Women's spending habits

D

daltonr

Guest
I don't know if this should be in The Craic, or here.

There's a magazine called Company which is a womans mag like Cosmo or whatever. (please don't ask how or why I was reading it!!!).

Anyhooo. Possibly the funniest/scariest column I've seen for a long time was one entitled "Creative Accounting", which explained to ladies how they could juggle their figures in order to afford that expensive dress, or pair of shoes or whatever.

I was expecting something along the lines of using the 56 days interest free credit on a card, or haggling with the store for a cash price instead of paying with VISA, or avoiding store credit like the plague!

But no. The advice was as follows:

Find a dress that is extremely expensive say...£600. Then don't buy it. Buy a dress for £60 instead. Now, you've saved yourself £540. Now you can buy those shoes for £140, and your still £400 to the good.

It goes on in this vain and gets MUCH worse.

Is this really how women think?

I don't want to appear rude or chauvinistic but seriously if there are people walking around with this kind of reasoning then I'd like to know about it because they clearly pose a danger to all of us.

I'd like to think that this column was in jest, but there's nothing to suggest that it was. Maybe by not having womens intuition I wasn't able to see though the joke!

-Rd
 
Money management

I don't know why you are so surprised. Just look at the women involved in the three Show me the Money programmes. Remember the one who said that cutting up the credit card or refusing to accept a loan offer was like throwing away real money.
 
Re: Money management

Just for the record, I don't want this to be a "women are crap with money" thread. For one thing I don't believe that that's true. (Irish Mammies in particular do wonders with limited amounts of money).

I'm curious though. DId I happen to hit on the one really bad column, or is this kind of advice routinely handed out in these glossy mags?

-Rd
 
Re: Yeah

From what I heard about SMTM the men weren't exactly financial wizards themselves.... :|
 
company magazine financial advice to woman

Hi Daltonr.

Ok, I would very much be in the target audience for company magazine and while I wouldnt be as bad as the girl on the "show me the money" I must admit it takes a lot of self control sometimes not to go out and buy shoes with my plastic flexible friend.

I didnt read the article you are referring to but I can safely say that we are not that stupid with money and nor would most magazines assume us to be.

These magazines are primarily focussed at fashion (not finance) is it possible that this quote...:

"Find a dress that is extremely expensive say...£600. Then don't buy it. Buy a dress for £60 instead. Now, you've saved yourself £540. Now you can buy those shoes for £140, and your still £400 to the good."

...Was saying find a dress that is extremely expensive but rather than buying it wait until there are cheaper imitations at £60. ie Quite frequently when a look is made popular by some star there are very quickly cheaper imitations in the shops. Are you sure it didnt mean that? (Which would be quite good advice)

Just wondering, but no, rest assured, we are not that financially dim.

MC
 
Re: Hilarious Article - Creative Accounting

"please don't ask how or why I was reading it!!!"

But I will ask - was it to get a good laugh at our expense?

As a matter of interest daltonr approx. just how much of the Irish female population would you think falls into this category taking "Irish Mammies in particular do wonders with limited amounts of money" into consideration? :rolleyes
 
Re: Hilarious Article - Creative Accounting

sueellen,

But I will ask - was it to get a good laugh at our expense?
Click to expand...

Absolutley not. I had no idea until after I read it that it would be so laughable. I read it because it was there, and the only other thing on offer was the Evening Herald.

As a matter of interest daltonr approx. just how much of the Irish female population would you think falls into this category
Click to expand...

I would hope that very very few people are as bad as the one that wrote this article. Although I have to say since reading it and hearing some peoples reaction to it, I do wonder. Shoes in particular seem to be a big weakness. All logic seems to go out the window when faced with a shoe shop. I suppose in my life I've spend as much on Books, CD's and DVD's, but I'd like to think a library is more sensible than a shoe rack.

Your take on the article is sensible, but if you read it you'll see it wasn't quite as sensible as that. In fact I didn't even do justice to the sheer stupidity of it in my earlier post.

It included:

Justifying the purchase of a new pair of shoes by deciding not to go out that night, and then having bought them deciding that she just had to go out to show them off.

Justifying another expense on the basis that she and partner had talked vaguely about going to Paris some time, and since she wasn't in Paris she could clearly afford to go out.

I don't know, maybe if I read it regularly I'd realise that this column was a satire which takes the piss out of people with this attitude, but I fear the whole thing was straight up financial advice for the busy shopaholic.

-Rd
 
company magazine

In fairness daltonr, it is company magazine...Im not exactly going to read heat magazine for stock market advice and investment.

But you have a valid point, those magazines havent a clue about sensible finance advice for their target market and your suggestions above about store credit cards etc would be much more sensible and much more in their interest.

I think the moral of the story is...next time pick up the evening herald :)
 
Re: company magazine

...Im not exactly going to read heat magazine for stock market advice and investment.
Click to expand...

Now there's a point. I don't read Mens mags either but would you see an article like this in Heat or FHM? Would they advice on how to afford the latest Boys Toy using similar rationalle.

I suspect a boys mag would choose the following line

"This flat screen TV costs €5000, you may have to stop feeding your kids for a month or two but that'll teach them valuable survival skills that will stand to them in future life, and besides, you're worth it."

i.e. the Boys mag advice would be more obviously a joke and would be less likely to be followed by a reader. If anyone posts saying they'd stop feeding their kids to buy a tv I'll take back everything I've said about women.

The Company magazine logic I can actually imagine being taken seriously.

-Rd
 
Re: company magazine

I'm not trying to be sexist here but maybe Company have more confidence in their readership's intelligence and ability to pick up on more subtly ironic (?) articles whereas the lad-mags have to spell it out more. Vive la difference and all that mullarky. Pity there isn't a link to the article - I'd love to read it now.

Rebecca

PS DaltonR, thanks for fixing my post yesterday re the Foreign Nationals/Banks.
 
Re: company magazine

maybe Company have more confidence in their readership's intelligence
Click to expand...

Could be! As I said from the start I'd like to think this column was a send up. Maybe I'm not into the subtlety of female humour. I don't get Deirdre O'Kane, does that mean anything?

Pity there isn't a link to the article - I'd love to read it now.
Click to expand...

I'll go and try to find that mag again and photocopy the article. I'll bring it along to the next AAM night out.

-Rd
 
Re: company magazine

I don't get Deirdre O'Kane, does that mean anything?
Click to expand...

Not really - she's simply not funny. Just for balance neither is Des Bishop. :)
 
Forget the shoes girls its official

Hey Daltonr

I went looking online to see if I could find the offending piece and I couldnt (unfortunately) however on their homepage www.company.co.uk there is a link to an article on mortgages beginning with the following sentence:

"Forget shoes – the latest must-have purchase for women is a home of their own. "

:lol

Oh dear.
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

"Forget shoes – the latest must-have purchase for women is a home of their own. "
Click to expand...

Why stop at one home, surely you'd need a couple. I mean it's not like you can buy just one that goes with everything!

Just for balance neither is Des Bishop.
Click to expand...

No he's not great. He has his moment, but he's no Bill Hicks.
Does anyone find it a bit ironic that an American is trying to educate us about the minimum wage!?!?!?

But at least he hasn't done a car Ad yet! Shame on you Deirdre. SHAME ON YOU!!!

-Rd
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

No he's not great. He has his moment, but he's no Bill Hicks.
Click to expand...

He's a pain in the Boll Hicks if you ask me.

But at least he hasn't done a car Ad yet! Shame on you Deirdre. SHAME ON YOU!!!
Click to expand...

Maybe that rule of thumb posted here a while back should be extended to cover this scenario too...

"Never, ever buy a financial product advertised by Linda Martin, any member of the cast of Glenroe" ... or any other Irish B list (if that's not a tautology?) celebrity...
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

This may be relevant...

click on to www.independent.ie and take a look at the pop up MBNA add, titled Crazy Jane - its quite funny, but scary at the same time.
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

On a serious note, I wonder if there is any research into gender differences on money and spending issues.

I remember reading one of the threads about the differences between men and women and one was:
A woman will buy something that is reduced in price, even if she doesn't need or want it.
A man will buy something he wants, no matter what price it is.
Click to expand...
I can think of loads of confirming examples. But, if I wanted to disprove it, I could probably find loads of contradicting examples.

I posted a link to some research which showed that women stock market investors outperform men fairly consistently. But someone else questioned the validity of the research.

Brendan
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

I posted a link to some research which showed that women stock market investors outperform men fairly consistently. But someone else questioned the validity of the research.
Click to expand...

There have been one or two high profile cases of Investment Clubs consisting entirely of woment that have done well. Of course there are probably many times more that have failed.

Like everything else in this world I doubt there is anything inate in women that gives them a different attitude to money. As much as Shoes have become a bit of a cliche for womens spending habits, men have equivalents, like DVD's, or Home entertainment equipment, or bits and pieces for the Car.

The one think I will say is that women need to cop themselves on and refuse to pay the Hairdressers the fees they are charged. If you tried to charge men €150 for a haircut there'd be a lot more men with long hair and home made haircuts.

Oh and one other money saving tip ladies... YOU LOOK MUCH BETTER PALE THAN WITH FAKE TAN!!!!! In fact you look terrible with fake tan and it's about time you stopped kidding yourselves.

-Rd
 
Re: Forget the shoes girls its official

Does that mean that I should stop using my Grecian 2000 too?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top