Which is the better of these 2 PRSA providers?

Impossible question.

The better one is the one that will provide you a larger fund at retirement. This will be determined by future fund performance, which cannot be known in advance.

Best you can do is find the one that's best suited to your preferences.

Pick the one that has the lower charges and fund(s) that suit your risk profile.
 
There are plenty of places where you can see past performance. www.finfacts.ie would be just one. But past performance is just that - in the past. While consistent outperformance over various time periods cannot be entirely ignored, I wouldn't use it as the only criterion for choosing a PRSA.
 
I know its not a perfect indicator. If charges are the same i need something to base my choice on. I was kind of hoping someone whould say BOI are complete disaster steer clear or Irish life are a disaster steer clear to make ny decision easier :)
 
Back
Top