Solid Wood Worktop

start

Registered User
Messages
25
Hi,

Just want to know what are the Pros and Cons Solid Wood Worktop. Does anyone have good experience or bad. ?

I am hearing mixed reviews, i.e look great but they easily scratch/stain. Is it worth the extra few quid. Does anyone have one for 3- 4 years now, how is it holding up?

Thanks in advance for any replies!
 
I had a beech worktop for about 6 years. As you said - looked great, but easily scratched and stained. Mind you, it is very forgiving, a few minor scratches didn;t ruin the look of it.

It got some water stains at the edges of the sink after a few years and a turmeric stain that lasted forever.

They need to be oiled every few years, but its not a big job.

Beech is a very pale wood, I recently saw a walnut worktop which looked fantastic and being a darker wood, minor stains would not show up as much.
 
Thanks Huskerdu

Those stains around the sink apparently get really bad -
Kind of hard to justify methinks spening a pile of money on a solid worktop , and then having to tip-toe around it

Having said that , sold wood worktops can look great in a kitchen,

Im still in two minds...
 
We have one which I love and it was in great condition for 5 or 6 years when it was being oiled regularly and we ensure that no water was left on the wood around the sink just by wiping it with a towel after washing up. But then the house was rented out and the tenants obviously didn't bother oiling or wiping down the work surface and after only one year there was very bad water damage/staining around the sink. So grand if you're the careful type ( and it's not a hassle at all, very easy to wipe with a bit of oil every now and then) but not for you if you expect little or no maintenance.
 
The worktop can always be sanded down and re-oiled which should help with most stains and marks.
 
I have an oak countertop. It looks great but you do have to be extra mindful of them not to put hot plates on the surface and wipe up any spills. I think they are worth it though as they look so much nicer than laminate.
 
You can have metal rods inset into the wood worktop, called Trivet rods I think, and you can then place hot items onto the metal rods.

An example here..

[broken link removed]

and here..
[broken link removed]

OK, so wood is likely not the most suitable for worktops, but it depends on your point of view. It requires some maintainence... but basically to oil it you only wipe over the surface with a cloth with oil on it... takes about 5 mins... and you only do this every six months or so, and more often around the sink, or as required. The more coats the merrier...

It takes a while to dry, perhaps six hours or overnight, or before you leave for work.. no point doing this a half hour before tea-time. Just use Danish Oil, or a dedicated worktop oil, like ones from Liberon, or Chestnut, or others I'm sure.


Wood worktops can get scratched or marked, a bit of sanding will fix most of this, and marks can be desirable depending on your point of view.

You need to use upstands at the back, like a skirting board, (see pics above)... this allows you to leave an expansion gap at the back of the worktop, and it can expand and contract into the space left below the upstands. The worktop should only be firmly fixed at the front in this case, although you can use 'buttons' to keep the worktop down at the back while still allowing movement. The upstands will also tend to keep the back down so the 'buttons' may not be necessary.

In some cases, where there's no joins, you can firmly attach the back of the worktop, and allow expansion at the front edge... although you would likely need the 'buttons' to keep the front edge down.



The most suitable worktop is likely to be a laminate, in that it's cheap, hard wearing, durable, hygenic enough I think, etc etc...and they do look ok.

Commercial kitchens always use stainless steel... this may be because it is hygenic, and easy to see dirt on, and keep clean... you could have one installed in a house although it wouldn't look great, would it?

Other worktops could be made from glass, coloured glass, tiles, granite, stone, re-constituted stone or manmade stone (silestone?), slate tiles, or cast concrete, which you can do nearly anything with, and it's very cheap for the concrete itself, and it can be coloured, made in any thickness, items can be inset into it, and it can be made into any shape. Concrete is the most used substance on earth.. not for worktops, just in general.

I've never heard of plastic or rubber etc being used as a worktop..

I have other pics of worktops if you'd like them, Beech, Iroko, Walnut, Oak, maybe Birch.. check out woodworkers.ie for sizes, prices and pics as well.

Cheers so
 
I have beech ones, think I bought them in woodworkers. They are hard work... I would not get them again, they need regular oiling - and it needs time for the oil to really sink in so you can't use them straight after oiling, they stain very easily (red wine is particulary bad), they burn if you do something silly and if any such thing happens, you have to sand them and reoil.... overall not the lazy option, next time I'll get granite or stone or something like that!
 
We have had ours for 6 years and I wish we had not chosen solid wood. Stains easily and while it is one thing being careful about not putting hot pots down on it, it is impossible to never splash water on it and to wipe down every splash the minute it happens. We, like vanilla, had tenants for 2 or the 6 years and they completely trashed it. We are getting it sanded and oiled because can't afford to replace it but everyone we have had to come and look at it has said even taking 4 - 5 mm off will only get rid of the worst of the stains. The water stains in particular have gone deep into the wood. Next time, if there is a next time, I would get concrete or stone.