Is this an ESPP (Employee Share Purchase Plan) or a SAYE (Save As You Earn) scheme or something? Revenue approved or not? What are you being charged tax on - the money saved or on any discount on the share price compared to market value? Are you initially avoiding tax/PRSI on the salary foregone and then being charged BIK? How exactly is the salary deduction done via payroll (e.g. is your gross on your payslip reduced by the salary foregone)?
For what it's worth my employer initially and mistakenly applied BIK tax and PRSI deductions via payroll on ESPP share price discounts until I pointed out to the that this was incorrect, that only tax applied and that this was dealt with on a self assessed basis by the employee via a [broken link removed]. Not sure if that's relevant in this case?
[broken link removed]e is a good summary of the BIK rules in force these days.