Power of attorney/ doctor fees

Discussion in 'Wills, inheritances and gifts' started by Bikini Widow, Jan 11, 2018 at 9:27 PM.

  1. Bikini Widow

    Bikini Widow Registered User

    Posts:
    42
    Hi all,
    I have a relative setting up power of attorney and their solicitor sent a letter to their GP to sign off on it.

    The GP is looking for 300 euro to complete this. Is this normal? Not sure what the GP is supposed to do exactly but 300 euro seems possibly excessive if just signing off on a document.

    Many thanks,
    BW
     
  2. Thirsty

    Thirsty Frequent Poster

    Posts:
    1,586
    Is this an Enduring Power of Attorney?
     
  3. DirectDevil

    DirectDevil Frequent Poster

    Posts:
    420
    €300 looks opportunistic and greedy. i.e. I am their G.P. and they need my approval so I can mark whatever fee I like.

    I would have thought that a fee of something like €75 to €100 would have been fair if there is a bit of paperwork involved.

    Unless the patient is living in a rural area with no real choice of G.P. a new G.P. should be able to do what is required.

    However, before breaking a relationship I would ask the G.P. directly if the charge of €300 is correct or was it a mistake ;)
     
    Dan Murray likes this.
  4. Dan Murray

    Dan Murray Frequent Poster

    Posts:
    429
    I'd also ask the GP what's involved precisely.

    As in: "I, Dr. Blah Blah, certify, that in my opinion, you are not nuts."

    Of course, anyone who pays €300 for such a certification is clearly nuts and should not be allowed to make a PoA, enduring or otherwise.

    So two things regarding our protected professionals here:

    - The arrogance and ignorance of the GP so blatantly over-charging; and
    - What's the solicitor doing.....shouldn't he be advising the client that €300 seems a bit pricey (or is the solicitor happy with the relativities with his own fee!?)

    Disclosure: My daughter is a medic
     
    DirectDevil likes this.
  5. elcato

    elcato Moderator

    Posts:
    2,705
    Who said the GP wanted €300 ? Was it the solicitor or have you seen a letter requesting this fee ? My mother had this done a while back and there was no fees involved directly with the GP. I can't be certain though that the legal bill had a charge on it for this but I'm pretty sure it didn't state it directly so maybe it is standard which is collected by the legal fees.
     
  6. Bikini Widow

    Bikini Widow Registered User

    Posts:
    42
    thanks all

    @elcato the Doctors admin person contacted my relative direct and told him there would be 300euro charge.

    @direct devil think my relative almost had a stroke when told. Doctor's surgery would be quite rural. Solicitor had no part in it apart from sending the request

    Thanks all for feeback.
    BW
     
  7. DirectDevil

    DirectDevil Frequent Poster

    Posts:
    420
    Last edited: Jan 12, 2018 at 4:20 PM
    I just had a second thought about this.

    I wonder if the G.P. thinks that he has been requested to prepare a medico-legal report on the patient and that he is charging accordingly.

    For example, if the patient had been in an accident and was asked by the solicitor to prepare a report for legal purposes that would be a "medico-legal report". I don't know what they charge for those these days !

    That said, I still think that the charge is a bit rich. My mother had a cardiac pacemaker implanted by a consultant cardiologist as a private patient. Her motor insurers wanted a letter confirming that she was safe to drive as a result of the procedure. The consultant sent her the relevant letter at no charge whatsoever.
     
    Last edited: Jan 12, 2018 at 4:20 PM
  8. Lillymarlane

    Lillymarlane New Member

    Posts:
    4
    B Widow...if the gp has to do a medical report on your relative, for the solicitor, to satisfy his/her opinion regarding your relatives competancy (to give instructions in the poa instrument)... then the '300€' seems to be a price that is charged by many medics (from my experience) for a medical report. However, if your relative has clarity of mind and their gp can verify this I do not see why there is a report required. A Medical Report would include an MMSE and would require the gp's time plus possible travel perhaps. But a verification as to competency where there is clearly no question (or a risk of undue influence/abuse) should not cost 300€. Just ask the solicitor what the 300 is for.
     
  9. llgon

    llgon Frequent Poster

    Posts:
    166
    I didn't understand this part. Who is protecting the GP and from what?
     
  10. Curlywurly

    Curlywurly Registered User

    Posts:
    18
    My mother was charged €75 for doctors report when making an enduring power of attorney. Doctor is in Dublin which I don't think should make a difference