Own apartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

D

d3481553

Registered User
Messages
14
Hi, I own an apartment which Im thinking about renting as I would like to do a bit of travelling.

I have done some research and renting a property is a daunting task to say the least as theres an awful lot involved and a lot of bases to be covered. The other caveat is that I would be about 3 months shy of the 2 years that you have to own a property before you can rent it.

My question is could I just get away with renting it under the rent-a-room scheme? I am not buying another property as my PPR, technically it will still be my PPR, Im just going on an extended holiday. While my potential lodger would be paying rent for the whole apartment, I could argue that he is only renting a room, he just happens to have the use of the whole apartment while I am on my extended holiday.

Does this sound reasonable?
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

No and don't expect to get much support for attempted tax evasion here.

What happens when your 'lodger' goes to claim tax relief on the monthly rent?

What happens when your lodger goes to deduct 20% of the rent payable to a non-resident landlord?

What happens if there is a fire or other damage to your property contents while you are 'on extended holiday'?

What happens if, with the utilities still in your name, your 'lodger' fails to pay the bills?

'technically it will still be my PPR' - utter nonsense, once you rent it it ceases to be your PPR, its an investment property.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

You have to operate within the tax rules on this one. Wait out the 3 months and rent it out then is my advice. Then go and enjoy your travels without fear of ever having an audit with the revenue.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

Thanks for the advise Cayne, Im inclined to agree with you

@mathepac
I think you need to calm down a little, Im on here to ask legitimate questions. I have no intention of evading tax but if theres a chance of doing things easier while not breaking any rules, I will explore all possibilities. I've simply asked if what I suggested is feasible, but its not and thats fine. Hopefully you can be a little more tolerant with other first posters looking for help.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

The other caveat is that I would be about 3 months shy of the 2 years that you have to own a property before you can rent it.
Click to expand...
I dont understand. If it's stamp-duty you are trying to avoid paying its five years but maybe this is social housing related or something.
What happens if you could be more civil with a first time poster?
Click to expand...
Eh ! So pointing out a blatant tax evasion ploy to someone in simple english is uncivil ? Maybe if the OP hugged the rule bug that would make him feel better ?
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

@elcato
Im a first time buyer and was therefore exempt from stamp duty and as far as I know you have to wait 2 years before you can rent your property otherwise you're liable for stamp duty clawback

...and I have no problem with people pointing out flaws in my reasoning, as Cayne kindly did, but theres a civil way of doing it. The forum is supposed to be a community of people with similar problems and solutions, not a firing range for people with slightly naive questions.

I just wanted advise from someone wiser on this subject than me. I don't think that advise should be dished out in the form of a boll0cking. I have no interest in tax evasion, if I did, I wouldn't be coming on here asking how to do things legitimately. I fully intend on registering with PRTB .etc.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

If you can wait the 3 months then i would do that.

Also something else to think about, i was reading a thread here the other day, someone thinking of doing the same as what you are, and when he spoke to his mortgage provider he ws told he woud have to move to an interest rate for an investment property which was a fair bit higher than what he is paying now.

I'm not sure if it's breaking the law to just not tell them about what you are planning. But best to find out what could happen if they found out you weren't living in the property anymore.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

Hmmm, interesting, I've been onto the bank a couple of times saying Im considering it and they havn't mentioned it, but more food for thought anyway, thanks
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

d3481553 said:
... I have done some research and renting a property is a daunting task to say the least as theres an awful lot involved and a lot of bases to be covered. The other caveat is that I would be about 3 months shy of the 2 years that you have to own a property before you can rent it...
Click to expand...
I think it is patently obvious what your intentions were coming on here. Having carefully researched the topic and identified some of the pitfalls and taxation issues, you pose the following -
d3481553 said:
... My question is could I just get away with renting it under the rent-a-room scheme? ...
Click to expand...
Someone who wants a legal and honest way out of a tax dilemma they have identified doesn't ask ' ...could I just get away with... ', which IMHO is an tax evasion question, but might ask something like 'Is there a legal way to avoid the taxes I will have to pay in the circumstances I describe?'
d3481553 said:
... technically it will still be my PPR, ... I could argue that he is only renting a room, he just happens to have the use of the whole apartment while I am on my extended holiday...
Click to expand...
Finally, the language traits which IMHO are the last refuge of the potential tax evader 'technically' and 'I could argue' and 'he just happens to have'.

In my view AAM has a reputation as a source of good honest information for tax-compliant individuals who pay their way and again IMHO there is no place for tax evasion type questions on the site.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

You have serious issues mathepac, disecting the semantics and context of each line of my post. I have repeatedly explained my position, that I have no intention of breaking any laws, Im simply looking for the most painless way of renting my apartment. I know nothing about this and Im starting from scratch so cut me a little slack and don't assume the worst of people straight off the bat.

The rest of the members have put forward useful constructive advise and even your first post had useful information although it was put across quite agressively. Theres no need to have a go at people, jump down their throat and accuse them of tax evasion. A simple 'no, you can't do that' would have done.
 
Last edited:
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

elcato said:
I dont understand. If it's stamp-duty you are trying to avoid paying its five years but maybe this is social housing related or something.
Click to expand...

Hi Elcato, rules changed back in 2007 - reduced the timeline for stamp duty clawback back to 2 years from 5.
 
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

d3481553 said:
You have serious issues mathepac, disecting the semantics and context of each line of my post. I have repeatedly explained my position, that I have no intention of breaking any laws, Im simply looking for the most painless way of renting my apartment. I know nothing about this and Im starting from scratch so cut me a little slack and don't assume the worst of people straight off the bat.

The rest of the members have put forward useful constructive advise and even your first post had useful information although it was put across quite agressively. Theres no need to have a go at people, jump down their throat and accuse them of tax evasion. A simple 'no, you can't do that' would have done.
Click to expand...

Hmmm - while I do think that mathepac was perhaps a bit abrupt in his post - your "righteous" indignation doesn't ring true. He didn't have to analyse your original post to arrive at exactly the same impression I and the other posters did. You knew what you were about and were looking for a way to get around/evade/avoid (choose your own spin on it) the cost to you of renting your apartment. You knew the right answer, you just wanted to see if there was a way to avoid it.

Do yourself the courtesy of admitting your own intelligence. Pretending you didn't understand that your question is readily understood (not construed, interpreted or inferred) as being tax evasion is not doing yourself justice.
 
Last edited:
Re: Rent-a-room Scheme

Management Companies, Apartments, is not the correct sub forum for this type of question. Management Companies, Apartments, relates to management of shared areas and multi unit developments etc.

Moved to Property Investment which is the forum which deals with landlord / tenant / rent-a-room issues.

,
As mathepac, so-crates and elcato (moderator) have pointed out we do not condone or discuss tax evasion schemes on AAM. Please do not engage in personalised exchanges with posters who point this out.("serious issues etc).

Legitimate discussion which focuses on the optimum legal way for you to manage your apartment while you are on your travels is allowed.

Ive expanded the title somewhat to more accurately reflect the question.

aj
moderator
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

Thanks for moving aj, I actually thought at the time I may have been posting in the wrong section. I think the amended title also reflects the honest nature of my original question, so I also thank you for that.

I obviously should have chosen my language more carefully as the 'get away with' bit seems to have gotten peoples backs up. I meant 'get away with' as in doing the minimum while staying within the law in the same way that you can 'get away with' worn tyres once they're not below the minimum tyre tread depth or 'get away with' having a glass of wine without being over the legal drink-drive limit.

Theres ways to reduce your tax bill without it being tax evasion (I just don't know them). A man can reduce the tax he pays by using his wifes tax credits (very loose example I know, but I can't think of anything else), does this amount to tax evasion because he's using a legal means by which to pay less tax? Thats all I was trying to do, exploring IF there was a way to makes things easier on myself. I never had and have no intention of breaking the law or discussing tax evasion schemes. I just thought the rent-a-room scheme might be an option, which it clearly isn't.

I've gotten a pretty hard time on here for an honest mistake or what some people believe to be a calculated ploy based on my perceived intelligence, which is unfair.

Thanks anyway for the bits of information people offered.
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

I'm not so sure it's as cut and dry as is being made out here.

Say I own my house 20 years and happily pay all my taxes etc. and I take in a lodger for 5 years under the rent a room scheme and he pays for a room in my house, then if I want to go on a round the world trip, do I have to eject the lodger? I doubt it. It's still my PPR. It's my home. When we go on holidays (ie, NOT to work abroad), even for a prolonged period it's still your PPR otherwise you'd be liable for CGT and everything which is obviously rubbish.

If the OP is content to take a lodger at the going rate for a ROOM and not the whole house (would exceed the 7k per annum limit on rent a room scheme anyway) then he should legally be able to go off on holiday and keep his lodger.

It WOULD be tax evasion if the OP conspired with the lodger Or lodgers to pay something under the table etc. to keep the declared income below the limits for rent a room. If I was the OP and I wanted to go travelling I would have no hesitation in seeking a trustworthy lodger for a few months before I go (so I could assess them before I left) and then get a family member to watch my house for me while I was away, collecting the rent (acting as a lawful agent) and making sure the bills were being paid.

If the OP needs the full market rent of the entire house (presume 3 bed in Dublin) to service his mortgage then it's obviously not going to be possible within the law. If the OPs mortgage is low enough and/or he has savings to make up the shortfall then taking a lodger in seems a reasonabe thing to do.
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

I think you need to get professional independent tax advice on the matter.

aj
moderator
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

There were a number of threads a while back (could be a couple of years) about the whole question of whether travelling for a long period changes the nature of your PPR. Revenue seem to take a view of saying "well, let us know the details and we'll tell you if your PPR has changed" - which is not ideal if you are enquiring after the event.

OP, I would also second ajapale's advice to seek professional advice, else write to the revenue and set out your exact intentions as to how long you'll be away, whether you will be working etc. and ask them for a view in advance.

OP, I think the reason you got a bit of a reaction was indeed your choice of words. Some people post onto AAM with thinly disguised (or not disguised at all) pleas as to how to evade tax and they generally get short shrift, and rightly so in my opinion. Due to your phrasing, I'd imagine some thought "here's another one" (as I did when I first read your initial post).

Slightly off topic to this but I do think that, when people do post about e.g. squeezing themselves into exemptions and reliefs that they are really not entitled to, the should be told straight up that it's unacceptable. In situations like that, I'm not in favour of the "if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all" view.
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

murphaph said:
I'm not so sure it's as cut and dry as is being made out here.

Say I own my house 20 years and happily pay all my taxes etc. and I take in a lodger for 5 years under the rent a room scheme and he pays for a room in my house, then if I want to go on a round the world trip, do I have to eject the lodger? I doubt it. It's still my PPR. It's my home. When we go on holidays (ie, NOT to work abroad), even for a prolonged period it's still your PPR otherwise you'd be liable for CGT and everything which is obviously rubbish.

If the OP is content to take a lodger at the going rate for a ROOM and not the whole house (would exceed the 7k per annum limit on rent a room scheme anyway) then he should legally be able to go off on holiday and keep his lodger.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your thoughts murphaph, funnily enough I was discussing this with a work colleague yesterday and he pondered the same point as you. I definitely think independent tax advise is a good idea, anyone know if you can hire a tax consultant on an hourly rate to have a chat about it? I think the easiest thing to do at the moment is to ring the revenue as suggested by my work mate and WaterSprite and see what they say

My (2 bed)apartment is outside Dublin and would fetch 600-650 p/m, so I assume the rent-a-room scheme would cover half of that, so I would still need to pay at least 300 per month + half the bills
 
Last edited:
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

d3481553 said:
Thanks for your thoughts murphaph, funnily enough I was discussing this with a work colleague yesterday and he pondered the same point as you. I definitely think independent tax advise is a good idea, anyone know if you can hire a tax consultant on an hourly rate to have a chat about it? I think the easiest thing to do at the moment is to ring the revenue as suggested by my work mate and WaterSprite and see what they say
Click to expand...
Independent advise or confirmation IN WRITING from revenue is the way to go. Under no circumstances get telephone confirmation and then proceed based solely on this.

d3481553 said:
My (2 bed)apartment is outside Dublin and would fetch 600-650 p/m, so I assume the rent-a-room scheme would cover half of that, so I would still need to pay at least 300 per month + half the bills
Click to expand...
Why would you be paying half the bills if you are using none of the utilitities? Maybe half the standing charge for your ESB (and half the line rental for telephone if you have one) is fair but not one penny of the bill itself for the time you are away.

Edit: it's no what the rent a room scheme will cover-it's what the MARKET RATE for a SINGLE room will cover. You cannot legally charge your tenant over the rate for a room to push the rent up to the rent a room limit as this would indeed be tax evasion (pretending to rent a room when in fact the tenant is renting the house-otherwise the tenant wouldn't pay over the odds for the 'room').
 
Re: Own appartment for just short of 2years. Going travelling :Rent-a-room Scheme?

murphaph said:
Edit: it's no what the rent a room scheme will cover-it's what the MARKET RATE for a SINGLE room will cover. You cannot legally charge your tenant over the rate for a room to push the rent up to the rent a room limit as this would indeed be tax evasion (pretending to rent a room when in fact the tenant is renting the house-otherwise the tenant wouldn't pay over the odds for the 'room').
Click to expand...

Yes, I was just having a stab in the dark, I've no idea what the rent-a-room rate would be, so I would have to check assuming this was even a viable option, but Im inclined to think that renting the apartment is the way to go; just hand everything over to a management company to look after while I enjoy a beer on a beach on a Thai island :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top