IT article: "State spending has soared by 1/3rd since 2016 with little discernible benefit"

We'll maybe the 50 days of committee deciding on it, and adding in layers of excessively complicated administrative procedure
Click to expand...
The committee element is part of the democratic process.

Big downside with living in a democracy is that every Muppet and it's mother has a say.

Mission creep is normal.

Suppose the relevant minister decided it would be desirable that we construct a new pets hospital.
That strangely is the easy part.

The fun starts when the interested parties get invited to make submissions.
When everyone is heard and accommodated the new pets hospital will have a surgical unit for woolly mammoths just incase Jurassic world turns out to be true.
 
No idea what mammoths have to do with it.

Look at the Arts council project. That's what this leads to. I wonder how many meetings they had on that one.
 
No idea what mammoths have to do with it.
Click to expand...
Its an analogy, when people start adding "nice to have" (depending on point of view) items to a simple project.

Look at the Arts council project. That's what this leads to. I wonder how many meetings they had on that one.
Click to expand...
Case in point
Good initial concept/idea.
Plan to make it all singing and dancing.........
 
BlackandBlue said:
Wrong order, this is part of the reason why the issues persists.

Correct order is standardize, streamline then automate if possible.
Click to expand...
Not in my experience. I find it better to remove unnecessary processes and tasks before the rest is standardised. Then the processes which can be automated are identified but it's more of a gant chart than a linear process.

BlackandBlue said:
Biggest problem is bespoke systems.
Hideously expensive in the long run but loved by tech companies as they have you for ever with tech support and upgrades.
Click to expand...
Absolutely; buy an off the shelf package, for HR, Wages, etc, and then adjust your practices and processes to work within that package. That's what organisations which are open to real competition do.
 
Look at all the council buildings, mostly all architect designed the "Aras an chontae" buildings in county towns mostly built in last 20 years since celtic tiger, all stainless steel and glass with canteens probably serving loads of different cuisines. However alot of the staff not even there every day but working from home. From what I can gather slot of government buildings and offices are basically empty now on Fridays
 
arbitron said:
Brendan Howlin is always entertaining even though he can be a bit left of centre for my taste.
Click to expand...
Poor Brendan, I thought he was retired and minding his own business!
arbitron said:
The obvious thing that you never hear lefties say is that people just need to stop getting sick.
Click to expand...
It would be nice if the healthcare sector did actually concentrate more on healthcare instead of sick care; prevention rather than cure.

That said, good post. Health outcomes are getting better but I do think that the prevention side, reduced alcohol consumption, exercise, diet etc is a big part of that, as is the closure of small hospitals around the country and the establishment of centres of excellence.
 
BIG-notorious said:
It varies by Department and office in fairness but the one I'm working in accommodates people from 3 different departments and is rarely at even 50% capacity.
Click to expand...
Wow.
That's shocking.
I hope there are break clauses in the leases but yes, political clientism is alive and well in this country. It would be great to see journalists highlight this rather than puff pieces about frivolous nonsense.
 
BIG-notorious said:
The rest of the public sector is probably st least as much. With obvious massive overcapacity due to blended working that rent bill should be trending towards zero over the next 5-10 years.
Click to expand...
But if they were to get serious about reducing office space due to only 50% capacity then that means shared desks, there probably be a hissy fit about that , hygiene OTT and the rest , they probably want a deep clean after every work day, of course provided by a private sector contractor working unsociable hours to fulfill ?
 
I find it better to remove unnecessary processes and tasks before the rest is standardized
Click to expand...
I would have to disagree here.

In a large organisation you will have "team norms".
This can be a problem for many reasons.

There is a concept called "work as imagined vs work as done."

Most managers are in the first category while many workers are in the latter.

You cannot fix/improve things if both parties have a totally different view point as to what is actually been done and how to actually do it in practice.

Often "imposed solutions" (top down) fail simply because the relevant authority (Government/Manager/Supervisor) hadn't a clue and was following the MBA playbook.


And people say they want more and bigger government.
Click to expand...

Slight correction needed.
People want more and more services provided, while expecting the magic money tree to cover the cost.

Its the squaring of this circle that causes problems.

Unrealistic expectations when resources are finite.
Over promising by politicians who are trying to satisfy all "their" electorate while not pissing off too much the rest.
 
A LEAN programme would never impose a top down solution. It asks simple questions, maps processes (real processes, what the theory states is irrelevant), removed unnecessary and non value added processes, reduces or reallocates headcount and then automates where desirable.
 
BlackandBlue said:
Slight correction needed.
People want more and more services provided, while expecting the magic money tree to cover the cost.
Click to expand...
I don't. I want the State to do the least possible for me as I can do many things better and cheaper for myself.
 
I don't. I want the State to do the least possible for me as I can do many things better and cheaper for myself
Click to expand...
Roads
An Garda
Hospitals
Schools
Etc
All are services provided by the state.
 
BlackandBlue said:
Roads
An Garda
Hospitals
Schools
Etc
All are services provided by the state.
Click to expand...
Correct.
What's your point?


I don't want the State to take €200 a month from me in taxes and then give it back to me, less their administration charge, and call it Child Benefit.
I don't want the State to do the same thing for Crèche fees.
I don't want the State to do the same thing for GP fees for my children.
I want the State to tax me in order to provide services to people who can't afford to pay for them themselves. If they are taxing me to provide things that I can pay for myself then it is costing me more because the State is inefficient.

I want the State to provide security, education and infrastructure and otherwise be as small and unobtrusive as possible while still looking after those who cannot look after themselves.

I don't want the State to be my Mammy. I have one of those.
 
BlackandBlue said:
Roads
An Garda
Hospitals
Schools
Etc
All are services provided by the state.
Click to expand...
Purple said:
Correct.
What's your point?
Click to expand...
+1

In my experience, all those services work well when government (in the form of politicians and their henchmen) get out of the way and let the service providers do what they're paid to do, but more often than not, they pile in and damage every thing they touch.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register