Hi - I agree, I don't think it should treated differently, maybe I should have been clearer about that. I just think the rate of tax is very high on top of dividend witholding tax that is already taken (15%).
I think the higher rate of tax in general is very high given what we get in return for it.
Also practically everyone whether they like it or not is an investor through their pension. In Ireland either you have the option to invest yourself, or through a pension fund which will return about 6% yearly. So it is the fund managers that pocket anything above that, including dividends. If you do it yourself, you'll pay it in taxes and we know who that benefits at the end of the day.. I agree with what you're saying - the tax system in general (deliberately or not), doesn't benefit the ordinary joe as far as I can see