N
Hey WHiskey,
I will have to disagree with your analysis.
While it appears to make sense, upoin analysis it is flawed.
Firstly - you are making a direct comparison between daytrading and buy-and-hold by using a nominal 20% gain.
Daytraders and position tradres(i.e. holding a position for a week or 2 or so) make money on volatility - not on long term gains.
SO - using your example above - lets say it rose 20% from one end of teh year to the next.
In this scenario the buy-and-old merchant will make 20%.
So - lets say for arguments sake that thos asset started at 100 and ended at 120 on year end.
Howver - it is quite possible that during the year it couild have risen to 150 - then dropped to 50 - risen to 140 - dropped to 60 - and eventually risen to 120.
The daytrader will attempt to make money from all these swings.
What you were doing is only looking at the start and end price and calculated the average daily gain to see what a daytrader would have made.
But as i say - it is the volatility where the day trader hopes to make his gains.
The buy-and-hold merchant on the other hand only compares the start price to the end price and ignores the volatility in between.
Good point.
Yep, clearly the price of most shares does not rise in a straight line on a graph with time, there are spikes. However, the volitility can work both ways, sometimes a share will rise a lot in a short space of time enabling a quick profit for the day trader, but at other times the share will fall a lot in a short space of time, making for big losses.
Trying to predict short term volitility which results in a sudden rise in a share price is surely difficult. Nobody knows the future. At any given time, the probability of an upward spike in a share price is probably little greater than the probability of a downward spike in a share price. Volitility can hurt a day trader as often as it benefits him/her.
OK, this is my last post on this topic, I'm not really qualified enough in this area !
I agree, Today i held of buying some irish bank stock believing that the stock was on the way down and twice i was incorect, the stock rallied and i missed the trades, But i believe tommorow has more opportunitys so roll on.Good point.
Yep, clearly the price of most shares does not rise in a straight line on a graph with time, there are spikes. However, the volitility can work both ways, sometimes a share will rise a lot in a short space of time enabling a quick profit for the day trader, but at other times the share will fall a lot in a short space of time, making for big losses.
Trying to predict short term volitility which results in a sudden rise in a share price is surely difficult. Nobody knows the future. At any given time, the probability of an upward spike in a share price is probably little greater than the probability of a downward spike in a share price. Volitility can hurt a day trader as often as it benefits him/her.
OK, this is my last post on this topic, I'm not really qualified enough in this area !
Hello NZT, I decided to short with the airlines and made some profit, How are you getting on with your trading.Hi T69,
I hope you sold those bank shares before they dropped?
NZT
Hello NZT, I decided to short with the airlines and made some profit, How are you getting on with your trading.
markets are v messy at the moment. if the dow undercuts its january low then we are in a very big drop, all over the world
Not neccessarly - markets are controlled - any down move will be followed by an up move - the problem is that you can't tell what they will do for too far out - this is why they are the experts who make the big money and the public is the public who make small money - or lose most of their money.
It is a game of odds - play the odds and you can partake in the game - listen to what you want tohear and you will probably get screwed - I bet this sounds familiar to a lot of people - some things never change in life unless one takes it upon onself to change oneslf - it is the only way to make progress!
markets are controlled - any down move will be followed by an up move - this is a rubbish statement, totally untrue
if the dow drops 1000 points in one day, there is no guarantee whatsoever that it will rise the next day. the up moves when they do arrive could be far less than the preceding down moves
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?