Business, not just farming.There is the favoured nephew/niece scheme in agriculture
I think revenue say not many people are impacted by inheritance tax in Ireland in any given year, so is it a big deal?
Neither person will pay any inheritance tax. It is one of the most bizarre logical flaws that pervades society that CAT is at all an issue for a person who doesn’t pay it. Do you get extremely exercised by the marginal income tax rate of a shop owner when you buy something?There is no equality of treatment in this.
Beyond the financial side. There is also the ‘equality’ side. Is it desirable in society for some people to receive large untaxed sums for no reason. When people have to compete with their peers for finite resources (eg housing). I’d see it as highly undesirable for society.Exchequer took in €850 million last year.
That’s a great argument for wealth tax (AKA property tax) but a lousy argument against changing inheritance tax.Say two people, one with children and wealth accumulated largely through increased property prices, wealth accumulation that has never been taxed, and this wealth can be passed almost tax free to younger generation the while another with no children and wealth accumulated through taxed work but this wealth will be further heavily taxed when passed to anyone. There is no equality of treatment in this.
Is it desirable in society for some people to receive large untaxed sums for no reason.
I’d have thought the number of children who meaningfully contribute to the wealth of their parents is tiny. If they have (through family business etc.) they should be appropriately compensated through income or equity.Not sure that they are receiving it for no reason.
A fair personal preference. I value a meritocracy in society extremely highly but that’s subjective.But I would not introduce a tax which does not raise much money just for equality.
I’m going to benefit from inheritances from by parents, as will my partner from her father. It will be life changing amounts of money. I think it would be appalling if it wasn’t taxed.
why should a non-parent not be allowed give a gift or leave an inheritance to someone of their choice, with the same tax consequences ?
The tax consequences are the same for parent and non-parent, that has been pointed out on a number of occasions in this thread already.
if a parent wishes to give their child a present of a house deposit of say €400K, the parent gives a present of €400K
If a non-parent wishes to give someone a present of house deposit of €400K, they will have to give them almost €600K to achieve the same result
TouchéI'd be more than happy to pay 66% tax on it
And if a parent wants to give someone else's child a present of a house deposit of €400K, they will have to give them almost €600K, exactly the same as the non-parent.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?