A vote for an Independent is a vote for parish pump politics

Yeah, I know one in a town north of me just like that as well, had the gym and everything but priced itself out of the local business.
 
Yeah, looking at the 'Independent' candidates standing in my constituency, only one was even vaguely the old school parish pump type, and actually mentioned a lot of country wide issues in their flier - the rest were the far right 'agenda' type.
 
Looks like the two Healy-Rae’s are showing the political parties and Micheal Martin how it’s done.
 
Looks like the two Healy-Rae’s are showing the political parties and Micheal Martin how it’s done.
Absolutely. But how what’s done?
Thankfully the majority of the population aren’t as selfish and myopic as the people who vote for the Healy-Rae’s and choose to vote for candidates who will legislate in the national interest. If we had a parliament full of Healy-Rae types the country would implode.
 
choose to vote for candidates who will legislate in the national interest.
My loan independent candidate always supports the government. They don't much care who is in government, they thinks it's in the national interest to support the government, we need stable government, and they also believe it magnifies their own influence.

This could be Seán Canney, Noel Grealish, Marian Harkin, or Michael Lowry, and possibly a few others.
 
An article on RTE on Independents.

As Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael are considered likely to go into government together, the question is whether they will form a coalition with smaller parties or a block of Independents.

 
The fact that the hotels only took up this business because they couldn't make a go at it in the tourist industry is beside the point.
It's not that simple, if you are serving normal tourism and domestic hospitality you have to compete and provide value for money, you need to have your premises looking nice and fresh. That all takes money and effort.
When the government comes in with a guaranteed revenue stream all year round , when you just need to maintain basic facilities well then its a no brainer you take the government money.
It's not about hotels not being able to run a business it is really about big government with huge resources distorting the whole hospitality market. I'm not saying that they shouldn't have done it but no other country bought up the stock of hotel rooms like irish government did. They just took the easiest option
 
Gavan Reilly of VM News reporting on Twitter, a group of Independents some of whom had connections to the 2016 Independent Alliance, have formed a grouping.

The new Dáil has its first technical group - behold the new(-ish) ‘Regional Group’:

Sean Canney TD
Marian Harkin TD
Barry Heneghan TD
Noel Grealish TD
Michael Lowry TD
Kevin (Boxer) Moran TD
Verona Murphy TD
Gillian Toole TD

 
I wonder are they forming a formal grouping to prepare for coalition ? It would seem to be more stable (or have that appearance anyway) - rather than a motley crew of independents with their separate shopping lists in return for supporting FF/FG.

The stability would come from individuals in the group not withdrawing support in a year or two - any withdrawals would be the whole group, so less likely to happen than any solo exiting by disgruntled Independents.
 
A formal grouping would also increase their speaking rights in the Dail
 
If we did proper local government here then almost all Independents would be sitting where they belong i.e. in their local government authority.
The lack of empowerment for local authorities is why we end up with Independents in our national parliament.
 
Initially independents were all about their own constituency issues but that is no longer the case, they are basically voicing rural and Conservative issues that have been abandoned by the mainstream parties. Its obvious that the big parties have moved to the centre left ,as mattie mcgrath said I didn't leave fianna fail, fianna fail left me. Also they are vehemently opposed to the green agenda stuff so want to push back against some of that. In other European countries they have Conservative and even hard right parties, we don't have that, the independents are the closest to that we have now
 
That explains a chunk of the Aontu vote as well.

In fairness to Michael Healy Rae, he was very impressive when RTE spoke to him at the count centre last weekend, certainly far more so then the likes of mumbling John McGuiness or the Shinners talking "change" to cover up the lost of 120000 votes. "Sophisticated" people think he is a gombeen but he is a successful millionaire business man and I'd have happily given him my number 1 if I lived down there based on how he spoke and the passion he had.
 
I vote for a government personally (not an opposition) hence why I would never vote for an Indo and agree with the OP that it's a wasted vote.

Isn't the real problem with our system that there is no viable alternative government?
I really don't believe the guff about 'the parties of the left'. The people who vote LP/SD/GP would far rather see their parties coalesce with FF/FG than with SF. Look at transfer patterns to confirm this.
 
I really don't believe the guff about 'the parties of the left'.
I don't know how FF and FG could be described as anything other than parties of the left. They are socially liberal and have massively increased spending, particularly on welfare, over the last decade. If you are to the left of them they you are heading into Marxist/communist territory.
 
That's hardly an Irish-only phenomenon though is it? Fiscal discipline seems a thing of the past (unless you're Swiss).
 
Yeah, I know one in a town north of me just like that as well, had the gym and everything but priced itself out of the local business.
Which is why its so frustrating that this is commonly projected as a problem solely connected to immigration. Its clear that there are real viability issues in the hospitality sector that need a proper discussion, and adding this only diffuses the very real problems with the sector (particularly those originating in families/companies/individuals still unravelling high borrowings from tiger era unsuccessful investments).