Holidaying in Portugal after the abduction

G

gramlab

Registered User
Messages
234
Heading to portugal on sunday for 2 weeks with 2 1/2 year old girl. A lot of people have asked me if I thought about possibly cancelling, taking extra precautions, not leaving my little girl out of my sight etc.

She is blonde and the portugeese have a thing about giving more attention to blonde children as they think "blonde" is lucky. She got a lot of attention last year when we were there. I would never leave her on her own anyway, but would anyone actually cancel a holiday or do anything different because of the Madeline abduction??
 
It would not deter me. This case seems to have caused mass hysteria. I've heard my neighbours talking of cancelling visits to France, Spain and Italy based on the fear this case has introduced.

If you take the normal precautions, like not leaving her alone for instance, then there should be no problem.
 
Driving past the Deerpark playground in Mount Merrion yesterday I noticed a woman who had parked her car partly on the footpath and within yards of the roundabout. Her car was partly blocked by a 4 x 4 that was parked in front of her. The woman was standing on the footpath side of the car while she allowed her son who couldn't have been more than 4 years of age climb out of the car on the roadside. It would have only taken a split second for that child to be killed by a passing car, a careless moment. How many people do things like that - don't insist that their children put on their seat belts, push the buggy on to the roadway while they stand on the footpath waiting to cross the road, leave kids in the car unattended etc. Are these people just plain stupid, thick away with the fairies, or lazy?
 
I feel sorry for Madelaine's parents being a parent myself - but everyone seems to have forgotten that they left 3 children under the age of 4 alone in an apartment - hardly makes them parents of the year, even if they are doctors! Don't think tying a yellow ribbon in their hometown makes up for the previous neglect on their part.
 
I wouldn't cancel my holiday...if anything Portugal must be the safest place at the moment with all the attention it's getting.
 
I think people have great difficulty in assessing the difference between real risk (as in the ParkLane's example regarding traffic dangers) and what is frankly mass hysteria.

We're off to Disney World in Florida this summer. We've had more than one person tell us to be extra vigilent whilst there, because of all the child abductions (and this was before this latest case happened). It struck me as rather odd: how could Disney put up with that? I did some research, and in the more than 30 years the place has been open, and the tens of millions of visitors it's had, the total number of child abductions is: none.

I'd never leave such young children in an apartnment by themselves, no matter how close I was. However, the reason is not that I'd be worried some stranger would come and take them, but that they might wake and terrify themselves when nobody answered, or that they wandered out and were hit by a car, or any number of accidents that can and do happen.

Having said that, I'd be very slow to judge anyone in that circumstance, as we've all done things we shouldn't have in retrospect. They'e also certainly paying for their mistake now.

Think about it: how many millions of people have travelled to Portugal, Spain, Italy and so on over say the past 10 years? How many child abductions from that group of people? It's so rare, it really doesn't deserve any real concern (as against the kinds of stuff that does happen: drownings, road traffic accidents, general accidents etc. etc.)

The problem of course is that by generating a climate of fear and mistrust that in itself has an adverse effect on children growing up. It's a sad world and getting sadder with each new case of media hype.
 
ACA said:
everyone seems to have forgotten that they left 3 children under the age of 4 alone in an apartment - hardly makes them parents of the year
Click to expand...

Couldnt agree more. Yesterday I was in Albert Park in Dublin with my girlfriend. We were just out for a walk after an exam. Beside the playground we saw a little girl... very very young, maybe 3 or so bellowing "daddy" and crying. She was walking away from the playground - and started walking around the park looking for her daddy. Other parents in the playground did'nt even bat an eyelid. The kid was tramatised and completely lost. We watched for about 10min from a small distance because we felt it wrong to leave the child alone - however, whilst we did approach the child and ask where daddy was (didnt answer), we didnt go any furture as some parents would lambast you for approaching their child. Anyways after about 10-15min the father emerged from the far side of brush and hedge - he had been playing tennis...

We were absolutely disgusted. He doesnt deserve to be a father. The poor child was left unattended for far too long...
 
I firmly believe that there are some people that should be actually vetted out before they are allowed to have kids, some people have no commitment to the responsibility.
Look at the women in the UK a few weeks ago that filmed the kids bashing each other and egged them on.

If in Ireland a parent left 3 children alone in a house and one got abducted, the social services would be stepping in immediately to care for the others, so how come this is not the case here?

They are 2 very highly intelligent people judging by their professions and while my heart aches for them and what they are going through quite simply I have to ask: What were they thinking?
There were 2 other children there, what if they had been unfortunate enough to be abducted aswell.
the mind boggles!
 
I'm not condoning what they did. I'm sure they themselves are asking "what were we thinking?". I too think it was neglectful, I can see however how they got themselves into a pattern of false security. This feeling of - everyone eats late on the continent - we're in a family friendly resort - everyone is doing this etc. they got themselves into a pattern of thinking this was safe. It was neglectful, but I can see how it wasn't intentional and also how it can happen to 2 well educated, well meaning people. As ang1170 said, we've all done things we wouldn't in retrospect. I'm sure they are now asking themselves "what were we thinking". I'm sure they'd happily submit to a lengthy social services investigation rather than losing their daughter. It was a mistake, a terrible mistake.

Unfortunately Madeline paid the price.
 
Good post, Casiopea. I'm bringing my family on holiday to Portugal this year and this unfortunate and sad case does not alter our plans in any way. Children are at risk wherever they are (in the family home at home, or abroad) if parents or guardians are negligent.
 
I don't know about going to Portugal but you better get out of Ireland... there was a murder last week !!!
 
Guy working with me told me this morning that his brother was in Albufeira last week with his 3 year old girl (who he says might have a very slight resemblence to Madeline) and over the course of the week a few people had asked his daughter if he was her daddy. Said he was a bit annoyed that someone might think he was paedophile or whatever but he could understand why they were asking.
(He is a bit of a storyteller so not sure how true this is)

Looking forward to my holiday and cant see myself doing anything differenty because of what happened, but each to their own I say.

Just hope the blanket media coverage has not made things worse for the poor child.
 
On the one hand Madeleines' parents have my sympathy. On the other hand I can't help thinking that if this had happened to someone from a different socio economic background that there would have been more of an outcry.

I've heard of hotels in Ireland and abroad offering baby-listening services which vary from a kind of a baby monitor through the hotel bedroom to members of staff listening at doors on a rota! Even apart from this I''ve heard of people putting a baby monitor in the room and bringing the receiver down to the restaurant with them in the hotel.

Call me paranoid but far before Madeleine I would never have left my children alone in these circumstances. When we went to Menorca the year before last our apartment was on the ground floor just next to the swimming pool. Our toddler was still taking 2 hour naps in the middle of the day then and I wouldnt even sit outside the french doors even with all other doors and windows locked. It was for a variety of reasons- if she woke up and I didnt hear her, or she couldnt see me but also it did occur to me that someone might come into the apartment.

It won't stop our annual holiday this year, won't alter it except I might be even more wary, but as I would never leave either of them alone anyway...

I think many parents are afraid or reluctant to criticise Madeleines' parents because we are very conscious that nobody is perfect. There are potential hazards everywhere for our children. You make a cup of coffee and turn your back for a second, or you leave a pair of scissors or a knife within reach- these things can happen to anyone. God knows I'm far from perfect and that is why I think we all have a touch of ' people in glass houses..'
 
Last edited:
CGorman said:
Couldnt agree more. Yesterday I was in Albert Park in Dublin with my girlfriend. We were just out for a walk after an exam. Beside the playground we saw a little girl... very very young, maybe 3 or so bellowing "daddy" and crying. She was walking away from the playground - and started walking around the park looking for her daddy. Other parents in the playground did'nt even bat an eyelid. The kid was tramatised and completely lost. We watched for about 10min from a small distance because we felt it wrong to leave the child alone - however, whilst we did approach the child and ask where daddy was (didnt answer), we didnt go any furture as some parents would lambast you for approaching their child. Anyways after about 10-15min the father emerged from the far side of brush and hedge - he had been playing tennis...

We were absolutely disgusted. He doesnt deserve to be a father. The poor child was left unattended for far too long...
Click to expand...

hi cgorman...

you must have serious self-control. I would loose the plot alltogether. seriously. I would have said it, i would have f*!ked all round me and had my say, despite his reaction.
some people dont deserve their kids, and some people have to fight nail & tooth to get an hour evey week!

tiz a funny world.....
 
It would not deter me - does it mean that because you are going to go there that you will be more vigilant than you should be anyway with children!

Desite that anyway, its probably the safest time to go to Portugal - with all the police presence!

,
 
I agree with the earlier post about mass hysteria. We were nearby (Lagos) during the week of the child's disappearance and are returning in September with our c. 2 year old. This incident would not deter us or cause us any major concern.
 
I agree they shouldnt have left their kids alone. If you go to a bar in Spain or Portugal you will find the locals can bring their babies with them. Lots would have their babies with them snuggled and wrapped up sleeping in a buggy in a bar or restaurant at 2 am . It's a very family friendly place.
 
I agree and disagree with a lot of posts here on this and have my own opinions aswell which I've posted.

Regardless of what our opinions are of the parents and what they done the upshot of all of this is that a little defenceless girl is somewhere in the world without her mam and dad. She was unlawfully taken and no one knows how she is being treated, is she being fed, looked after and I hate to even think of what worse things are going on.

At this stage whats done is done and it is wasted energy talking about the parents and what we all would have done in the circumstances.

I think everyone at this stage should focus their energy on hoping and praying that Madeline gets returned safely to her family, unharmed and hopefully that she has not experienced too much trauma.
At this stage I think everyone would just like closure on it. I know I do!
 
ci1 said:
She was unlawfully taken
Click to expand...
Allegedly. There is nothing other than circumstantial evidence to support that hypothesis.
I think everyone at this stage should focus their energy on hoping and praying that Madeline gets returned safely to her family, unharmed and hopefully that she has not experienced too much trauma.
Click to expand...
I agree with the sentiment but would question the efficacy of hopes and prayers in securing a positive outcome...
 
ClubMan said:
Allegedly. There is nothing other than circumstantial evidence to support that hypothesis.

I agree with the sentiment but would question the efficacy of hopes and prayers in securing a positive outcome...
Click to expand...

As well as hoping and praying, you can also download an ePoster from www.findmadeline.com and put it up in public places. You can also contribute to the fund to aid find her on that site.

And if you or anyone you know has been holidaying in the area you should upload your holiday photos (scenes with other people in the background) to [broken link removed]
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top