Brouhahaha
Registered User
- Messages
- 184
Hi,
I am a PAYE employee who has to file a form 11 tax return due to being director of a non-trading company. I file the form 11s with zero returns (other than PAYE) to reflect this.
I applied for rebate of some health expenses for 2010 and was informed revenue didn't have a form 11 registered for 2010 so I (re)filed it with the health expenses included.
Rather than refund the health expenses they have calculated I have a €44 liability and are applying a late filing fee of about €1000.
I'm not sure how:
a) I am liable €44 after all income went through PAYE (multi-national employer) and a tax rebate was applied for - but obviously not concerned by this now
b) I somehow owe €1000 surcharge when I am tax compliant bar revenue not having a return on file. If the surcharge is meant to be 10% of tax liability and my tax (bar this €44 liability) has been payed through PAYE how can the €1000 surcharge be justified?
What are my chances of a written appeal of this surcharge being successful?
Thanks in advance,
B.
I am a PAYE employee who has to file a form 11 tax return due to being director of a non-trading company. I file the form 11s with zero returns (other than PAYE) to reflect this.
I applied for rebate of some health expenses for 2010 and was informed revenue didn't have a form 11 registered for 2010 so I (re)filed it with the health expenses included.
Rather than refund the health expenses they have calculated I have a €44 liability and are applying a late filing fee of about €1000.
I'm not sure how:
a) I am liable €44 after all income went through PAYE (multi-national employer) and a tax rebate was applied for - but obviously not concerned by this now
b) I somehow owe €1000 surcharge when I am tax compliant bar revenue not having a return on file. If the surcharge is meant to be 10% of tax liability and my tax (bar this €44 liability) has been payed through PAYE how can the €1000 surcharge be justified?
What are my chances of a written appeal of this surcharge being successful?
Thanks in advance,
B.