why do churches have spires? What are the "vents" on the side for?

M

markowitzman

Registered User
Messages
936
was walking by a cathedral today and the thought hit me as to why do churches have spires?
Seems a complete waste in view that they seem so complicated to build and probably took so long to build centuries ago.
What are the "vents" on the side for?
Why did the folks just stick a standard roof on the church or am I missing something?
 
Re: church spires

AFAIK they are symbols of prayer ie pointing to heaven?

Also I guess practically they help people locate the building?
 
Re: church spires

Ever wonder why so many churches were built here during the famine?
 
Re: church spires

Some of them do have a practical purpose. They hold peals of bells.

They're good sites to rent out for concealed mobile phone aerials hidden behind the vents.
 
Re: church spires

I suspect it is partially prosaic realism, big church dominating the surrounding. The spire I think also frequently doubled as a bell-tower, higher up they are, the better the range they are audible over.

Post crossed with General Zod ... oops :)
 
Re: church spires

markowitzman said:
Seems a complete waste in view that they seem so complicated to build and probably took so long to build centuries ago.
Why did the folks just stick a standard roof on the church or am I missing something?
Click to expand...

Does everything have to be so practical?

I'm not overly bothered with what goes on beneath the spire, but I think most churches are beautifully designed and a pleasure to look at. For me that's reason enough.
 
Re: church spires

Times have changed for spires.

'Ritchie calls the Dublin Spire an "act of urbanism," that is, it's a landmark, an orientation point, a meeting place, and a vertical exclamation mark in a city that is still largely horizontal (ed: da drink!?) ..... it also evokes the "new" Ireland.'

Another blurb reads:
'What does the Dublin Spire mean? Whatever you want. There is no writing, no iconography, no overt symbolism. This spire is not a sign.'

Personally I find this sort of gobbledegook to be not in the least bit inspiring. (sorry bad pun!)
 
Re: church spires

Jack The Lad said:
Does everything have to be so practical?

I'm not overly bothered with what goes on beneath the spire, but I think most churches are beautifully designed and a pleasure to look at. For me that's reason enough.
Click to expand...

Hear, hear. For practical buildings look at communist countries. I find churches to be amongst the best visits when I am abroad on holidays - churches of any religion.
 
Re: church spires

ClubMan said:
Have you not noticed any of the many monstrosities that were built particularly from the 1950s onwards?
Click to expand...


Alot of them look like they landed from outer space, very ugly.
I heard on the radio today that Limerick Cathderal has the highest spire in Ireland. Go Limerick:D
 
Re: church spires

Monasteries and churches would tend to have differnet design anyway, with the monastery having to be practical in that it houses people.
 
Re: church spires

MrMan said:
Monasteries and churches would tend to have differnet design anyway, with the monastery having to be practical in that it houses people.
Click to expand...


Monasteries? Do you misread "any of the many monstrosities" ? :)

I agree some of the more modern churches really are as ugly as sin.
I suspect those commissioning the churches got caught up in the modernist architecture movement and probably fell for
the gobbledegook (new approach to people & spaces) they heard from (secular?) architects.
 
Re: church spires

Have you noticed that a lot of catholic churches are built on the highest parts of towns and villages, they competed with the protestant churches,
always aiming to be higher, protestant churches tend to be in quieter leafy areas of town. However, attending the occasional christening or funeral some of the more modern 'ugly' churches do surprisingly contain some beautiful stain glass work
 
Re: church spires

yes as per your pic General Zod..........vents (surely this is not their real name!?)
still unsure of function or role of spire?
this cathedral was built in famine times and I just question why they spent money in this way when locals dropping like flies....
that said local church looking for "donations" for new spire.......has much changed?
 
Re: church spires

Here's the dictionary definition of the noun vent.

1. an opening, as in a wall, serving as an outlet for air, smoke, fumes, or the like
Click to expand...

Looks like the most appropriate term to me.

Which church are you talking about? Or would that be revealing too much? ;)
 
Re: church spires

http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/167266 That does look big, relative to the rest of it.

Externally built between 1828 - 1831, excluding the spire which was added in 1853. Local crop failures in the preceding decade and in 1830 and 1831 but before the main potato famine 1845 - 1851. 1892.

Adding the spires later seems to be common. It would certainly be a lower key building without it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top